Based on 162 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
2485 Swamp Pike, Gilbertsville, PA 19525
Phone: (484) 732-8433
Hours
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jack Lorenzo
Heard about this place from Giuseppe and Kaitlin (his waitress) from a different restaurant. Had to try it. Now has a beautifully remodeled and decorated interior.
… more
Small Talk Media
The food was great but we were even more blown away by Allie’s service. Incredibly prompt, always smiling, answered all our questions.. you really don’t get service and a smile like that anymore. Thanks Allie for making our experience so great.
… more
Lyndsey Slanec
I’ve eaten here for lunch, nearly every day, for a week—-it’s consistently good. Their pizza is good, their sandwiches are good. I had an arugula prosciutto pizza, quite good.
… more
Sharon McNeill
Had a nice quaint lunch with some good friends today. Our waiter was super friendly and accommodated all of our needs. Good menu, prices are reasonable to mid. Great variety. Presentation was nice and servings were great. I left very full and satisfied. The atmosphere is very nice, casual but aesthetically pleasing. I’d never been to All Stars but have a feeling it’s quite different. There is dining on the second floor as well. Would recommend.
… more
Rich B
Wanted to try a new spot and we chose a great spot. We sat outside and enjoyed a well prepared meal, can’t wait to go back for the pizza,everything we ordered was delicious!
… more
John Hulik
Ate here the other evening. First our server was never notified about us being sat, so waited 15 minutes till server showed. (Shame on host). Then the server didn’t seem to know too much about the menu. The thing that really took the cake was the amount of oil in our food. There was a 1/4 to 1/2 cup of oil under our pasta. Honestly, for the price, it wasn’t worth it.
… more
Jo Anne Forman
Delicious Marinara sauce! We enjoyed the Pescatore over Angel Hair and the Mussels MarInara over Gluten Free Penne. The side salad starter was cold, crisp and fresh with a very tasty homemade Balsamic vinaigrette.
… more
Charles Phillips
This location has changed hands quite a few times in the past few years, with a range of quality with each new one. I really think this place is gonna make it. They renovated the inside extensively, and it feels like a whole new building. The menu is pretty big with lots of options. The food was delicious and came out really fast and just as we were finishing up the owner came by and gave us cannolis! They were amazing!
… more
Rosalie Clouser
We came as 7 siblings with various spouses, a total of 11. We were seated rather promptly for such a large group. This was a dinner to get together and just support one another. The food was amazing. Options were available for the large percentage of us who must eat either gluten free, dairy free or both. The owner/chef who is also Sicilian came out to speak to us for a few moments. It was amazing to see his love for his trade, his food and people in general. He was gracious and kind. He had no idea he was talking to 7 siblings who had lost their (Sicilian) Mom a few months ago. But his heart was so open and caring. In that itself he was a comfort to each of us. He kindly gave us cannolis freshly made for dessert. What a pleasure after the monumental tasks we have had in going through our mother’s home and preparing it for sale. We so miss her. His care was, as previously stated, a comfort in itself!
… more
Jennifer Eromenok
Went to dinner the night before mothers day and the place was busy but we got seated right away! The service was slow but understandable for it being the night it was. Our food was very good and the garlic know were the best I’ve had in the area. I highly recommend the stuffed mushroom appetizer. Our dinners were very large portion size and very tasty. I would recommend Peppes to anyone looking for really good food and good atmosphere.
… more
… View more