Papa J’s Pizzeria & Diner Menu – Honor, MI

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Honor, MI

Our family owned and operated ’50s style diner serves a full menu and great pizza with a vintage look and feel. Enjoy good food, fair prices and fast, friendly service. Not in the mood for a burger but craving a real shake? Papa J’s serves the best hand dipped and soft serve ice cream, real shakes and malts in town. Get it delivered to your doorstep from 4 p.m. to 9 p.m, every day of the week and up to 8 miles!

Based on 881 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Papa J's Pizzeria & Diner 49640

Address:
10583 Main St, Honor, MI 49640

Phone: (231) 325-7070

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Monday

(Labor Day)
Closed

Holiday hours
Tuesday 3–9 PM
Wednesday 8 AM–9 PM
Thursday 8 AM–9 PM
Friday 8 AM–9 PM
Saturday 8 AM–9 PM
Sunday 8 AM–9 PM

Menu

Main Menu
Beer Battered Shrimp
Twelve Red Hook amber ale battered shrimp
$9.99
Buffalo Shrimp $10.99
Cheesy Breadsticks
Our O.G. cheesybread. Served with marinara or ranch.
$8.99
Deep Dish Cheesebread $10.99
Clam Strips
Breaded and fried till golden.
$8.99
Coconut Shrimp
Six coconut coated jumbo shrimp fried, served with a pineapple strawberry dipping sauce.
$9.99
Mini Corn Dogs
Twelve bite size corn dogs.
$9.99
Deep Fried Pickles
Two large pickle spears, wrapped in ham, filled with cream cheese, beer battered and deep fried.
$8.99
Chips $3.99
French Fries
A shareable portion of our in house hand cut fries.
$3.99
Tater Tots $3.99
Sweet Potato Fries
Savory seasoned wavelength sweet fries.
$6.99
Onion Rings
Beer battered and fried.
$5.99
Fried Cauliflower
Beer battered cauliflower fried till golden.
$7.99
Fried Green Beans
Toasted onion battered, fried till golden.
$8.99
Fried Mushrooms
Beer battered whole mushrooms, fried till golden.
$7.99
Garlic Bites
Bite size breadstix “lathered” with butter then “dusted” with garlic and parmesan.
$7.99
Mozzarella Cheese Stix
Five breaded mozzarella cheese sticks. Served with marinara or ranch.
$7.99
Pizza Bones
Plain and simple but always delicious. Twisted bread sticks covered in parmesan. Served with marinara or ranch.
$7.99
Antipasta
Romaine, pepperoni, salami, tomato, green and black olives, pepper rings, and mozzarella.
$13.99
Beef Taco Salad
Shredded lettuce, beef, tomato, onion, cheddar, and black olives. Served with sour cream and salsa.
$12.99
Caesar Salad
Romaine, croutons, and shredded parmesan.
$9.99
Chef Salad
Romaine, turkey, ham, american and swiss cheese, tomato, crouton and a hard boiled egg.
$13.99
Cherry Chicken Salad
Romaine, pecans, bleu cheese, red onion
$13.99
Chicken Caesar Salad
Romaine, chicken, parmesan, and croutons.
$12.99
Chicken Taco Salad
Shredded lettuce, chicken, tomato, onion, cheddar, and black olives. Served with sour cream and salsa.
$12.99
Fried Chicken Salad
Romaine, crispy chicken, cucumber, cheddar, and red onion.
$12.99
Garden Salad For 10
Simple salad with garden vegetables and croutons. One choice of dressing. Enough salad for ten PEOPLE. NOT COWS.
$25.99
Greek Salad
Feta cheese, black olives, pepper rings, green pepper, red onion, tomato, and romaine.
$12.99
Lg Side Salad $11.99
Oriental Chicken Salad
Mandarin oranges, almonds, crisp noodles and house made honey vinaigrette.
$13.99
Pint Of Coleslaw
Have you heard of Murphy’s Law??? How about COLES LAW….
$8.50
Soup Of The Day
Please call us to see what our soup(s) of the day are- we don’t keep all of these on hand (:
$5.99
Bacon Cheeseburger
Bacon and american cheese
$12.99
Blue Moon Burger
Bleu cheese and mayo
$12.99
Hamburger
Meat and bread
$11.99
Jalapeño Burger
Jalapeno, swiss cheese and mayo
$12.99
Mushroom Burger
Sauteed mushrooms and onion, swiss cheese and mayo
$12.99
Olive Burger
Sauteed green olives, swiss cheese and mayo
$12.99
Papa Burger
Fried to order haystack onions, lettuce, tomato, pickle, mayo, Dirty Bastards BBQ, swiss and american cheese….everything but the kitchen sink, but feel free to add more to it:)
$15.99
Patty Melt
Grilled sunflower rye bread, sauteed onions and swiss cheese
$12.99
Royale With Cheese
Served Deluxe (mayo, lettuce, tomato) with american cheese
$11.99
Western Burger
Bacon, onion rings, Dirty Bastards BBQ and american cheese
$14.99
Moomers Shake W/BURGER $5.99
SS Shake W/BURGER $4.99
BBQ Chicken Wrap
BBQ Chicken, shredded lettuce, cheddar, tomato and ranch
$11.99
BLT
Smoking will kill you. Bacon will kill you. But smoking bacon will cure it:)
$11.99
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Spicy chicken, shredded lettuce, cheddar, tomato and ranch
$11.99
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Chicken, romaine, parmesan and caeser dressing
$11.99
Chicken Gyro
Chicken, feta, red onion, cucumber and tzatziki sauce
$11.99
Club Sandwich
Triple decker sandwich. Consists of ham, turkey, bacon, american and swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo….phew that is a mouth full;0
$15.99
Club Wrap
Ham, turkey, bacon, american and swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo.
$13.99
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Crispy chicken, lettuce, tomato and mayo. Served on a Brioche bun
$11.99
Crispy Chicken Wrap
Chicken, cheddar, lettuce, tomato and ranch
$11.99
Fish Sandwich
Choice of pollock or cod. Dressed with tartar, lettuce, and tomato
$11.99
Greek Wrap
Chicken, feta, spinach, tomato, red onion, ranch and greek dressing
$10.99
Grilled Cheese
Swiss, cheddar and provolone
$9.99
Hot Turkey
Traditional hot turkey sandwich. Served with mashed potatoes, gravy and coleslaw.
$13.99
Hot Roast Beef
Our family recipe pot roast. Between two pieces of white bread. Smothered in gravy. Served with mashed and coleslaw.
$15.99
Gyro
Shaved lamb, feta, red onion, cucumber and tzatziki sauce
$11.99
Philly Steak
Thinly sliced steak, sauteed onions, peppers and swiss cheese. Served of a foccacia roll
$12.99
Pot Roast French Dip
Family recipe pot roast (yes this is me calling it out, its good. Very good.) sauteed onions and swiss cheese. Served on a foccacia roll with a side of Aujus to dip.
$12.99
Reuben
A friend of mine wanted to make a reuben sandwich but he couldn’t find the right bread… You could say his plans went a-rye.
$13.99
Shrimp Po Boy
Beer battered shrimp, lettuce, tomato and cilantro lime mayo. Served on a foccacia roll.
$12.99
Tuna Melt
Grilled sandwich on rye with tuna and swiss.
$10.99
Veggie Wrap
Lettuce, tomato, red onion, roasted red peppers, green pepper, cucumber, mozzarella, cheddar and ranch.
$10.99
Rachel
Rye, Swiss, Turkey, and coleslaw
$13.99
Beer Battered Shrimp Basket
Red Hook Ale battered shrimp fried till golden.
$12.99
Chicken Strip Basket
Four chicken strips fried till golden.
$10.99
Clam Strip Basket
Breaded clam strips. Served with tartar and a lemon.
$11.29
Coconut Shrimp Basket
Six coconut coated jumbo shrimp fried, served with a pineapple strawberry dipping sauce.
$13.99
Cod Basket
Baked. Beer battered. Breaded. However you like it. Served with tartar and a lemon.
$13.49
Fried Chicken Basket
Our famous four piece chicken. Served with all the fixings. Choice of potato, coleslaw, biscuit, butter and honey.
$14.99
Pollock Basket
Three pieces of pollock. Baked, beer battered or breaded. Served with tartar and a lemon.
$11.49
Perch Basket $23.99
BLT Sub
Man…looking at all of this food is bacon me hungry.
$9.99
Cheeseburger Sub
Burger, American cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo. Served on a grilled bun
$11.99
Chicken Sub
Chicken, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato and mayo
$9.99
Club Sub
Turkey, bacon, swiss and american cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayo. Served on a toasted bun
$10.99
Deluxe Supreme Sub
Italian meats (ham, pepperoni, salami), mozzarella, sauteed onions and green peppers, lettuce, tomato and french dressing
