For Papa Johns Pizza in New Carlisle, OH, the secret to success is much like the secret to making a better pizza – the more you put into it, the more you get out of it. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, our original fresh dough, or even the box itself, we invest in our ingredients to ensure that we always give you the finest quality pizza. For you, it’s not just Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. It’s a family gathering, memorable birthday, work celebration or simply a great meal. It’s our goal to make sure you always have the best ingredients for every occasion. Call us at (937) 846-1155 for delivery or stop by N Main St for carryout to order your favorite, pizza, breadsticks, or wings today!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts. Based on 128 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
410 N Main St, New Carlisle, OH 45344
Phone: (937) 846-1155
Website:
Hours
| Sunday |
11 AM–11:30 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10 AM–11:30 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday |
10 AM–11:30 PM |
| Wednesday |
10 AM–11:30 PM |
| Thursday |
10 AM–11:30 PM |
| Friday |
10 AM–12:30 AM |
| Saturday |
10 AM–12:30 AM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Zach Morgan
Great food and the staff was wonderful, made sure they found us a deal even though we were not asking for one
… more
Tina Wright
We stopped eating /order from here because they always messed the order up , it should have be CALLED stoners Pizzeria. EVERONE IN BUILDING WAS HIGH . well I guest a year wr give it a try again and let me tell you it was the best experience I have ever had at papa johns. So they much have got new crew members that can do their job …… thank you 100%
… more
Thomas Alcorn
Crew was not organized, manager was not in charge of the crew. Orders were not being made in a timely manner.
… more
Amanda Stiles
My husband was nice enough to think about me. I love the garlic knots. He ordered some but when it got here the sauce was open so it was empty. That’s the best part. Very disappointed.
… more
Vella Reeves
Poor customer service. Staff has zero personality, will not say hello or even tell you how much your total is, nor change.
… more
Adam Shepard
Have had tons of pizza. Several states and fancy restaurant pizza….but let me tell ya….the pizza today ranked in my top 5 of all time. Super friendly people working today as well. What a great experience I had with PJs today.
… more
Tony Kidd
Wanted 1st an last name an when refused first name hung up an will kit answer phones . Amateurs
… more
Bob Carr
Ordered from here 7/19/20. Gave me the wrong order. Didn’t know until I got home 20 minutes later. My wife called as I was going back down there. Told her they couldn’t replace my original order and it would still be as fresh under the heat lights add in the oven. But they would give us a 2 liter of soda! So I called after she did. They instantly put me on hold where I stayed until I got back to the store which was nearly 8 minutes time. They told me when I returned that they did remake the order. After telling my wife they couldn’t??? I told them I didn’t believe they remade it. He told me he didn’t care and told me to leave. This was the manager. Another employee from the kitchen area also came out and tried to get involved. I told them to refund my card and is never come back to that store. What a joke of a manager and store this place has become. I was a fairly regular customer, willing to drive the 20 minutes from my house.
… more
Cor Vargas
For New Years Eve we ordered over $70 worth of food from here at 10pm with a 34-44 minutes estimated delivery time. At 1020 our order was showing as our for delivery. 11pm comes and goes and it still shows at out for delivery. Around 1120 it now shows a new name for delivery person. The manager was rude when I called at 1130 asking about our order annoyed that I expected hot fresh pizza vs hour old pizza that was apparently taken by the wrong driver. We got our food after midnight. We’re very disappointed.
… more
Bbbb Gggg
This was my first ever ordering from papa johns an it’s gonna be my last. Ordered two large pizzas delivery was fast an the pizzas was hot but when you pick up a slice all the toppings would slide off the pizza eat two slices an just threw it all away
… more
… View more
