Based on 371 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 2.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
12203 E Iliff Ave, Aurora, CO 80014
Phone: (720) 638-1000
Hours
| Saturday | 4 PM–4 AM |
| Sunday | 4 PM–4 AM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
4 PM–4 AM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 4 PM–4 AM |
| Wednesday | 4 PM–4 AM |
| Thursday | 4 PM–4 AM |
| Friday | 4 PM–4 AM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: clorder.com
Reviews
Mahmood Aldulaimi
Disgusting, burnt pizza, undercooked burgers. This place should be shut down for health hazards. I have never put a bad review for a food place. But this place here… I do not know how they are in business.
… more
Zackariah Farah
In all, I decided to give Papa Nicky’s 4 stars. Not for the food or service or price but because they gave us a novel and stimulating dining experience. To be clear, our two “pizzas” arrived about 3 hours late, cost over $60 and could not exactly be described as delicious or even edible.
… more
Tya Ewers
Please DO NOT EAT HERE JUST OPENED THE BOX TO EAT my Calzone and this is what I found THIS IS ABSOLUTELY UNACCEPTABLE! I should not be finding bugs in my food I’m so grossed out this place needs to be shut down!
… more
Amy White
The food has been going down for the last couple of years. I gave it one last shot but cause I’d loved their food now. It is sauceless and slattered and cheese to. I guess fool the parishioner no salt no garlic no pepper no sauce no. Spices the bread has went down to cheap cut in half-Italian loads. You can buy at the grocery store I am so disappointed. I will never spend another sixty five dollars 4 3 meals again.
… more
Angel Little bear
I placed my order over the phone, I’m not sure as to who took my order for my pizza and wings. I waited about an hour for it to show up, then when the driver/delivery guy comes up he forgets my soda in the car. The person taking my order is talking so fast I can barely comprehend what they’re saying to me, by the time I hear my total he hangs up on me before I’m even able to ask my last question. And to top all of that off he brings me this smashed pizza then proceeded to say “oh thank you for the generous tip” but doesn’t give me my receipt all I know is my debit card is charged $50 for something that was originally supposed to be 30$
… more
Younion Miller
Ordered late on GrubHub and just literally never got my order. It remained showing on the way for an hour past ETA so I had to get GrubHub to refund me and cancel. Food still never came. Quite annoying. Don’t offer late night delivery if you’re just not going to deliver.
… more
Alyssa Brown
Pretty fast delivery and Greta customer service my delivery guy called instead of ringing my doorbell. Late night munchies were satisfied. Good price core what I got and a good amount of food. I’m assuming the bad reviews just went at a bad time. My food was fresh and hot.
… more
Ryan Wilhelm
I ordered a chicken parm sub. 2 bites in and discovered the chicken was raw… Never again
… more
Arbaz Hussain
I was a little bit hesitant to order from here after reading the reviews. But ubereats had a crazy 60% off deal so I couldn’t pass that up. I was honestly surprised how good the food I was. I order meat lovers calzone and pizza and the best part was it was halal.
… more
Kevin Hardy
I have no idea why this place gets bad reviews. I have not had one bad experience here. Dilip is always nice to me and gives me an amazing product and always takes care of me. The supremes pizza is amazing, the under carriage of the pizza is great, it’s a good crust so the topping doesn’t fall off. It’s right around the corner from my place and I always have fresh food. I will continue to order for this place and support this local business. They always ask me how the food is every time I come in and chat with me for a few as well. Tons of options on their menu and the prices you can’t beat!
… more
… View more