$10.99
Ham Sub
Ham, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato and mayo
$9.99
Italian Stallion Sub
Italian sausage, bacon, sauteed onion and green pepper, lettuce, tomato and italian dressing
$9.99
Italian Sub
Italian meats (ham, pepperoni, salami)
$9.99
Meatball Sub
Chopped meatballs, family recipe pizza sauce and mozzarella. Served on a toasted bun
$9.99
Pizza Steak Sub
Thinly shaved steak, family recipe pizza sauce and mozzarella. Served on a toasted bun
$10.99
Pizza Sub
Pepperoni, pizza ham, family recipe pizza sauce and mozzarella. Served on a toasted bun
$9.99
Steak Sub
Thinly shaved steak, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato and french dressing
$10.99
Super Sub
Turkey, ham, salami, swiss, lettuce, tomato and mayo
$9.99
Turkey Sub
Turkey, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato and mayo
$9.99
Vegetarian Sub
Sauteed mushroom, onion, green pepper, green and black olives, lettuce, tomato, mozzarella and french dressing
$9.99
Beer Battered Shrimp Dinner
Red Hook beer battered shrimp. Choice of potato.
$15.99
Chicken Strip Dinner
Breaded chicken tenderloins. Choice of potato.
$14.99
Clam Strips Dinner
Breaded clam strips. Choice of potato.
$13.99
Coconut Shrimp Dinner
Six coconut coated jumbo shrimp fried, served with a pineapple strawberry dipping sauce. Choice of potato.
$15.99
Cod Dinner
Baked. Beer battered. Breaded. However you like it. Served with tartar and a lemon. Choice of potato.
$15.49
4 Pc Fried Chicken Dinner
Our famous four piece chicken. Served with all the fixings. Choice of potato, biscuit, butter and honey.
$16.99
12 Pc Fried Chicken Dinner
Dinner for the family 🙂 Served with all of the fixings. Pint of mashed and gravy. Pint of coleslaw. Four biscuits with honey and butter.
$30.99
Pollock Dinner
Three pieces of pollock. Baked, beer battered or breaded. Served with tartar and a lemon. Choice of potato.
$14.99
Pot Roast Dinner
Our family recipe pot roast is just delicious. Sorry if we run out…It happens. Served with mashed and gravy, carrots, soup and salad.
$16.99
Smothered Chicken
Two chicken breasts, smothered in mushrooms and onions. Topped with melted swiss and tomatoes. Served with mashed potatoes and gravy.
$15.99
Perch Dinner $25.99
Chicken Alfredo
Grilled chicken, fettuccine and a homemade alfredo sauce. Served with a piece of garlic texas toast.
$13.49
Spaghetti
We make our homemade sauce from grandmas recipe book. Served with a piece of garlic texas toast.
$12.99
1# Chicken Wing Boneless $10.99
1# Chicken Wing Trad $11.99
KIDS Cheese Pizza $7.99
KIDS Chix Strips & Fries $7.99
KIDS Grilled Cheese & Fries $7.99
KIDS Hamburger And Fries $7.99
KIDS Macaroni & Cheese $7.99
KIDS Mini Corn Dogs $7.99
KIDS Pepperoni Pizza $7.99
Baked Potato $3.99
Coleslaw $2.49
Cottage Cheese $2.99
Fruit Cup $4.99
Salad Dressing $0.00
Side Mashed $2.99
Side Mashed W/Gravy $3.99
Side Gravy $1.49
Side Pizza Sauce $1.29
Side Ranch $1.29
Side Garlic Butter $0.99
Sweet Potato Fries $3.99
Waffle Fries $3.99
Drink Menu
2 Liter $3.29
Milk
Child’s Size milk
$3.49
Soda Pop To-Go
Choose from any of our Fountain Soda flavors
$2.29
Breakfast Menu
Camaro
One egg, choice of meat
$8.99
Catalina
Skillet with hashbrowns, ham, onion, green pepper and cheddar. Served on a egg flat.
$13.99
Chevelle
Two eggs, choice of meat
$9.99
57 Chevy
Two eggs, choice of meat, choice of potato
$10.99
Corvette
Two eggs, ground sirloin (grilled to your specification), choice of potato
$12.99
Fury
Two eggs, choice of potato
$8.99
GTO
Two eggs, corned beef hash (cooked to your specification)
$12.99
Mustang
Biscuits and gravy, DOES NOT come with toast, biscuit or pancakes.
$8.99
Oldsmobile
Three eggs, one ham, two sausage links, two pieces of bacon, choice of potato
$13.99
Peugeot
Our take on a eggs benedict. DOES NOT come with toast, biscuit or pancakes
$12.99
Rambler
Breakfast sandwich. Served on an english muffin. Topped with american cheese. Your choice of meat
$5.99
Road Runner
Breakfast Pizza. Choose three toppings.
$11.99
Rolls Royce
Two eggs, New York Strip (cooked the way you like) and choice of potato
$18.99
Shelby
Stuffed hashbrowns. Stuffed with mushrooms, onion, sour cream and cheddar.
$12.99
Street Rod
Chopped up sausage patties, hashbrowns and egg. Smothered in sausage gravy. Covered in cheddar cheese.
$14.99
T-Bird
Three eggs, choice of meat, choice of potato
$11.99
Bonneville
Three large cranberry pecan pancakes.
$10.99
Cadillac
Belgian Waffle. Dont forget the add ons
$9.99
Challenger
Three pieces of french toast. Smothered in pecans, drizzled with caramel and icing.
$11.99
Corvair
Three buttermilk pancakes
$8.99
Fairlane
Three buttermilk pancakes with blueberries inside
$9.99
Falcon
Three pieces of french toast
$9.99
The Gremlin
Three build your own buttermilk pancakes.
$10.99
Volkswagen
Short stack of french toast or cakes
$8.99
Buick
Ham, onion, green pepper, mushroom and american cheese.
$13.49
Cheese Omelet
Choose your cheese
$11.99
Chariot
Bacon, tomato, spinach, feta cheese, onion and green pepper.
$13.49
Chrysler
Ham, sausage, bacon, onion, green pepper, mushroom and american cheese
$13.99
Dodge
Mushroom, onion, green pepper, tomato, swiss and american cheese
$13.49
Ham And Cheese Omelet
Ham and choice of cheese
$12.99
Low Rider
Taco meat, onion, green pepper, cheddar and mozzarella
$13.99
Model-T
Corned beef hash, onion, green pepper and swiss cheese
$13.99
Renault
Onion, bacon, sour cream and hashbrowns inside omelet
$13.99
Soap Box Derby Car
Build your own omelet.
$13.99
Studebaker
Onion, bacon, mushroom, green pepper and american cheese
$13.49
The Taxi Cab
Thinly shaved steak, onion, green pepper and swiss cheese
$13.99
The Tractor
Ham, potato, onion, green pepper, mushroom and cheddar cheese
$13.49
Little Red Wagon
One egg and choice of meat. Served with toast, biscuit or pancake.
$6.99
Roller Skates
One Mickey Mouse pancake. Add m&ms, chocolate chips or blueberry. Comes with choice of meat.
$6.99
Tricycle
One piece of french toast. Choice of meat.
$6.99
Bagel And Cream Cheese $4.99
Cinnamon Roll
Ask for it to be grilled. No extra charge.
$4.99
Corned Beef Hash $8.99
Oatmeal $5.99
1/2 Oatmeal $4.99
Side Sausage Gravy $3.99
Side Amer. Fries $3.99
Side Breakfast Meat $5.99
Side Hashbrowns $4.99
Toast/E.Muffin/Biscuit
Side of Toast
$2.99
Yogurt Parfait $8.99
Tater Tots $3.99
1 Side Cake $2.99
Breakfast Buffet $14.99
Mexican Night
Nachos $5.95
Taco Salad $12.99
Burritos $10.99
Single Taco $2.99
Quesadilla $6.99
Taco Pizza $16.99
Taco Plate $8.99
Pizza Menu
Personal Pizza
A 4-slice, 8″ pizza.
$7.99
Small Pizza $12.50
Medium Pizza $13.50
Large Pizza $14.50
X-Large Pizza $15.50
Big Boot $33.99
Stromboli
A volcanic island in the Mediterranean, the most northeasterly of the Lipari Islands. Just kidding…It is a type of turnover, filled with whatever you would like.
$20.99
Personal Specialty $8.50
Small Specialty $16.99
Medium Specialty $18.99
Large Specialty $20.99
X-Large Specialty $23.99
Big Boot Specialty $37.49
12″ Chicago Cheese Pizza $20.99
12″ Chicago 1 Topping $23.98
12″ Chicago 2 Topping $26.97
12″ Chicago 3 Topping $29.96
12″ Chicago 4 Topping $32.95
12″ Chicago 5 Topping $35.94
12″ Chicago 6 Topping $38.93
12″ Chicago 7 Topping $41.92
14″ Chicago Cheese Pizza $23.99
14″ Chicago 1 Topping $27.98
14″ Chicago 2 Topping $31.97
14″ Chicago 3 Topping $35.96
14″ Chicago 4 Topping $39.95
14″ Chicago 5 Topping $43.94
14″ Chicago 6 Topping $47.93
14″ Chicago 7 Topping $51.92
12″ PAN Cheese Pizza $18.99
12″ PAN 1 Topping $21.98
12″ PAN 2 Topping $24.97
12″ PAN 3 Topping $27.96
12″ PAN 4 Topping $30.95
12″ PAN 5 Topping $33.94
12″ PAN 6 Topping $37.93
12″ PAN 7 Topping $41.92
14″ PAN Cheese Pizza $21.99
14″ PAN 1 Topping $25.98
14″ PAN 2 Topping $29.97
14″ PAN 3 Topping $33.96
14″ PAN 4 Topping $37.95
14″ PAN 5 Topping $41.94
14″ PAN 6 Topping $45.93
14″ PAN 7 Topping $49.92

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

John Landsbaum
We were told this might be the best burger place in Michigan and they also have hand dipped malts. That was a great suggestion! Place was jumping with Sunday regulars and they were very apologetic. Once we ordered, everything came out promptly. The burgers were fantastic and came with fresh cut fries that were just the strong side of crispy – awesome. Chocolate malt was HUGE! We split it between ourselves and enjoyed every sip!

… more

Barbara Sielski
We have had our car club cruise to Papa J’s a couple times. The food (we do the pizza buffet with salad bar) is always great and plentiful, the staff friendly and helpful. And the ice cream yummy.

… more

Ryan LaMadline
Amazing all you can eat breakfast buffet on Sundays. Everything was fresh! The eggs Benedict is amazing! Coffee is always hot and fresh, never an empty cup.

… more

shreyas kulkarni
Good old traditional American diner. The food is good and in good portions. We took papa pizza and garlic knots. The garlic knots were very soft and fluffy. Liked their marinara sauce. The servers were friendly and welcoming. It has a retro look to it from inside.

… more

Chris Oquinn
Love this place! I live right down the road. The crispy chicken strips in a basket or sandwich is excellent. Gyros, fish and chips, biscuits and gravy all really good. Haven’t tried the pizza yet, that’s next. Service is excellent, the waitstaff are cool. Please eat here, it’s very good.

… more

Jack’s, Against all Odd’s! “JAXS”
The place was not all that busy, I felt ignored but that is not reasonable thinking I’d say understaffed is most likely the answer, wate staff is very nice. It took 10 min just to get a drink and menu, ok well that can happen but if not being critical service is often prompt and delightful at Papa J’s. The restaurant is really neatly decorated like a retro modern 1950″s dinner interesting to look at all the Kool paintings and things people looking all around tv on although watching sealions give birth on the Discovery Channel is not the best dinning entertainment. I ordered biscuits and gray 3 eggs hash browns and bacon. At 9:49 arrived at 10:21 so approximately 30 min the table that arrived 10 min after my arrival was served first well ok what can you do but twiddle your thumbs I have found reacting to such things is fruitless Nothing good ever happens with negative confrontational aggressive behavior. The food looks ok. Hash browns raw inside. Biscuits and grave are extremely good light Biscuits and the gravy is tasty and light and creamy great combo, eggs over easy nice jod there and bacon crisp 5 peaces ok, all in all food is good would be great but undercooked hash brown got Papa J’s a good instead of exclent grade restaurant is nice wate staff is under staffed price high. I Would I come back yes I think on a different day an excellent grad wold be accomplished, Enjoy

… more

Peter Wilke
I’ve been a patron of Papa Js for years. Always a good choice to visit. Haven’t had a miss on anything during my many visits. I’ve not hit their Ice cream yet, still on my list. I will return for sure.

… more

Heather Strang
I grew up around Benzie County and have been to Papa J’s multiple times. I’m in town visiting family and we decided to come eat. It was busy for a holiday week but no too busy. There were a limited number of servers it seemed like but still enough to cover the room. I feel like our waitress took a little long to get around to us and didn’t check in to see how things were going. When our food came out, my burger came out steaming hot, but my fries were almost cold and the fried mushrooms I ordered, that I asked to come before my meal, got delivered with my meal and were almost cold as well. So it’s a 4 star day for me, but doesn’t deter me from giving them a go the next time I’m in town visiting.

… more

Marc Palmer (Fire On The Dark Star)
Great place for Breakfast, Lunch, or Dinner I chose the pizza and salad bar and it was great!!! Fresh pizza, fresh salad ingredients and great atmosphere with many old photos and history on the walls. Can’t wait to go back for breakfast!

… more

Momma P
Don’t try to order anything within the last hour of closing. They will claim the order didn’t come to the Honor location even though the girl answered the phone “Papa J’s, Honor, Michigan”. When I tried to call to see what was going on since my son was sitting there waiting (still before closing time), they then wouldn’t answer the phone. So, I cannot comment on the food and the service is rotten. Take your money somewhere else.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions