Counter-service place offering hot & cold subs on house-baked bread, plus pizza, calzones & salads. Based on 294 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
130 S State St, Hagerman, ID 83332
Phone: (208) 837-6680
Website: http://www.papakelseysofhagerman.com/
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–8 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ed Whitley
Nice little place, plenty of indoor seating and a small patio area out front with 4 or 5 small tables. Big menu with pizza, sandwiches, wings, and some other things, and priced reasonably for the current inflation. Took about 40 min to get 2 large and 1 mini pizza, but they were very good, would go again.
… more
Mark Kehoe
Ordered a pizza for Carry out after work and toppings were added that wasn’t supposed to be on there, when I got home I called them back to make it rite with no answer, they never called me back after leaving a vm either. This would be the 3 rd time I’ve had wrong toppings on my pizza. I ordered the Fred’s delight and they always be putting onions on it . Probably done with this place from now on . *****Updated***** still no reach out on my review
… more
Brian Rich
In Full disclosure, I didnt eat here, but the people I was with did.
… more
John
Papa Kelsey’s has the best hot subs in the valley. Consistently good and fulfilling. The Italian combo is the way to go! If you get a whole sub it’s nigh a mile long and makes for some great leftovers! Best quick stop in Hagerman!
… more
Scott Richardson
Waited 45 minutes for eat in pizza. When we finally went to the counter to check on status, they said they forgot it was eat in so it was sitting there for a long time. Pizza quality and taste was similar to Digornios frozen pizza – very little sauce and cheese. Soda machine was out of ice and carbonation. Overall, a very disappointing experience.
… more
Erick Bostrom
This is a favorite stop of the family every time we go to Miracle Hot Springs.
… more
Scotty J Outdoors
Extremely good pizza. Great service. Thanks to the restaurant down the street. If you Would have had better service we would have never found this place. I highly recommend this place.
… more
Jeremy Bergeson
We ordered two subs and two personal pizza. All fabulous. Good bread. Good dough. Good ingredients. Very tasty.
… more
Kevin Winter
Very nice, clean, roomy place. Excellent selection of delicious food. Our sandwiches were superb. Friendly, fast service. We’ll be back soon!
… more
Pst Taylor
It was a to-go order with extra crispy onion rings and they came out uncooked it all and it was a to-go order so I guess they don’t care about if it’s to go they just cook it however
… more
… View more