A local, authentic pizzeria brought to you by Chef Nicholas St. Clair & his wife Alison St. Clair, of Top 100 Restaurant in America, Antebellum, in addition to Roland Stanley of Cork It in Gainesville. Peyton’s Pie Company – named after his son, Peyton.
Based on 249 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
5609 Main St, Flowery Branch, GA 30542
Phone: (678) 828-8699
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
12–8 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 12–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–8 PM |
| Thursday | 12–8 PM |
| Friday | 12–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jason Adams
Peyton’s Pies has a very authentic taste. I would rate their pizza one of the highest in Gainesville/ Flowery Branch. You’ll love the craft beer next door and assortment of pies. Located in quaint downtown Flowery Branch Georgia.
… more
Steve Rider
The pizza is amazing but the wings…the wings are ! The wife and I decided to drive over from Hoschton to try Peyton’s after seeing a few friends post about it. It was worth the trip and we will be back. The wings are crispy just like the wife likes and the sauces are delicious. We had them put the sauces on the side. Our pizza was 1/2 classic and 1/2 seahorse. The crust is thin in the middle with a thick outer crust. The sauce is like a chunky marinara and the toppings are fresh. Very cool vibe in downtown Flowery Branch!
… more
Thomas Clark
The best pizza I’ve ever had in Georgia. It’s a little hard to eat being on the floppy side, but the ingredient quality is unbeatable. Easily the best mushrooms I’ve ever had on a pie too!
… more
krystal thomas
DO NOT MISS THIS MEAL!! The absolute best pizza I’ve had outside Italy and the Alabama White sauce wings are something I’ll dream about often! The pizza: has everything! Perfect balance with an insane sauce, fresh ingredients, crunch, chew and you can enjoy as basic or complex a topping combo as you please, it will be memorable! We had the Cheese and the My Honey is Hotter Than Yers. Both were so good we lost words and resorted to moans and gestures to communicate! You can hurt yourself on the pizza and wings alone but PLEASE save room for their homemade desserts (especially the brownie) that will reset your standard of delicious! Going back again tonight with my family because this place was just that good and it gives me a reason that will keep judgment at bay! And that’s just the food! The service was spectacular (thank you Halle and Ashley!) and the live band playing outside the restaurant between it and the brewery added an additional layer of fun and community during the meal. This will be a regular visit! See you there!
… more
Jeb Napier
Been there twice now. I wish I took some pics, but I will for the next time I go. 🙂 I have had the SFC and the Margherita pizzas. Both were awesome. The SFC is pricey but damn it was yummy. The greasy new yorker is great as well. I love the crust, airy and light and crispy. I count Peytons in my top 3 pizza places. Definitely worth trying out if your in flowery branch area. Service has always been good as well. There is not a lot of seating but well worth the wait.
… more
Christopher Barber II
We Love finding New Spots randomly on Yelp and this one does not disappoint. After a good time at a local Winery some good pizza hits the spot. This will be apart of our routine now…hit the Winery, Hit Peytons or vise versa lol. But stop in grab a pie and sit outside and enjoy…and get a lil olive oil put on your pie crust
… more
Jennifer Harlan
We got there right at closing, but the staff was still very kind, courteous and still attentive, unlike the experience next door at Beer Me. Keep up the awesome work!! Pizza was wonderful as always. Your sauce is GREAT!! I had the Wild Farm Green salad for the first time and it was delicious!
… more
Israel Rivera
Amazing atmosphere and food. A truly great authentic Italian style pizza made with a proper matured and proofed dough that is light and gentle on your stomach with premium quality toppings!
… more
Timoteo Ferguson
Best pizza around from a good hot wood fired oven. Connects to Beer Me for added fun. Basic interior, but you are not going there to be on Magnolia Network. Price is Right old school shows always on the one TV gives you good flashbacks. Love this place.
… more
Greg Simpson
The pizza was good but our server rushed us as soon as we were seated. We arrived about 7:50 and they stay open till 9pm. She rushed us to order , when asked why she said they were about to run out of somethings. I noticed they turned away people before 9pm. I am not very happy about how we were treated. Who wants to spend money at a restaurant where it seems they want to push you out the door.
… more
… View more