We believe that fresh, made from scratch pizza that you bake at home is the perfect way to pizza. Order online and pick up in-store. We offer contactless pickup stations at our stores and delivery and curbside pickup where we can. Change The Way You Pizza.™ We accept EBT!
Chain outlet offering build-your-own takeaway pizzas, to be cooked at home. Based on 55 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $
✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
219 S Century Ave, Waunakee, WI 53597
Phone: (608) 850-9135
Hours
| Thursday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Paul Cruikshank
tried to call in for an order and no response. Thinking it was the wrong number we made an online order. Came in to pick up my pizza and both employees were not working on anything. When I told him I was there for my pick up he said we are in the middle of making the pizza. He then went to the back of the store and about 5 min later came back with the dough. In the slowest manner possible he began to make my pizza. While waiting another man came in for a remake because his pizza was wrong and another gentleman came in and was not even acknowledged by a staff member. After waiting for a few min the older staff member who I can only assume was the manager was asked by the customer if he could make an order. His response was “Its gonna be awhile we are very far behind.” The customer responded with that’s okay can I place an order and just come back in a little bit to pick it up? The assumed manager responded with ” No we are really behind this pizza what suppose to be out 15 min ago.” After seeing this attitude by the staff I decided to call the same number that I tried to call before as the phone rang and rang for several minutes before. Turns out the number was correct and was just being ignored by both employees. This papa murphy’s is easily the worst run I’ve ever seen. It was not ever that busy when I got there. Any backup in orders was clearly due to lazy employees who clearly don’t care about putting fourth any effort at their job. Honestly I’m not even mad. I’m more impressed with how little someone can care about their job. lol
… more
Kadance Poleski
I got a salad and half of it was rotted and and slimy which was disappointing and I thought I could just pick it out but it was a lot but I usually like there pizzas this time is was normal crust instead of thin but typically it’s good but this will deter me for a minute 6/29/23
… more
Lance Corey
Service was poor I ordered my online order and it wasn’t ready when I showed up it said it would be ready in 30 min it took them 40 min they were rude.
… more
Abby Groves
I’d give zero stars if that was an option. Ive worked in customer service for 14 years and always treat customer service works with respect. However, thus was my worst customer service interaction ever. Ordering online is an absolute waste of time. Our first order wasn’t confirmed on our end so we sent a second order only to then find out both orders were accepted. We called the store and they told us they couldn’t refund us or cancel one of the orders because “they just couldn’t” but they would give us a free pizza coupon we could use next time. Which we agreed too. They did confirm that they had both our orders… When we went to the store to pick up our order of two large pizzas and 3 cheese bread orders, only the pizza was there. We asked for our sides and we were told they were completely out of sides. Why didn’t the website tell us that? Or when we originally called about there being two orders placed? The kid behind the counter would only offer his apologies and said nothing about our original coupon to make things right. After some discussion, an other employee came out of the back and offered us our original coupon because she was who we originally talked to. We were missing about $25 worth of our order and said one coupon would not be enough. Both employees started to argue with us and said there was nothing they could do. We asked about a manager, or leaving our contact information and we were basically told if the manager isn’t physically present he won’t refund anything and leaving a note won’t get us anywhere. The one employee then offered to take back our one pizza and we could put a note on that for the manager. The other employee then started blaming the store being out of everything because Little Cesar’s just closed and that they opened late today because they had to refund a bunch of orders and couldn’t open until late… (oh, so you do offer refunds?) Seriously questioning the staff and manager. How can you leave two teenagers to run a store and not give them good customer service skills? How can a manager leave the store in that big of a disaster and not instruct the employees to help the customers in this situation especially when they know this is an ongoing issue Also? Also, how can the website let you order anything even when that item is out of stock?
… more
Alexander L
Place has gone downhill, have to go out of town for actual Papa Murphy’s now. They don’t do extra sauce or follow order instruction, when attempting an order the great act of how long it’s going to take basically says ‘dont order here’
… more
Mindy Jo Oren
so this is the third time we’ve called at 7:15 and 7:30 and no one will answer the phone.we live 2 mins away so decide to go there. The first time they made my son wait in line for10 mins than would not take his order. They are rude on the phone, hang up on us and just seem lazy towards the end of the night.If you can’t handle people and are just watching the clock till closing time and hurrying people than you should not be working in customer service…..This is not ok behavior
… more
Matthew Freeman
We get pizza here on Fridays just about every other week of the year. The consistency is great and I don’t ever recall having a bad experience. The pizza tastes great and has a good mix of cheese and toppings.
… more
Jamison Wolfer
Ordered from here twice… First time they didn’t have our order ready and had to wait while watching someone put the pizzas together as slowly as possible. Second time we ordered and had another family member pick it up and they said the order was just 2 pizzas and didn’t give us 3 other items we ordered. We won’t be placing a third order and hopefully will get our money back.
… more
Carol Felland
Always good! Never been disappointed with a Papa Murphy’s pizza.
… more
Stacey Persha
Wonderful employees. After a long day at work I picked our 1yr old up from daycare and headed to Papa Murphys. After I ordered my Pizza and cheese bread, and was waiting for it to be made, I was told one of the employees would help me and carry out my Pizza since I had our baby. Great Pizza, helpful and polite employees.
… more
… View more