Based on 365 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
✔️ Takeout
Address:
2919 US-206, Columbus, NJ 08022
Phone: (609) 267-0166
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 8 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 8 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 8 AM–5 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Mark Deavult
The South Jersey Legend!
… more
Amy Traberman
BEST PIZZA IN NEW JERSEY! and I’ve tried A LOT! Been going here every Sunday for the past 10 years. Pizza sauce is one of a kind and the slices are nice and thick. I can’t stand the typical New York razor thin slices that taste like cardboard out of a brick oven. Reasonable prices too! (Haven’t raised consistently due to inflation). Awesome friendly staff. pretty much the only pizza I’ll eat. 🙂
… more
Heaven I
The best thing about moving back to NJ is my favorite childhood pizza place ❤️ I drove an extra 20 minutes out of the way to treat myself! The pizza is delicious as always and the customer service is always great!
… more
Stephen P
Its not the old time pizza recipe anymore!!! The crust is like crunchy bread sticks now!!! The soft pizza we all knew for years is gone from here now,i will never pay $28 for that pie never again!!! Bye,bye
… more
Eirete Hall
I personally hate sauce lol but I tried it. Their pies are seriously delicious. The red cream soda is something I get religiously every time I go. Its amazing! The lines can get ridiculous BUT move pretty fast so totally worth it.
… more
Allison O.
A unique, homemade pizza with the sauce on top. If you get a chance to grab a slice and some cherry cola, it’s definitely worth trying out. I can’t wait for the counters to open up again for sitting in to eat, though.
… more
Mal
I’m very confused. There’s no cheese. Only sauce and it tastes like Campbells tomato soup. I have never in my life seen pizza served with no cheese. When we first opened the box I really thought they mixed the order up with someone who ordered a pie with no cheese. Actually couldn’t eat it and had to throw out. First time I’ve never enjoyed pizza. How does this guy have a pizza shop?
… more
janée franklin
So so good! ❤️ We take a 35 minute drive to the Columbus Market just for their pizza & res cream soda. We take a look around just cuz we’re there but we are mostly there for the pizza
… more
Norman Rockwest
How the mighty have fallen. Used to be, arguably, the best pizza in the world. Now it is but the shell of a further champion. The entire place has transformed into marginally good pizza distributed assembly line with little personality, flavor and seating. Not quite sure what happened, but it’s no longer the pizza that drives me to visit. Unfortunately Pete’s pizza is no more. It’s now just pizza, and not even good pizza.
… more
Rusty Ace
Almost identical to Kate and Als. I had to wait a bit longer (30 minutes or so) than originally quoted but they do make a great pie.
… more
… View more