Payne’s Pizza & More Menu – Marion, OH

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Marion, OH

Based on 809 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Payne's Pizza & More 43302

Address:
1624 Marion-Mt Gilead Rd, Marion, OH 43302

Phone: (740) 389-4732

Website:

Hours

Wednesday 10:30 AM–9:30 PM
Thursday 10:30 AM–9:30 PM
Friday 9:30 AM–10 PM
Saturday 10:30 AM–10 PM
Sunday 10:30 AM–9:30 PM
Monday 10:30 AM–9:30 PM
Tuesday 10:30 AM–9:30 PM

Menu

Food
Wednesday 14″ 1 Item Pizza & Salad $14.99
Medium Pizza $10.00
Large Pizza $11.50
XLarge Pizza $13.00
Pizza By The Slice $3.00
Half & Half $13.75
Chicken Bacon Ranch $15.00
Big Daddy $13.75
Chicken Alfredo $13.75
Payne’s Supreme $12.75
Abbie’s Pig Pizza $13.75
Vegetarian $12.75
Taco Pizza $12.75
Hawaiian $12.00
GC Pizza $8.00
Regular $7.00
Honey BBQ $7.00
Spicy $7.00
Half BBQ Pork $6.25
Half BLT $6.50
Half Breaded Chicken $6.75
Half Chicken Bacon Ranch $8.00
Half Club $6.25
Half Grilled Chicken $6.50
Half H/C/S $6.00
Half Ham & Cheese $6.00
Half Ham & Turkey $6.00
Half Italian $6.25
Half Meatball $6.00
Half Pizza $5.75
Half RB Combo $6.50
Half Reuben $6.00
Half Roast Beef $6.00
Half Steak $6.50
Half Stromboli $6.00
Half SW Chicken $6.50
Half Taco $6.00
Half Tuna $6.00
Half Turkey $6.00
Half Veggie $5.75
Whole BBQ Pork $12.00
Whole BLT $12.00
Whole Breaded Chicken $12.50
Whole Chicken Bacon Ranch $15.00
Whole Club $11.75
Whole Grilled Chicken $12.00
Whole H/C/S $11.00
Whole Ham & Cheese $11.25
Whole Ham & Turkey $11.00
Whole Italian $11.50
Whole Meatball $11.00
Whole Pizza $10.25
Whole RB Combo $12.00
Whole Reuben $11.00
Whole Roast Beef $11.00
Whole Steak $12.00
Whole Stromboli $11.00
Whole SW Chicken $12.00
Whole Taco $11.00
Whole Tuna $10.75
Whole Turkey $11.00
Whole Veggie $10.25
Spaghetti $6.00
Spaghetti Combo Meal $9.50
Chicken Parm $9.50
White Sauce Linguine $7.50
Lasagna $10.00
Grilled Chicken Salad $7.50
Chef Salad $7.50
Chicken Caesar Salad $7.75
Veggie Salad $6.50
Greek Salad $7.00
Taco Salad $7.00
Dinner Salad $3.50
Cream Of Potato $4.00
Broccoli & Cheddar $4.00
Chicken Noodle $4.00
Chili $4.00
Vegetable Beef $4.00
Garlic Bread $1.75
Garlic Cheese Bread $2.25
Macaroni Salad $3.49
Coleslaw $3.00
Bread Sticks $3.50
Nacho Supreme $6.50
Chips $1.00
Adult Chicken Strips $8.25
Dessert Pizza $9.75
Cookie $1.00
Slice Of Cheesecake $4.50
Kids Spaghetti $3.50
Kids Chicken Strips $6.00
Kids White Sauce $3.50
Dipping & Side Cups $0.00
BLT Half $8.00
BBQ Pork Half $8.00
Club Half $8.00
Ham & Cheese Half $8.00
Ham & Turkey Half $8.00
Italian Half $8.00
Ham, Cheese & Salami Half $8.00
Meatball Half $8.00
Pizza Sub Half $8.00
Roast Beef Half $8.00
Roast Beef Combo Half $8.00
Reuben Half $8.00
Turkey Half $8.00
Taco Sub Half $8.00
Stromboli Sub Half $8.00
Tuna Half $8.00
Veggie Half $8.00
Soup And Dinner Salad Special $6.50
On The Side Ranch $0.50
On The Side Mayo $0.50
On The Side Italian $0.50
On The Side Pizza Sauce $0.50
On The Side Cheese $0.50
On The Side Garlic Butter $0.50
On The Side Bbq Sauce $0.50
On The Side Hot Sauce $0.50
On The Side Salsa $0.50
On The Side Sour Cream $0.50
Drinks
Fountain Pepsi $2.89
Fountain Diet Pepsi $2.89
Fountain Mountain Dew $2.89
Fountain Diet Mt. Dew $2.89
Fountain Mug Root Beer $2.89
Fountain Dr. Pepper $2.89
Fountain Orange Crush $2.89
Fountain Lemonade $2.89
Fountain Unsweet Tea $2.89
Fountain Raspberry Tea $2.89
Fountain Sweet Tea $2.89
Fountain Cherry Pepsi $2.89
Fountain Starry $2.89
Kids Drink $1.50
2-L Pepsi $3.25
2-L Diet Pepsi $3.25
2-L Mountain Dew $3.25
2-L Mug Root Beer $3.25
2-L Dr. Pepper $3.25
6 Pk Pepsi $6.50
6 Pk Diet Pepsi $6.50
6 Pk Mountain Dew $6.50
6 Pk Starry $6.50
6 Pk Mug Root Beer $6.50
6 Pk Dr. Pepper $6.50
6 Pk Orange Crush $6.50
Can Pepsi $1.50
Can Diet Pepsi $1.50
Can Mountain Dew $1.50
Can Starry $1.50
Can Mug Root Beer $1.50
Can Dr. Pepper $1.50
Can Orange Crush $1.50
Water $1.50
Fruit Punch Gatorade $1.75
Lemon-Lime Gatorade $1.75
Cool Blue Gatorade $1.75
Orange Gatorade $1.75
Orange Rockstar $2.75
Lemonade Rockstar $2.75
Silver Ice Rockstar $2.75
Punched Rockstar $2.75

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

The Goat
I had ordered a meatball sub…..when the menu description said meatball sub…I can honestly say I fully expected the meat to be ball shaped…this particular delicacy seems more like a quarter or half ball, or meat disc sub…meat slice sub?? This place used to be sooo good but this was our third and final try.

… more

Douglas Pennington
I ordered a Stromboli and it was on a bun instead of a crust folded over the toppings. The bread was so hard around the edges that it couldn’t be eaten. When I called to complain they hung up the phone on me. There was very little pizza sauce and very little cheese on it. I don’t recommend anyone to order or eat here. My mother ordered cream of broccoli soup and she got melted cheese with just a couple little pieces of broccoli in it. The soup was disgusting to even taste.

… more

Jessica Houser
Ordered kid’s spaghetti and one was an ok amount but one had about 20 pieces of pasta under the cheese that was burnt to the bottom of the container. I realize the meal isn’t expensive but neither is pasta. It said “half sized portion” on the menu. I can’t imagine an adult sized portion only being twice this.

… more

HolyBrainChild
They have great food, but, struggle with accuracy, and usually forget about the salad lol staff is very friendly and helpful.

… more

TtvDrakyll1972
After new management I ordered 2 pizza’s, 2 subs an Italian and a club total around $67 when received food the club had no mayo but the Italian did and no Italian dressing. Told owner if he could find mayo on my club I’d gladly pay him $67 more for the food he laughed and said he made it and knew it was there but would rather not have my business…his loss never ordering again

… more

Carrie Warner
This ultimately my most favorite place in marion to eat when I go out, I love the people who work here and everyone is always friendly! And I’ve gotta say hands down best pizza ever thank you guys for all your hard work!!

… more

Devon Greathouse
Their pizza pies absolutely slap; great stuff. My family prefers them. Some times the website doesn’t accept orders and this hurts my heart.

… more

Toree Enderle
WORST PIZZA PLACE IN TOWN. DO NOT ORDER HERE. I ordered two subs and a dessert pizza. All of it was horrible!! Tasted almost bad and there wasn’t barely any filling on the desert.

… more

John Edwards
One of our favorite pizza places. The food is excellent and at a fair price. The restaurant is very clean, as are the restrooms.

… more

M Motter
Have had lunch here a few times. Great subs, pizza and salads. Friendly staff and homey atmosphere. Great food for the $$.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch