Based on 197 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
Address:
16541 San Carlos Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33908
Phone: (239) 415-0220
Website: http://pastabilitiesrestaurant.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Nicole Pocol
Wow. Meal and service couldn’t have been better for our party of 8. Simply amazing. All of the cheeses and flavors were fresh and delicious. The noodles in every dish was cooked perfect. The seafood is all wild caught, no farm raised fish. Shrimp and scallops were divine. Any say enough good things. It makes me sad for the establishment and owners to think of how many people have passed this place up due to the name or what it looks like from the outside. An absolute gem. Authentic Italian food at its finest.
… more
bublehed (Bublehed)
We loved this family run restaurant. The food and service was excellent. They are really taking care during this Covid19 outbreak. Tables are spaced apart, the staff wears gloves and masks. The food was just as impressive . We had 3 baked seafood entries all were excellent.
… more
Daniil K.
This establishment has a roadside sign that reads “Best Italian cuisine at SWFL”. this is a complete and blatant lie !!! this is the best Italian cuisine in all of Florida. I have been to Florida many times, but I can confidently say that I have never met such excellent service in these parts. Everything was amazing, from the lovely staff to the gourmet food worthy of the Michelin stars. Cozy, warm and welcoming. There are no wishes, it cannot be better. Thanks to everyone: Heidi the waiter and the hostess, unfortunately I forgot her name. It is impossible to imagine a better ending to the evening than a visit to this diamond establishment. You are super, although I’m usually picky about the establishments. Thank you for your work and for being so responsive to your clients. 15/10.
… more
Julianna
Absolutely love this place. They make you feel like family. The food is soooo good and the staff is great with customer service. We had the sampler plate and added meatballs/sausage. The soup had so much flavor. We will definitely be back.
… more
Raegan Linster
Overall, Pastabilites was a great experience! It’s definitely a more intimate, “fine dining” type of place, but you can be casually dressed and not stick out. Our waiter Marc was most helpful and friendly, and all the staff there was just awesome. We were constantly checked on, our water glasses never got lower than half empty before they were filled up, and the food came out super quick considering it’s an Italian Seafood place. And let me say, there are certainly many “pastabilities” of entrees to choose from! Really though, there was a ton of options, from veal to duck to all kinds of seafood and the like. Their house salad had a homemade dressing that was shockingly good, it would’ve made any salad taste better. I got the seafood trio which had shrimp, scallops, and calamari over pasta. I really enjoyed it! The scallops and shrimp were a bit over cooked, but the flavoring was so good that I didn’t mind, I really enjoyed them anyways. The calamari was definitely the best part, they were just fantastic. My dad got the veal, and he was it was really good. They are known for their cheesecake, so of course we tried the Blueberry one. It was pretty good, a lighter, fluffier cheesecake that wasn’t so dense so you didn’t feel as stuffed eating it. Not the best ever but decent! They are also definitely on the spendier end costwise, but it’s high quality food ask service you’re paying for. I would happily come back here.
… more
Eti Khang
Wow, thank you so much for the fantastic food and great night we had atxyour place. Pastabilities was recommended by many locals. It’s a very authentic New York style Italian seafood restaurant with amazing service. An absolute must visit if you like good food.
… more
Victor Santoro
Incredible and surprising small Italian restaurant with wonderful staff and even better food. The Veal Elegante was supreme, and for dessert Tartufo ice cream and espresso, just speechless!
… more
Kenneth Merkle
Awesome food ,top notch
… more
Ethan Malcom
I can not tell you enough about the cheese cake. I am not one to order desert while eating out but this was amazing. we even got one togo and had it on the beach!!! ( picture is of it on the beach not at the restaurant)
… more
An Trvlr
My family and I had an excellent meal. Portions are large and everything was delicious. Desert was equally good and they definitely don’t skimp on their wine pours. Service was excellent. My parents always talk about how much they love Pastabilities, and after our experience I’m excited to return on my next visit too.
… more
… View more