At Pie in the Sky we are believers in tradition and we build our pizzas with that in mind. Each of our pizzas is made to order to suit your individual taste. We begin with a hand stretched pizza dough, made with 100% virgin olive oil, then topped with our own sauce and a delectable mix of toppings using only fresh produce, top grade 100% beef and pork products and Vermont’s finest 100% Mozzarella cheese. The pizza is then transferred to a stone hearth to bake to a desired crispness.
Laid-back spot serving up casual Italian grub from whole pizzas & slices to hot & cold subs. Based on 486 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
240 Highgate Commons Rd, St Albans City, VT 05478
Phone: (802) 524-5442
Website: https://www.pieintheskyvermont.com/
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jeff Vaughan
Fantastic pizza options and exceptional service. There is so much good food to try! The desserts are worth saving room for! This is far more than a pizza joint.
… more
Christina P
Be warned! Once one discovers the pizza at Pie in the Sky, one will start craving Pie in the Sky. Exceptional pizza with a sauce that is addictive. When we visit we always order the T-Rex with the addition of black olives and sauce. So delicious!
… more
Deedee Hartnett
Sadly I have to say I was deeply upset to find out that this restaurant didnt do home delivery on weekends. I would have definitely given it a better rating. I hope in the future you’ll provide this service.
… more
Juliet “Jay Dubs” Whiskey
Originally a 4+ star review….but I won’t be going here anymore. I’m tired of being asked, every single time, if I want to leave a tip for the staff for pick ups.
… more
M Tryhorn
Been going to this place for years now. Never disappointed. Best pizza in the area as far as I’m concerned. The sandwiches are great also on their homemade bread. Casual, family friendly and the hardworking staff are friendly and courteous. Highly recommended.
… more
Stephen Jablonski
When it comes to pizza, I’ve tried every option available multiple times and Pie in the Sky stands above them all. The pizza is always great quality, ready on time, and reheats well if there are any leftovers. The staff are always quick and courteous. Even when it’s the dinner rush and they’re overwhelmed with calls and customers they act cool and composed. Easily the best pizza in St Albans.
… more
Julie Cook
Don’t bring gift cards. They really don’t like typing the long numbers in the back and they will make you feel like it’s your fault. I get gift cards from my client and will tell them not to get me any. I brought my mother and we both felt like embarrassed. Not enough staff and the waitress was overwhelmed thus not happy with the gift cards.
… more
Ilya B
Got a cheese steak and a Hawaiian pizza. The cheese steak is the best in the surrounding area. Great flavor and very fresh roll. Pizza is great as well, light and not greasy. Is now my go to place for a cheese steak in this area.
… more
Dranton
I’ve ordered from this location for years. For the most part the service has been great and the food good. We’ve tried to branch out a little recently and have been disappointed. What you see below is allegedly a Margarita Pizza. This comes without spinach, without chunks of mozzarella, and was frankly quite a let down. I’ll also note that they add roast beef and mushrooms to their chef salad. I’ve worked I. Good service before and when you order these items this is not what you expect to receive. In their defense their sandwiches are delicious but be very specific about what you want.
… more
Tyler
So within the last 5 months or so pie in the sky has went so down hill and it’s so sad mine and my daughters absolute favorite place to eat up until recently, seems like the new staff had zero customer service skills, my main problem is how openly the staff will trash talk customers with no regards who hears it. tonight’s visit we watched more then half of the extremely young staff bash any customer that came in or any customer that questioned there order. Maybe it’s just me but I feel if those people are spending there money in your establishment they have every right to ask questions about the food they are buying or ask to add or remove certain things they don’t want WITHOUT the staff waiting for them to walk out the door just to blatantly talk smack about them with a dinning room full of other guest who can clearly hear the full conversation. We miss the old staff and the old managers who actually cared about their guests and not just making their money. A good start would be to have a customer service training and maybe hire like one or two adults to supervise the “children”. All in all you know what they say about opinions I guess!
… more
… View more