Pancho’s Cantina Menu – Island Park, NY

Type : Tex-Mex restaurant

Location : Island Park, NY

Colorful cafe with murals on the walls, crayons for the kids & familiar Tex-Mex dishes. Based on 438 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$

Pancho's Cantina 11558

Address:
4245 Austin Blvd, Island Park, NY 11558

Phone: (516) 897-8300

Website:

Social Profile:

Menu

Main
Spicy Queso Dip
Our mild queso mixed with spicy green chili sauce
$3.99
Mild Queso Dip
Melted cheese blended with roasted peppers
$3.99
Pancho’s Classic Guacamole
Made daily with fresh avocados
$9.99
Spicy Southwest Guacamole
With corn, black beans and a touch of jalapeño
$9.99
Tropical Guacamole
Blended with fresh mango salsa
$10.99
Drink Margaritas (New Mexico)
The St. Germain
A ‘skinny’ margarita of fresh squeezed lime juice, Herradura Silver tequila and St. Germain Elderberry liqueur
$11.00
The Milagro
Triple distilled Milagro Silver tequila with peach schnapps and blue curacao
$11.00
The Tropical Margarita
A super refreshing blend of 1800 Coconut tequila, pineapple juice and our homemade margarita mix
$8.50
The Tutti-Frutti Margarita
Chambord, Margaritaville Mango tequila & cranberry
$8.50
Skinny Margarita
La Puerta Negra Silver Tequila on the rocks with only fresh lime juice, a splash of Cointreau and agave nectar
$11.00
The Pomegranate
1800 Reposado & pomegranate liqueur
$10.00
Tres Gen Frozen Especial
Tres Generaciones Anejo and Gran Marnier atop our famous frozen
$12.50
No Pits About It
La Puerta Negra Silver and watermelon liqueur
$9.00
X–Rated Margarita
Blood orange, grapefruit, & passion flavors of X-Rated Fusion liqueur with Margaritaville Mango tequila
$9.00
Live Happier (New Mexico)
Herradura Dew
Midori Melon and Herradura Reposado
$10.00
Horni Margarita
Sauza Hornitos, triple sec & cranberry
$9.00
The Cabo Wabo
Cabo Anejo, fresh lime juice straight up with a touch of Gran Marnier
$12.00
Mango’ Rita
Margaritaville Mango tequila and mango puree
$9.00
Mango-Habanero Margarita
A sweet & spicy libation with fruity mango and chile habanero sauce
$9.00
Sangarita
Margaritaville Mango tequila combines with our homemade Red Sangria. A Pancho’s classic
$10.00
Fuzzy Margarita
Avion Reposado, Absolute Peach and peach syrup
$10.00
Gran Matador
1800 Reposado, Licor 43 & Gran Marnier
$10.00
Cabo Cantina
Straight from Cabo San Lucas. Cabo Wabo Silver, amaretto and cranberry
$9.50
Avion Anejo Cadillac Margarita
Super smooth & delicious. Avion Anejo served straight up with fresh lime juice and Cointreau
$12.50
Caliente Margarita
Tanteo Jalapeño tequila, margarita mix and agave nectar. A spicy sweet creation served on the rocks
$10.00
Panchos Classics (Texas)
Mexican Mamacita Punch
A refreshing libation of dark rum, Malibu Coconut, mango rum, a splash of Herradura Silver tequila & fruit juices
$9.00
Chocolate Martini
Godiva Chocolate liqueur makes ours great
$9.00
Mexicali Blue
Absolut Raspberri, blue curacao & lemonade
$8.00
Rocky Mountain Mudslide
A smooth creamy blend of Kahlua, Baileys and fresh milk (we swirl the glass with chocolate)
$9.00
The Pain Killer
Dark rum, cream of coconut, pineapple & OJ
$9.00
Bloody Caliente
Our homemade Bloody Mary with Stoli Jalapeño vodka
$8.50
Pancho’s “Sinkers”
Pineapple
Frozen lime margarita atop pineapple vodka
Strawberry & Cream
Strawberry frozen & whipped cream vodka
Teagarita
Sweet tea vodka & frozen margarita. A Santa Fe favorite
Mangos (Texas-1933)
Mango Lemonade
mango rum, lemonade, and a splash of cranberry
$8.00
Mango Colada
Creamy coconut and real mango frozen smooth with mango rum
$8.50
Mango’ Rita
Margaritaville Mango tequila and mango purée, shaken and served on the rocks
$9.00
Beer (Colorado)
Monkey Fist IPA
Pacifico
Blue Moon
Amstel
Budweiser
XX Amber Or Lager
Sol
Modelo Especial
Blue Point Toasted Lager
Heineken
Coors Light
O’Douls (Non Alcoholic)
Michelob Ultra (Low Carb)
Negra Modelo
Corona
Corona Light
Loaded Cabo Corona
Loaded Cabo Corona
A California Favorite! We ‘load’ the neck of your Corona with Cabo Silver Tequila
$9.00
Sangria (New Mexico USA)
Red, White, Or Peach $9.00
Wine (California)
Cabernet
Merlot
Sauvignon Blanc
Pinot Grigio
White Zinfandel
Chardonnay
Tequila (Arizona)
Tequila And Flights
Ask about our Tequila selection and Flights Menu
Nacho Bar (New York)
Sour Cream
Olives
Onions
Cilantro
Jalapeños
Fresh Tomatoes
Colorado Chili
+$1.50
Veggie Chili
+$1.50
Grilled Chicken
+$2
Spinach & Veggies
+$1.50
Guacamole
+$1.50
Refried Beans
+$0.75
Corn & Bean Relish
+$0.75
Black Beans
+$0.75
Portabella Mushrooms
+$1.50
Avocado Slices
+$1.50
Roasted Shrimp
+$3
Grilled Hanger Steak
+$2.50
Taco Truck Tacos (New Mexico)
Carne Asada
Sriracha slaw
Pork Carnitas
pineapple chipotle salsa
Crispy Catfish
cabbage & salsa fresca
Mexi Shrimp
salsa fresca
Chorizo Potato
creamy yogurt sauce
Chipotle Chicken
chipotle BBQ
Roasted Portabella
red peppers & pepper jack cheese
Quesadillas (Texas – The Lone Star State)
Just Cheese $7.99
Chorizo Potato $10.99
BBQ Skirt Steak $13.99
Cheddar & Mashed $8.99
Pork Carnitas $11.99
Avocado & Tomato $10.99
Spinach & Veggie $9.99
Grilled Chicken $12.99
Roasted Shrimp $13.99
Shredded Chicken $11.99
Portabella Mushroom $10.99
BBQ Beef $12.99
Cheese Burger Quesadilla
Ground beef, tomatoes, cheese, ketchup and pickles
$10.99
Buffalo Chicken
Your choice of grilled or breaded chicken
$13.99
The Cuban
With pulled pork, ham, pickles and yellow mustard in a habanero tortilla
$13.99
Starters (Arizona)
Chicken Wings (9)
Spicy Buffalo, Mild Grilled BBQ, Sweet Honey BBQ or Crispy Jorge’s
$12.99
Grilled Mini Burritos (2)
BBQ Beef & Mozzarella; Grilled Portabella, Roasted Red & Poblano Peppers (Vegetarian); Spicy Chicken & Roasted Corn
$7.99
Crispy Calamari
Classic, Honey BBQ or Spicy Buffalo
$12.99
Avocado Toast
Fresh avocado, diced tomatoes, pumpkin seeds, black bean & corn relish, cilantro and avocado oil
$7.99
Guacamole $9.99
Wing Ding Sampler
All 4 styles of wings 3 different dipping sauces
$17.99
Buffalo Sampler
Chicken Quesadillas, Wings, Calamari and Fingers. All Buffalo Style
$17.99
Tidbit Sampler
Grilled BBQ Wings, BBQ Rib Bits, Pork Carnitas Quesadilla, and BBQ Beef & Mozzarella Mini Burritos
$17.99
BBQ Baby Back Rib Bits $13.99
Chorizo Empanadas
Homemade with house ground chorizo, beef, sautéed onions, peppers and potatoes
$10.99
Cornbreaded Popcorn Shrimp
With our creamy garlic dipping sauce
$13.99
Jalapeño Poppers (6)
Crispy chile peppers stuffed with cheddar cheese
$9.99
Chicken Fingers (5)
Classic, Honey BBQ or Spicy Buffalo
$9.99
Buffalo Chicken Mini Wrap
Breaded or Grilled buffalo chicken rolled with blue cheese, celery, carrots and romaine lettuce in flour tortillas
$8.99
Salads (Texas)
Pancho’s Salad
Shredded lettuce, cheese, carrots, tomatoes & onions with our own Mexican vinaigrette
Baby Greens
With diced tomatoes, cheese and low fat chile ranch or thyme vinaigrette
Caesar Salad
Our slightly spicy version of the classic
Chili + Soup (Colorado)
Chihuahua Chicken Soup
Homemade chicken broth with avocado, tomato, onions and fresh cilantro
$4.99
Colorado Chili
cheese & sour cream
$7.99
Black Bean Soup
onions & sour cream
$5.99
Veggie Chili
with cheese
$7.99
Tortilla Soup
Our Version of the Mexican Staple
$5.99
Pancho’s Specialties (Nevada)
Bandito Burrito
Grilled chicken breast, black beans, cheese and spicy green chile sauce inside a large flour tortilla, sour cream & guacamole
$18.99
Grilled Vegetable Burrito
Fresh spinach, mushrooms and veggies with refried beans, salsa and cheese inside a spinach tortilla, sour cream & guacamole
$17.99
Pancho’s Classic Super Burrito
Shredded chicken or ground beef, refried or black beans, onions and cheese rolled in a flour tortilla topped with mild ranchero sauce or spicy green chile sauce, with sour cream and guacamole Or we’ll leave out the beans, fry yours golden and crispy and call it a “Chimichanga”!
$17.99
Colorado Enchiladas
Grilled chicken and fresh avocado inside soft flour tortillas topped with melted cheese and mild ranchera sauce, sprinkled with fresh cilantro
$19.99
Enchiladas Garcia
Grilled chicken & portabella mushrooms inside soft corn tortillas, topped with monterey jack and spicy green chile sauce
$19.99
Tacos Al Carbon
Try Yours In Lettuce Wraps. Grilled flour tortillas stuffed with either:
$19.99
Enchiladas Primo
BBQ skirt steak in soft flour tortillas smothered with mild ranchera & spicy green chile sauces and monterey jack cheese
$23.99
Spinach And Veggie Enchiladas
Corn tortillas filled with fresh spinach, mushrooms and assorted veggies, topped with mild ranchera sauce or classic ancho gravy, and melted cheese
$17.99
Enchiladas En Mole
Your choice of filling: Roasted Corn & Chicken or Pork Carnitas(or one of each); with a traditionally spicy sauce of chilies and chocolate, in soft corn tortillas topped with melted Monterey Jack cheese
$18.99
Chicken & Shrimp Jambalaya
Red rice cooked with fresh ground chorizo sausage, diced chorizo links, poblano chilies, boneless chicken, and tender shrimp; served with two side dishes
$23.99
Stick Chicken Ribs + BBQ (Wyoming)
Desperado’s Chicken
BBQ boneless breast topped with three melted cheeses
$19.99
Margarita Chicken
Strips of grilled chicken sautéed with garlic, sweet lime juice, triple sec & a hint of gold tequila
$18.99
Cheyenne Chicken Lettuce Wraps
Garlic & cilantro marinated breast slices with fresh avocado and sweet red pepper purée, drizzled with spicy chipotle bbq sauce
$19.99
Cowboy Combo
Half rack of baby back ribs paired with your choice of: Six Santa Fe Grilled or Corn Breaded Shrimp
$27.99
BBQ Chicken & Ribs Combo
Half rack of baby back ribs with your choice of white or dark meat chicken
$23.99
Spicy Poblano Chicken
Grilled boneless breast topped with fire-roasted poblanos, red peppers and portabellas finished with green chile sauce and melted cheese
$21.99
Baby Back Ribs
A full rack of the best ribs around
$27.99
Cattleman’s BBQ Skirt Steak
A house specialty: grilled and served sliced in our homemade garlic barbecue sauce. Make It Surf & Turf: We’ll add Four Cornbreaded or Santa Fe Grilled Shrimp
$27.99
Seafood (Rhode Island – Ocean State)
Santa Fe Grilled Shrimp
Succulent shrimp seasoned in our New Mexico style shallot & herb butter
$24.99
Cornbreaded Shrimp
With creamy garlic & spicy BBQ dipping sauces
$24.99
Shrimp Margarita
Sautéed with garlic, sweet lime juice, and a hint of gold tequila
$24.99
Mexicali Shrimp
Our version of a “mildly-spicy” classic Mexican dish. Shrimp sautéed in a garlic vegetable purée
$24.99
Shrimp Acapulco
Fried shrimp smothered in mild ranchera and spicy green chili sauces topped with melted monterey jack cheese
$25.99
Fresh Salmon Fillet
Barbecued
with Pancho’s homemade BBQ sauce
Yucatan Baked
with a lime-cilantro corn crumb topping
Roasted
with fresh spinach and veggies
Fish Fillet
Broiled Spicy Tortilla Crusted Tilapia
with mango salsa
Cajun-Spiced Catfish
broiled and topped with fresh tomato salsa
Yucatan Baked Catfish
with a lime-cilantro corn crumb topping
Southern Fried Catfish
crispy with fresh mango salsa
California Fish Tacos
Tortilla Crusted Tilapia
broiled with mango salsa
Baja Style Catfish
cornbreaded with fresh tomato salsa
Step One
Enchilada
Soft corn tortilla smothered with classic ancho gravy and melted cheese
Burrito
Flour tortilla, onions, salsa and cheese with or without refried or black beans inside. No sauce or cheese covers these burritos
Quesadilla
Toasted flour, whole wheat or corn tortilla stuffed with melted three cheese blend
Classic Hard Taco
Crisp corn tortilla shell, salsa, lettuce, tomato and cheese
Classic Soft Taco
Corn, flour or whole wheat tortilla with salsa, lettuce, tomato and cheese
Taco Grande
Any hard taco wrapped in any type of soft tortilla spread with refried beans
Classic Fillings
Seasoned Ground Beef
Grilled Chicken
Shredded Chicken
Chipotle Chicken
Three Cheese Blend
Chorizo & Potato
Fresh Spinach & Veggies
Premium Fillings
Portabella Mushroom
+$1
Roasted Chicken & Corn
+$1
Carne Asada
(+$1) seasoned hanger steak
Pork Carnitas
+$1
BBQ Beef
+$1
Fresh Avocado
+$1
Guacamole
+$1
BBQ Skirt Steak
+$3
Chile Rubbed Shrimp
+$3
Step Three
Refried Beans
BBQ Beans
Black Beans
BBQ Bean Salad
Black Bean & Corn Relish
Guacamole Or Avocado
+$1.99
Spanish Rice (Tomato Based)
Western Rice (Cilantro Based)
Seasoned Waffle Fries
Shoestring French Fries
Sweet Potato Fries
+$0.99
Mashed Potatoes
Green Chile Mashed
Sweet Plantains
+$0.99
Classic Pancho Salad
Baby Greens Salad
Caesar Salad
Fresh Spinach & Veggies
Grilled Vegetables
Mac & Cheese
Veggie Chili
Colorado Chili
Famous Fajitas (Utah)
Grilled Chicken Fajita $19.99
Mixed Vegetable Fajita $18.99
Portabella Mushroom Fajita $18.99
Grilled Hanger Steak Fajita $22.99
Pork Carnitas Fajita $19.99
Combo Fajita (Any Two Above) $20.99
Skirt Steak Combo (W/ Any One Above) $22.99
Roasted Shrimp Fajita $23.99
BBQ Skirt Steak Fajita $25.99
Grilled Salmon Fajita $25.99
Entree Salads (Vermont)
Pancho’s “Rice Bowl”
Western rice, black beans, sautéed bell peppers, onions, fresh tomato salsa, romaine lettuce and avocado topped with sour cream
Tortilla Basket Salad
Lettuce, tomato, onions, carrots, cheese, and BBQ bean salad in a crisp spinach tortilla basket, with our Mexican vinaigrette
Pancho’s Mesclun Salad
Baby salad greens, diced tomatoes corn & black bean relish and spiced croutons. Served with low fat chipotle ranch dressing
Seasonal Salad
Romaine hearts and baby greens, mango salsa, diced avocado, chopped grilled veggies and craisins tossed with our thyme-lime vinaigrette, topped with blue corn tortilla strips
Salad Supreme
Pancho’s Mesclun Salad with Chicken, Steak & Shrimp
$23.99
Childrens Menu (Arizona)
Hamburger
Cheeseburger
Chicken Fingers
Beef Hot Dog
Hard Or Soft Tacos
Chicken Quesadilla
Beef Or Bean Burrito
Mac And Cheese
Cheese Quesadilla
Chicken Or Cheese Enchilada
Yong Adult Menu (California)
Desperado’s Chicken
Sliced Grilled Chicken Breast
Steak Quesadilla
Colorado Enchilada
1/4 Barbecue Chicken (White Or Dark Meat)
1/2 Rack Baby Back Ribs
add $3.99
Popcorn Shrimp
add $3.99
Sliced Skirt Steak
add $3.99
Burgers (Nevada)
Nevada Burgers
8 oz. of freshly ground beef served wrapped in a flour or whole wheat tortilla or on a soft roll
$15.99
Panchos Favorite Sides (Utah)
Refried Beans
Barbeque Beans
Black Beans
Black Bean & Corn Relish
BBQ Bean Salad
Seasoned Waffle Fries
Shoestring French Fries
Sweet Potato Fries
+ $0.99
Mashed Potatoes
Green Chili Mashed
Sweet Plantains
+$0.99
Mac & Cheese
Spanish Rice (Tomato Based)
Western Rice (Cilantro Based)
Colorado Chili
Veggie Chili
Pancho Salad
Baby Greens Salad
Caesar Salad
Guacamole Or Fresh Avocado
+$1.99
Fresh Spinach & Veggies
Grilled Vegetables

