Paola’s Osteria, new Carnegie Hill hot spot, this casual Italian restaurant is named after legendary chef, Paola Bottero, the Osteria feature, chef Marco Gialone crisp, thin and light, signature pizza. Fresh home-made pastas, meats and seafood dishes created by chef Nelson Monte, an extensive variety of Italian wines and cocktails that can be tasted in the dining room, at the bar or in the private wine cellar.
Paola’s Osteria is already one of the neighborhood favorite spot.
Comfortable restaurant spotlighting Italian cuisine, including pasta, pizza & seafood dishes. Based on 196 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1246 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10128
Phone: (212) 923-5820
Website:
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday |
12–10 PM |
| Wednesday |
12–10 PM |
| Thursday |
12–10 PM |
| Friday |
12–10 PM |
| Saturday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday |
12–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Mila Tal
A nice place, with yummy food, good & quick service, close to Guggenheim Museum and not too far from The Metropolitan.
… more
Cris Guhman
Great service, cozy and pleasant place.
… more
Ajit Parulekar
Fantastic food. Service could have been a little better but the outstanding food made up for any shortcomings. Worth eating at Paola’s Osteria.
… more
Caleb
Decent, definitely appealing to the crowd who enjoy eating a fancier establishment. Service was good. The meatballs tasted decent and margarita pizza was good. I was thinking about the chicken parmigiana but it didn’t even come with spaghetti which was unfortunate. If I wanted to spend a bunch of money I would come back but others enjoy that concept more than I. My friend got the veal and he seemed to enjoy it.
… more
Richard S
Best chicken parm I’ve ever had – been here for it three times already! Rest of the food is always good as well. Very nice staff and atmosphere.
… more
Aaron Prohaska
11/23/2022
… more
Melina Fiorella Gadien
Terrible service. The waiter without even greeting or welcoming us asked if we were ready to order. He did not ask about allergies or preferences. In the corner of the room the employees gather to chatter and it is even uncomfortable. When we had already paid, another waiter came up to ask us if we wanted to order dessert. Totally disorganized.
… more
DrKim
Their risotto con funghi with truffle and 3 kinds were fantastic. Cooked in harmony. Creamy. They use high quality ingredients. Also attentive to customers dietary restrictions.
… more
Gina Doost
The perfect Italian spot! Wonderful service, inviting atmosphere, and a great delicious authentic menu. Stopped by on a whim for lunch and the experience has me in need of returning. The hostess was so sweet and accommodating and I loved how the owner made his rounds greeting tables. A gem of a place!
… more
Irina Kurakin
5 of us came in off hours, only one table was taken outside. The hostess refused to seat as at a 7 place table nor connect a two place table to a four seat table. When we pointed out that the place is empty now, she said that if we don’t like the seating she is offering we can take a walk. Unbelievable! I feel bad for whoever owns this place. Of course, we left, no shortage of good places in the area.
… more
… View more
