Penstock Coffee Shop & Roastery Menu – Highland Park, NJ

Type : Coffee shop

Location : Highland Park, NJ

Roasting and serving the best coffee in New Jersey, shipping worldwide.
Penstock is a gateway for stories—where ideas and experiences are freely exchanged and where building community truly connects us.

Quality, craft, and transparency are important. Where your coffee comes from and who you share it with—are everything.

Visit the coffee shop & kitchen for nitro cold brew on tap, single origin coffee brewed to order on the pour over bar, a quick, hot cup of joe, home coffee brewing equipment, single origin chocolate, and scratch-made, wholesome eats and treats to boot.

House-roasted beans fuel the pour-overs & espressos at this chill, laptop-friendly coffee spot. Based on 487 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Penstock Coffee Shop & Roastery 08904

Address:
13 S 3rd Ave suite c, Highland Park, NJ 08904

Phone: (732) 455-2994

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 8 AM–5 PM
Wednesday 8 AM–5 PM
Thursday 8 AM–5 PM
Friday 8 AM–5 PM
Saturday 8 AM–5 PM
Sunday 8 AM–5 PM
Monday 8 AM–5 PM

Menu

Early Eats
Parfait
Organic yogurt from Seven Stars Farm topped with crunchy maple almond granola.
$4.75
Hokkaido Milk Bread Toast
A thick wedge of house-made Hokkaido Milk Bread covered in house-made ricotta and house-made with lemon zest and honey.
$8.99
Penstock Bakery
Dark Chocolate Rye Cookie
Dark chocolate chunks with houseground rye berries, coconut oil, sprinkled with French sea salt.
$3.50
Browned Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie
Chocolate chunks, Nutella, and French sea salt made into a big cookie.
$3.00
Pour Over Coffee
Decaf Oromia Coop, Ethiopia
Decaffeinated by Swiss water process. Hints of strawberry emerge in the fragrance, followed by guava in the cup. While light bodied, the coffee has a chocolatey finish and light acidity making it balanced and refreshing.
$4.00
La Bendicion Farm, Nicaragua
A naturally processed selection of Pacamara beans from our direct trade partner, Luis Balladarez’s farm in Las Segovias.
$4.00
Bottled Beverages
Humankind Bottles
30% thru July (discount already applied). Every purchase supports the building of clean water wells in villages across the world.
$1.79
Pellegrino $1.50
Loose Teas
Blood Orange
2 oz of our blend of hibiscus flowers, blood orange peels, and rose hips
$10.00
Citron Green
2 oz of our lightly flavored green tea with notes of lemon and lime.
$10.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Victoria Kay
Gets busy at peak times, and usually busy. Get there early for the the best selection of baked goods. Best cafe hangout in town. I haven’t had a single complaint and I’ve been here many times. May be pricey to some, but it’s great quality that I’m glad to pay for as a treat. Food is delicious and light, coffee is excellent. Gluten free options etc.

… more

shrinidhi navale
Got the iced latte with oat milk. Easy to customize/substitute with coffee.

… more

Bowie Chung
This is the type of local coffee shop that seals the deal for someone to decide to move to the neighborhood.

… more

Ylsme Her
I personally did not like it. I didn’t think we were served fresh coffee, I took a sip and that was it, didn’t even finish half of my so called capuccino. The place is not going to be what you expect, where you can have coffee and enjoy it. Not big enough to accomodate all patrons since most just stay there longer than normal so don’t expect too much on their coffee and the place itself. Great for those that loved their coffee and the place but this is an honest review from a coffee lover.

… more

Dan Acosta
Always enjoy each visit here. The baristas are so talented and kind! Truly one of the best spots around if you are seeking quality beans and coffee experience.

… more

Shravankumar Hiregoudar
Delicious coffee and kind staff! Love the vibe of this cafe!

… more

Marina Dmitrieva
Girls gave me an attitude because I left a tip less than 1$ it took forever for them to make my cappuccino lead was broken and cup was not full coffee itself tasted very sour I had to throw it away. Very unpleasant experience.

… more

Karen Drake Alvarez
This is a cute, hometown type coffee shop. They have awesome lattes! I love their fall specials, pictured here is the apple maple latte. Online ordering is convenient if you’re on the go. If you can stay and dine in, then they have a delightful playlist and a nice vibe. I also love looking at the latte art. On the weekends they have cruffins (croissant dough made into a muffin) and other delicious pastries.

… more

Benjamin Schellack
House made bread, house pickled onions, and perfectly proportioned/flavored. Best avo toast at any coffee shop I’ve had.

… more

Richard Lehman
Super chill place with great coffee and pastries. Everyone is fun and helpful, see the latte art, and Haley was absolutely the most incredibly awesome when I visited today. To the whole gang, keep up the good work. I can’t wait to come back again soon!!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions