Based on 74 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
13302 Palm Beach Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33905
Phone: (239) 362-2086
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Colt Green
If you saw this restaurant before when it was Sir Pizza, you’d think the owners had the power to resurrect the dead. They have completely transformed a dingy, run-down failure of a restaurant into a vibrant, casual, counter-serve pizza experience that is second to none. The staff is friendly and cheerful and cares about service and making you great food in a timely manner. Speaking of the food! The NY style crust is crispy on the outside and has a great chew inside. We particularly enjoyed the Mediterranean pizza which featured fresh toppings that were perfectly proportioned. Our kids enjoyed the classic cheese pizza. All-in-all, great experience, and we’ll be back soon!
… more
Jackie S
I was originally going to give it four stars due to the crust being a tad too thin to hold the toppings but the flavor really is there! Good pizza and would go again.
… more
Eric stone
Third time I’ve been to this establishment. First time with new name thought maybe there was new owners. Thought maybe the food was better. Thought maybe the food would be better.
… more
Victor Almodovar
I have been literally looking for some authentic New York Style Pizza for months now. I’ve tried all kinds of places. I finally found it. Palm Beach Pizza. They have made me so happy. I highly, highly recommend it. They have so many options but the plain cheese was the food for my soul. If your looking for good pizza, awesome staff and cleanliness, this is the place you wanna go to.
… more
Aubrey B
Great pizza; their classic crust is delicious and they load it up with pepperoni. Definitely recommend trying!
… more
Bryce M
The pizza is one of the better pizzas I’ve had in the area. They underpromised and over delivered on the time the pizza was supposed to be done. Love you our system of alerting me during the entire process from start to finish of my pizza. The current issue is the hours. I’ve been by at 6:00 and the restaurant has been closed. What’s going on? You’ve got a great business but you need to be open. I’m giving a 5 star because you deserve it.
… more
Kevin Johnson
Pizza was great. Loved sauce, crust, and sausage crumbles. Staff were very friendly and provided fast service. Will go often
… more
jade Rodriguez
I placed an order for pick up and it was ready within 10 minutes sub was amazing! Pizza was awesome aswell will be placing more orders in the future
… more
Stephany Stephenson
We ordered a large pepperoni & sausage and cheesy garlic bread. Our first pizza came out with a hole, so the young men made another one. While we waited, less than 15 min, we had the pleasure of chatting with Aiden. Aiden is a spectacular young man! He has nothing but great things to say about the people he works for and with. He was so passionate about the pizza and the products they offered. We even found out that the main location in Babcock Ranch has trivia nights and such.
… more
Nallely Almodovar
We just left PBP and I can honestly say it was everything we hoped for and more! My husband’s been on the hunt for some good New York style pizza and Palm Beach Pizza hit it out of the park for us! We had their knots and wings also and they were delicious as well! The star was definately the cheese pizza! The flavor in the crust and the sauce was perfect! The cheese was so yummy and stretchy and just what you want in a New York style pizza! PBP will definately be our go to pizza spot now!
… more
… View more