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Jenna
I have been coming here since I was a child… Its tradition to come on our birthdays. They give you $10 off if you come 3 days before or after your birthday. But thats not what makes this place amazing. Amazing atmosphere, great food and service. I will be coming here for years to come 🙂 Thank-you panchos!!❤

… more

Tstarr Crafts
First time at this restaurant. I was given two baskets of chips before a waiter even came to the table . The chips were good though I had the grilled chicken quesadillas that were good . The sangria is good but you can get better sangria at piecraft .

… more

Bruce W
We had a party of 7, everyone enjoyed their dinner and the service was outstanding.

… more

Joseph Lanzarotta
Good restaurant staff was very friendly food was pretty good and very filling they have a great selection to choose from and they have a combo meal where you can get 2 entrees which is pretty cool and serving free chips and salsa is always a good perk will be back in the future

… more

Sean Kelly
My favorite spot for sunday brunch. The food is ALWAYS good. Plus what other restaurant can you listen to some grateful dead while enjoying your tacos XD. Lots of TVs for watching sports too

… more

BettyAnne Spuhler
The food is always excellent! Their drinks are delicious as well. I have ordered their red sangria to go throughout COVID 19 pandemic. The customer service is also amazing. I placed an order for delivery lastalast night did not receive enough chips with my order for the amount of dips ordered. I called them just to let them know for next time. They sent me more chips and extra guacamole at no charge with a bag that had “sorry” on it almost immediately. Their attention to customer service with this personal touch makes me want to order for dinner again tonight. Thank you Pancho’s!

… more

Theresa R
Ordered for delivery, food came earlier than expected ..delivery person was wearing a mask and gloves .. Didn’t get the name of the girl we ordered from but she was great knew the menu and was on point. The food was hot upon arrival and was amazing.. It was so much food and so many extras we did not miss the feeling of not being in the restaurant. Definitely doing this again soon. Thanks Pancho’s for a great dinner.

… more

audi Chang
Nice food. Good service. A tad noisy, but it’s Independence Day!

… more

C B
This restaurant has a party room with multiple great options at a reasonable price! The party room can fit approximately 40 people and they offer substantial options for appetizers, sides, entrees and dessert. I had a very intimate family celebration and the manager made sure he added personal touches adequate to the surprise party. The two waitresses handling the party and managing the buffet made sure there was enough food and beverages and made sure everyone was satisfied, even the kids! The food kept coming continuously and whatever was left-over they packaged it nicely for us to take home. This business has been running for 40 years and I am thankful they helped my celebratory occasion come to life.

… more

Mor Tician
I have never had a bad dish, here! The service is always great. Sometimes it may take a little longer, but relax people, it’s not that serious!!!!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions