Based on 136 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
99 NY-25A #4, Shoreham, NY 11786
Phone: (631) 744-3344
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–8 PM |
Menu
| Our Special Deals | |
| Date Night Any two pasta dishes, bread and salad. |
$37.65 |
| DIY Pie Uncooked dough, sauce, and cheese -perfect for family fun. |
$18.25 |
| Family Dinner Two large cheese pizzas, 10 garlic knots and a 2 liter drink. |
$44.45 |
| WFH Meal Any sub, sandwich, or wrap with fries and a drink. |
$19.40 |
| Appetizers | |
| Spicy Buffalo Wings Hot or mild wings served with Bleu cheese dipping sauce. |
$12.00 |
| Zucchini Sticks Sliced zucchini breaded and fried golden brown served with marinara sauce. |
$12.00 |
| Baked Clams | $11.40 |
| Mozzarella Sticks Deep fried cheese sticks. Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside. Virtually guaranteed to be a table favorite! Served with a side of marinara sauce. |
$12.00 |
| Stuffed Mushrooms Stuffed. |
$12.00 |
| Fried Ravioli Fried. |
$12.00 |
| Fried Calamari Battered calamari deep fried and served with a spicy tomato dipping sauce. |
$15.95 |
| Bruschetta Alla Pellegrino Toasted garlic bread topped with fresh plum tomatoes, basil, olive oil and fresh Mozzarella. |
$12.00 |
| Eggplant Rollatini Thinly sliced eggplant and lightly fried, stuffed with ham, Ricotta cheese and baby mushrooms. |
$15.95 |
| Godfather Bread Roasted red peppers and melted Mozzarella cheese on top of garlic bread. |
$9.70 |
| Combo Platter 4 spicy wings, 4 Mozzarella sticks, 8 zucchini sticks and 2 baked clams served with Bleu cheese and marinara sauce. |
$21.65 |
| Chicken Fingers & Fries With fries. |
$12.00 |
| Salads | |
| Italian House Salad Mixed Greens, tomatoes, black and green olives, roasted peppers and Mozzarella cheese. |
$9.15 |
| Caesar Salad Fresh Romaine lettuce with our special Caesar dressing and homemade croutons. |
$10.25 |
| Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Our traditional Caesar topped with grilled chicken cutlet. |
$13.15 |
| Traditional Greek Salad Black olives, red onions and Feta cheese on mixed greens. |
$13.15 |
| Antipasto Salad Ham, salami, Provolone, tomato, black olives, roasted peppers and Mozzarella cheese on a bed of mixed greens. |
$13.15 |
| Craisin Walnut Salad Mixed greens topped with tomato, black olives, Mozzarella cheese, dried cranberries and glazed walnuts. |
$13.15 |
| Wraps | |
| Mama Mia Wrap Chicken cutlet, red peppers, fresh Mozzarella, lettuce and tomato with balsamic reduction and fresh basil. |
$12.55 |
| Hail Caesar Wrap Grilled or fried chicken, Romaine lettuce, shaved Parmesan cheese with Caesar dressing. |
$12.55 |
| Mama Siciliano Wrap Grilled eggplant, red peppers, fresh Mozzarella, with balsamic and fresh basil. |
$12.55 |
| The Italiano Wrap Salami, ham, Provolone, pepperoni with lettuce, tomato, red pepper, red onion with balsamic dressing. |
$12.55 |
| Buffalo Chicken Wrap Grilled or fried chicken tossed with Buffalo sauce, lettuce, tomato, red onion and Jack cheese. |
$12.55 |
| Chicken Club Wrap Fried chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, American cheese and mayo. |
$12.55 |
| Heros | |
| Meatball Hero With meatball. |
$12.85 |
| Meatball & Sausage Hero With meatball and sausage. |
$13.15 |
| Meatball & Peppers Hero With meatball and peppers. |
$14.00 |
| Sausage Hero With sausage. |
$12.85 |
| Sausage & Peppers Hero With sausage and peppers. |
$14.00 |
| Eggplant Hero With eggplant. |
$12.85 |
| Pepper & Egg Hero With pepper and egg. |
$13.40 |
| Chicken Cutlet Hero With chicken cutlet. |
$14.00 |
| Chicken Club Hero Lettuce, tomato, onion and Mozzarella. |
$14.25 |
| Veal Cutlet Hero With veal cutlet. |
$15.70 |
| Shrimp Hero With shrimp. |
$15.70 |
| Veal & Peppers Hero With veal and peppers. |
$16.55 |
| Italian Combo Hero Ham, Provolone, Genoa salami, black olives, onions, red pepper, lettuce, tomatoes, and topped with shredded Mozzarella, balsamic vinegar and oil. |
$14.00 |
| House Special Hero Fried chicken cutlet, roasted red peppers, fresh Mozzarella on a toasted hero (no sauce). Served with balsamic vinegar & oil. |
$15.40 |
| Paninis & Calzones | |
| Fresh Baked Cheese Calzone Stuffed with fresh Ricotta cheese, Mozzarella and Parmigiano. |
$12.00 |
| Chicken Panino Fried chicken cutlet, fire roasted red pepper and fresh Mozzarella on our homemade bread. |
$12.00 |
| Pepperoni Pinwheel With pepperoni. |
$4.30 |
| Pizza Pops | |
| Chicken Parmigiano Pizza Pop With chicken Parmigiano. |
$12.00 |
| Broccoli Pizza Pop With broccoli. |
$12.00 |
| Sausage & Peppers Pizza Pop With sausage & peppers. |
$12.00 |
| Spinach Pizza Pop With spinach. |
$12.00 |
| Pepperoni Pizza Pop With pepperoni. |
$12.00 |
| Meatball Pizza Pop With meatball. |
$12.00 |
| Pasta | |
| Pasta With Oil & Garlic With oil and garlic. Served with salad and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$14.25 |
| Tomato Pasta Served with salad and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$14.25 |
| Pasta With Fresh Plum Pomodoro Sauce With fresh plum pomodoro sauce. Served with salad and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$17.10 |
| Pasta With Meat Sauce With meat sauce. Served with salad and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$19.40 |
| Pasta Bolgonese Ground beef with tomato, herbs and a touch of cream. Served with salad and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$20.55 |
| Pasta With Clam Sauce Red or white. Served with salad and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$20.55 |
| Pasta With Sauteed Broccoli With Oil & Garlic With sauteed broccoli with oil and garlic. Served with salad and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$19.40 |
| Pasta With Sauteed Broccoli In A Fresh Ricotta Cream Sauce With sauteed broccoli in a fresh Ricotta cream sauce. Served with salad and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$20.55 |
| Pasta Alfredo Sauce White cream sauce. Served with salad and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$20.55 |
| Pasta Ala Vodka Pink vodka sauce. Served with salad and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$20.55 |
| Baked Pasta | |
| Baked Ziti | $18.85 |
| Stuffed Shells | $18.85 |
| Homemade Lasagna | $18.85 |
| Cheese Or Spinach Manicotti | $18.85 |
| Ravioli | $18.85 |
| Pizza by the Slice | |
| Stuffed Meat Pizza Slice | $7.45 |
| Regular Cheese Slice Classic cheese or create your own pizza. |
$4.30 |
| Sicilian Pizza Slices | $4.30 |
| Grandma Pizza Slice | $4.30 |
| Pizza | |
| Neapolitan Pizza Traditional round 8 slices with cheese and tomato. |
$21.65 |
| Sicilian Pizza 16 x 16, 12 slices. With cheese and tomato. |
$24.55 |
| Grandma Pizza 16 x 16 12 slices, thin, flaky square crust topped with light Mozzarella cheese, fresh plum pomodoro sauce sauce and grated Parmigiana cheese. |
$25.10 |
| White Pizza X- Large 18″, 8 slices. Ricotta, Mozzarella and Parmesan cheese. |
$30.80 |
| White Broccoli Pizza X-Large 18″, 8 slices. With white broccoli. |
$34.20 |
| White Spinach Pizza X-Large 18″, 8 slices. With white spinach. |
$34.20 |
| Margherita Pizza X-Large 18″, 8 slices. Sweet plum tomato, pesto sauce topped with fresh Mozzarella. |
$30.25 |
| Brooklyn Pizza Thin crust square covered in our garlic knot spread, spices, Mozzarella and topped with our marinara dinner sauce. |
$28.50 |
| Gluten Free Pizza 10″. |
$15.95 |
| Ultra Thin Pizza 12″ Plain or whole wheat. |
$15.95 |
| Cauliflower Crust Pizza 10″. Cauliflower crust. |
$15.95 |
| Pellegrino Specialty Pizza | |
| Baked Ziti Pizza X-Large 18″, 8 slices. Baked ziti. |
$34.20 |
| Spaghetti Bolognese Pizza X-Large 18″, 8 slices. Spaghetti with a hearty meat sauce and a touch. |
$34.20 |
| Penne Ala Vodka Pizza X-Large 18′, 8 slices. Penne with our famous ala vodka sauce. |
$34.20 |
| Chicken Parmigiana Pizza X-Large 18′, 8 slices. With chicken Parmigiana. |
$34.20 |
| Buffalo Chicken Pizza X-Large 18′, 8 slices. With Buffalo chicken. |
$34.20 |
| BBQ Chicken Pizza X-Large 18′, 8 slices. With BBQ chicken. |
$34.20 |
| Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza X-Large 18′, 8 slices. With chicken bacon ranch. |
$34.20 |
| Chicken Broccoli Tomato Pizza X-Large 18′, 8 slices. Sauteed in garlic. |
$34.20 |
| Chicken Bruschetta Pizza X-Large 18′, 8 slices. Tomato, fresh Mozzarella, roasted red peppers and fries chicken topped with balsamic drizzle. |
$39.90 |
| Chicken Francaise Pizza X-Large 18′, 8 slices. Battered chicken in a lemon, white wine sauce. |
$34.20 |
| Tomato Pesto Pizza X-Large 18′, 8 slices. With tomato pesto. |
$34.20 |
| Spinach Pomodoro Pizza X-Large 18′, 8 slices. Sauteed spinach and our famous grandma sauce. |
$34.20 |
| Eggplant Parmigiana Pizza X-Large 18′, 8 slices. Eggplant covered with tomato sauce, Mozzarella cheese and topped with Ricotta cheese. |
$34.20 |
| Italian Salad Pizza X-Large 18′, 8 slices. Topped with shredded Mozzarella. |
$31.95 |
| Greek Salad Pizza X-Large 18′, 8 slices. Iceberg lettuce, black olives, red onions, tomato and cucumbers topped with Feta cheese and oregano. |
$31.95 |
| Grilled Chicken Caesar Pizza X-Large 18′, 8 slices. With grilled chicken Caesar. |
$34.20 |
| Chicken Marsala Pizza X-Large 18′, 8 slices. Chicken sauteed with mushrooms and a Marsala wine sauce. |
$34.20 |
| Sauteed Vegetable Pizza X-Large 18′, 8 slices. Spinach, broccoli, mushrooms, peppers and onions sauteed in Garlic and olive oil. No sauce needed for this delight. |
$39.90 |
| Caprese Pizza Fresh tomato topped with basil, fresh Mozzarella, roasted red peppers and balsamic reduction. |
$41.05 |
| Crispino Pizza X-Large 18′, 8 slices. Thin crust Sicilian topped with plum tomato, fresh Mozzarella, roasted peppers, and fresh basil. |
$38.75 |
| Stuffed Meatlover Pizza X-Large 18′, 8 slices. Ham, salami, pepperoni, sausage, meatball, Provolone and Mozzarella, sauce on the side. |
$44.45 |
| Some of Our Favorites | |
| Chicken Rollatini Thinly slice chicken cutlet breaded and stuffed with prosciutto, baby mushrooms and fresh Mozzarella. Served with pasta and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$22.80 |
| Penne Capriciosa Sauteed chicken tenders in a vodka cream sauce with artichoke hearts, sun-dried tomatoes and topped with fresh Mozzarella. Served with pasta and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$22.80 |
| Chicken Francaise Tender medallions of chicken sauteed in a lemon butter sauce. Served with pasta and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$22.80 |
| Chicken Breast Parmigiana In a tomato sauce and Mozzarella cheese. Served with pasta and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$21.65 |
| Veal Cutlet Parmigiana In a tomato sauce and Mozzarella cheese. Served with pasta and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$25.10 |
| Veal Francaise Tender medallions of veal sauteed in a lemon butter sauce. Served with pasta and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$26.25 |
| Eggplant Parmigiana Breaded eggplant in a tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese and italian seasonings. Served with pasta and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$21.65 |
| Eggplant Rollatini Breaded eggplant stuffed with Ricotta cheese, ham and baby mushrooms in a tomato sauce. Served with pasta and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$22.80 |
| Shrimp Fra Diavolo Very hot. Sauteed in a spicy marinara sauce with garlic. Served with pasta and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$25.10 |
| Shrimp Scampi Broiled shrimp in a white wine, lemon and garlic butter. Served with pasta and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$25.10 |
| Calamari Marinara Very hot. Fresh calamari sauteed in olive oil with fresh plum tomatoes and garlic. Served with pasta and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$25.10 |
| Chicken Marsala Sauteed with mushrooms and Marsala sauce. Served with pasta and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$22.80 |
| Veal Marsala Sauteed with mushrooms and Marsala sauce. Served with pasta and homemade garlic knots or bread. |
$26.25 |
| Kid’s Menu | |
| Kid’s Pasta | $9.70 |
| Side Orders | |
| Meatballs (3) | $9.70 |
| Sausages (3) | $9.70 |
| Pizza Dough | $6.85 |
| Fresh Baked Garlic Knots | $4.60 |
| Homemade Zeppoli Cinnamon sugar knots are also available. |
$1.15 |
| Homemade Sauce | $6.60 |
| Side Of Sauce | $0.90 |
| French Fries Our delicious French fries are deep fried ’till golden brown, with a crunchy exterior and a light fluffy interior. Seasoned to perfection! |
$5.70 |
| Rice Ball These cheesy deep-fried rice balls are made with diced parsley and cheese. |
$6.30 |
| Cappellini Ball With capellin. |
$2.85 |
| Desserts | |
| Tiramisu | $6.30 |
| All Cakes | $6.30 |
| Ice Cream Truffles | $6.30 |
| Cheesecake | $6.30 |
| Cannoli | $1.75 |
| Chocolate Fudge Cake | $6.30 |
| Drinks | |
| Canned Soda | $2.30 |
| Water | $2.30 |
| Fountain Drinks | $2.30 |
| 2 Liter Bottles Pepsi Diet Pepsi Root Beer Orange Starry Lemon-Lime Iced Tea |
$4.30 |
| 20 Oz Soda | $3.15 |
| Specialty Pizza by the Slice | |
| Baked Ziti | Slice | $6.00 |
| Spaghetti Bolognese | Slice Spaghetti with a hearty meat sauce and a touch. |
$6.00 |
| Penne Ala Vodka | Slice Spaghetti with a hearty meat sauce and a touch. |
$6.00 |
| Chicken Parmigiana | Slice | $6.00 |
| Buffalo Chicken | Slice | $6.00 |
| BBQ Chicken | Slice | $6.00 |
| Chicken Bacon Ranch | Slice | $6.00 |
| Chicken Broccoli Tomato | Slice Sauteed in garlic. |
$6.00 |
| Chicken Bruschetta | Slice Tomato, fresh Mozzarella, roasted red peppers and fries chicken topped with balsamic drizzle. |
$6.00 |
| Chicken Francaise | Slice Battered chicken in a lemon, white wine sauce. |
$6.00 |
| Tomato Pesto | Slice Battered chicken in a lemon, white wine sauce. |
$6.00 |
| Spinach Pomodoro | Slice Sauteed spinach and our famous grandma sauce. |
$6.00 |
| Eggplant Parmigiana | Slice Eggplant covered with tomato sauce, Mozzarella cheese and topped with Ricotta cheese. |
$6.00 |
| Italian Salad Pizza | Slice Topped with shredded Mozzarella. |
$6.00 |
| Greek Salad Pizza | Slice Iceberg lettuce, black olives, red onions, tomato & cucumbers topped with Feta cheese and oregano. |
$6.00 |
| Grilled Chicken Caesar Pizza | Slice Mesclun greens topped with shoestring onion rings and mango slices, raspberry dressing. |
$6.00 |
| Chicken Marsala | Slice Chicken sauteed with mushrooms and a Marsala wine sauce. |
$6.00 |
| Sauteed Vegetable | Slice Spinach, broccoli, mushrooms, peppers and onions sauteed in Garlic and olive oil. No sauce needed for this delight. |
$6.00 |
| Caprese | Slice Fresh tomato topped with basil, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers and balsamic reduction. |
$6.00 |
| Stuffed Meatlover Pizza | Slice Ham, salami, pepperoni, sausage, meatball, Provolone and Mozzarella, sauce on the side. |
$7.45 |
| Half & Half Pizzas | |
| Half & Half Pizzas | $41.05 |
| Homemade Soups | |
| Chicken Noodle Soup | $6.85 |
| Italian Wedding Soup | $6.85 |
| Minestrone Soup | $6.85 |
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Lisa Lichelle Hill
⚡Lisa – UPDATE- 10 ⭐ The box, the pizza, the box, the pizza, THE BOX, THE PIZZA!!! OMG They got a new Holiday Box! Bravo! The Sicilian pizza slice OMG! Heaven in my mouth! You know, That’s how it’s Done! Pelligrino’s Pelligrino’s ✨ The Best! – Lisa Lichelle ✨
… more
Ryan wootle
I wanted to like it as the people working there are nice but wow this is the worst pizza I’ve had in a long time.
… more
joe arcara
Pizza is excellent. And, if you like a Grandma’s pizza, I doubt you will find a better one on Long Island
… more
Fightingagainst Therudeanduncalledfor
Nice people, but 4 dollars for a slice that isn’t any better then Costcos is a little steep.
… more
Tim C.
Patrick makes the best pizzas and his specialty slices are excellent. Clean, friendly and delicious. Thanks again PAL!
… more
Jodi Hunt
Delicious pizza and very friendly people working at the shop. Kids love ordering from here. Best crust and pizza sauce!
… more
Kailyn Champlin
One of the most consistently high-quality pizza places we’ve gone to in the local area. Order from them every week. Love their food, from the pizza to the heroes to the pasta.
… more
john w
Pizza not that good it looks like it’s been sitting out for days I love pizza but I’m sorry they need to do better
… more
Theresa e Sola
Pizza is delicious. Have been going here for at least 20 years and never disappointed. Staff is friendly and attentive.
… more
Kels T
THE BEST CANNOLI’S I HAVE EVER HAD. I wished I lived in the area but if I’m ever back this is a MUST try.
… more
… View more