Pelican Jo’s serves New York style pizza with the best ingredients and fresh dough made daily. Unlike our competitors we offer free local delivery and are locally owned and operated. We have been serving the Windsor community for 12 years and the Milliken and Johnstown communities for 3 years.
Based on 411 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
263 Eastman Park Dr, Windsor, CO 80550
Phone: (970) 686-7297
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Braden
We ordered 3 calzones and one of them was about half the size of the other two. We order food here fairly regularly so we knew this one was undersized. We took it back to try to have it fixed but was told they were the same amount of food, amount of dough, amount of toppings. And they didn’t want to help me out. I’ll add photos so you can decide if this was the same amount of food. Also, last time two of our calzones had jalapeños instead of green pepper. Quality control feels like it’s going down.
… more
Nikki N
Always good pizza and desserts! The brown sugar brownie is the best dessert. Had our delivery order mixed up with another customer on accident but I didn’t call to notify them and happily had whatever the wrong order was. I was surprised to hear the door 30 minutes later and they kindly brought a freshly made pizza that I did order earlier. This was so nice of them to do!! I really appreciate the effort and time they provided, especially on a weekend night.Thank you for providing tasty food and excellent service!
… more
Natalie Plaszewski
This was our first time here and we gave it a try. My husband was disappointed that there wasn’t cheese over the veggies to keep them on the pizza, and all the toppings just fell right off. He said it was like basically eating a salad on a pizza. Mine was alright. The staff was friendly, the timing on the website was accurate.
… more
Ashley
We ordered online today and the order was really messed up when we called they said it didn’t go through online I ordered an Italian sub and there was no sauce which it comes with and also no onions. She said sorry and then hung up on me. I feel like it’s poor customer service to not make it right too bad because I order frequently and I’ve never had a bad experience until now
… more
Jack Jacobson
This place is great! I have been here for both takeout and dine in. The food tastes excellent, and the service is reasonably fast. The people who work there are amazing. One of them was even kind enough to give us some extra free pizza, when they were just gonna throw away some extra. I would defiantly recommend coming here if you want to get some great pizza without having to go to a large chain like dominos.
… more
Justin Nolte
Tonight was our first time going to this location. The pizza itself was pretty good. We got a standard pepperoni and sausage pizza and it was pretty decent. A little on the greasy side but I don’t mind that.
… more
Maggie
The garlic knots were amazing. Service was really quick and the food was made very fast. Everyone was super kind! 10/10 recommend
… more
L Herrera
I have been here twice. The first time was good. The calzone was tasty, but the exterior of the dough/crust was a bit charred. Nothing to post about, though, so I decided not to dwell on the teenage cook pulling ingredients out of the line bins and eating while he was preparing other people’s food (gross). I’m here a 2nd time and this time I’m posting…about how I ordered off the menu, minus an ingredient. Then I had a hankering for extra mushrooms (since I took something off)…and was told that would be $2 up charge! Lol. So, the minus ingredient didn’t balance out the extra ‘shrooms? Pass. ?? Annoying to customers and a silly hill to die on.
… more
Dustin Sellmer
I ordered from the Milliken location 3/16/23. I ordered 12 pizza rolls and they look like little potatoes. I have ordered from Windsor sense last night. I’ve always received much larger and longer pizza rolls at the Windsor location. They are still great tasting, just miss the original out of Windsor
… more
Laura Bristow
As the years go on, I get more and more disappointed with this place. They missed my order and had to wait. Got home and opened the box to find a burnt pizza. Why would you serve this to anyone? They obviously had to see the pizza when they put it into the box.
… more
… View more