At Papa Grande’s we serve fresh coastal Mexican cuisine with specialties like blackened fish tacos and short rib cheesesteak burritos. Our garage door bar is one of the best indoor/outdoor dining spots on the coast. We serve great happy hour specials including our famous agave crush, homemade margaritas, and house nachos. Stop by for a good time and some quality Mexican food in Fenwick Island!
Warm, timber-clad stop for coastal Mexican cooking such as fish tacos, burritos & tequila drinks. Based on 696 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
38929 Madison Ave, Selbyville, DE 19975
Phone: (302) 436-7272
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 12–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
12–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 12–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–10 PM |
| Thursday | 12–10 PM |
| Friday | 12–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Christina Reeder
Four stars for a beautiful atmosphere, delicious margaritas, a very tasty steak burrito, and a very nice server. The margarita’s tasted very fresh & had a good balance between alcohol and sweetness. The steak inside the burrito was good quality steak, plentiful, and well seasoned. If the fried fish tacos were as good as the burrito this would be a 5 star review, but they were just ok. We found them a little “fishy” and very dry. The slaw is flavorless (just dry cabbage.)and the tacos had very little sauce. We started to ask for more sauce, but didn’t because we got distracted by the burrito. The pickled onions were very good though! The other reason for 4 stars is lack of affordability. For two simple entrees and two base margarita’s we spent $79 after tip! Additionally, neither entree came with a side and no complimentary chips & salsa. Had we purchased an appetizer this would have been a $100 meal for decent, but not extravagant food. I think we’ll start doing picnics on the beach for 1/4 the price.
… more
Kayla Hunter
Such a nice dining atmosphere, especially outside at sunset! I am gluten free and vegan and have a corn allergy, so it is already difficult for me to eat out. However, the staff was super knowledgeable and accommodating, and I was able to get their farmer’s bowl, that day made with buckwheat, onions and peppers (took off the corn and replaced the corn dressing with a different vinaigrette). Happy to know I can always return and have a great meal that won’t make me feel sick!
… more
Mark Phillips
Waitress was great but the hostess had very short shorts on and kept bending over near our table(not what we wanted to see while eating). Ate upstairs and felt the atmosphere was lacking. Staring at an HVAC unit(which could have easily been covered up), PVC pipe(that could have easily been painted or covered), wood ceiling(any decoration would have been nice), and a hostess rear end( serious it was over 10 times she bent over at the bar in-front of us). Food was decent but not great. The shrimp in the surf and turf added nothing because the beef was stronger tasting(there was shrimp but just couldn’t taste them unless you plucked them out). The Mahi Mahi tacos were great. The brussel sprouts had a good flavor but were very hard. For the price I expected better.
… more
Kristen
really delicious pork relleno. the pear elderflower martini was a bit too sweet for me but if you like sweet martinis you’d like it. overall great service and good food but kinda pricy for what it is
… more
G A
Food and drinks are amazing. Service is okay. I enjoyed the nachos and tequila. The view is awesome. Next to the water and right in the heart of Fenwick! Stop by and have good food and good drinks!
… more
Bob
I had the steak chimichurri burrito special and it was the best burrito. I’ve had in a long time. The cheese sauce on top is just killer.. Beautiful presentation tasted as good as it looked.
… more
John Verbos
Hands down one of the best meals I’ve ever had in my life! The portions are more than generous and extremely affordable compared to other restaurants as well as an overall better food quality than most other local restaurants! I highly recommend anybody in the area to check this place out it was well worth the wait and money we spent! Our sever was an absolute pleasure and recommend dishes for us to try and I can’t believe how spot on she was with delicious recommendations I never had enchiladas before until recommended ….I can’t remember her name but the family that had a 2 year old there for a birthday dinner appreciate you !
… more
Nicholas Herr
Loved it. Great to see more options for food in OC area. Food and service were great. Staff was very friendly. Enjoyed the music and love the upstairs bar area.
… more
Stan Walls
Very good Margaritas. Excellent food. Our server Amelia was very attentive and pleasant. We will return. Our company of eight were all very pleased. Very happy. Our compliments to the management.
… more
Leslie Zell
I can’t say how thankful I am I chose to come to this restaurant.
… more
… View more