Serving quality pizzas, pastas, salads, subs and side dishes using only the freshest ingredients in our recipes. Build your own pizza with just the right amount of toppings or select from one of our specialty pizzas. See our website for the best deals! Delivery, carry out, catering and online ordering are available.
Casual pizzeria chain serving classic & creative pies, plus wings, subs & sides. Based on 183 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
506 B Spaulding Rd, Montezuma, GA 31063
Phone: (478) 472-7272
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–8:45 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:45 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:45 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:45 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9:45 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9:45 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Audrey Bartlett
My husband and I love this place. We live closer to Butler, so we could easily go to Main Street Pizza. But their food just does not compare to Papa’s Pizza, and we’d rather drive for a little longer and get excellent food and service, every time.
… more
Stacie Moore
Never saw a Philly steak look like this. And this was after they fixed what was wrong with it. It cMe with peppers and onions and I asked to add mushrooms. When I got it there were no mushrooms and the peppers and on ions weren’t even cooked. When I said something to the cashier/ waitress she said the were cooked but the obviously were not she asked did I want them to fix it I said yes. When they brought it back you can see the results. All they did was put mushrooms on top and stick it in the oven again and burnt the meat or at least dried it out even more. When I tried to get the waitress’s attention she said what. That what was heard by the person that was sitting at my tables telephone companion. That’s when I knew I just needed to get my money back and leave. I had convinced my friend not for us to eat in Atlanta but to go to this great pizza place on the way back to Americus I guess I was remembering Something That Never Was because I never been there before and got treated so poorly. The only reason that it has three stars is because my friend really enjoyed her BBQ Hawaiian pizza
… more
Justin Haydock
I am a truck driver and was just passing through. Ordered an X Large pizza to go. While waiting for the pizza the staff was super friendly. The pizza was absolutely delicious. Not greasy, not too much sauce, just perfect. If I am ever around this town again I will most definitely be back.
… more
Lisa Goldman
Usually the younger staff are nice and my order taste great but I guess it depends on who totals up your order how much it costs. An under $10 item usually, was over $10 today. My item seemed alil light weight also, as if someone only put the bare minimum of cheese, mushrooms etc.
… more
David Bowen
Got a calzone for lunch. First time going, service was decent and food was good.
… more
Jimmygunzs Pelly
Best pizza I had since I left nj .. good pizza is hard to come by here!
… more
A brother in Christ
The square pizza here is pretty good. It’s a pan style pizza with crusty-baked cheese around the edges, which I really like. They will even make any specialty pizza half one type and half another for you. I got a Philly on one side and a chicken Mediterranean on the other one time.
… more
Nicole Hulsman
Food is good but service sucks. Really slow too….we waited outside a long minute before our food came out. Sigh. Was late for work.
… more
Ty Smith
I am not a big fan of the pizza but my family loves it. I actually like the piggy sticks, but every time I get them, they are not temperature hot like the pizza. I have to heat them back up once I get home and that should not be the case to hot, fresh, ready food. I will try the food again though to possibly give a better rating.
… more
JEFFERY GRINDLE
Great pizza. A little pricey.
… more
… View more