Easygoing, red-trimmed Italian eatery offering standard pies & sandwiches alongside wings & sweets. Based on 519 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
716 S Broadway, Baltimore, MD 21231
Phone: (410) 522-3222
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–2 AM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Friday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–2 AM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sophia T
One of the very few places in Fells Point where the kitchen is open after 10 pm. I’ve definitely had better calzones, this mushroom chicken one had roughly 6-7 cubes of chicken meat & maybe 5 thin slices of mushrooms total. They also automatically charge a 20% late night service fee. Still love this ✨low vibrational✨ hot steamy cheesy dough
… more
Josh Levey
Good late night pizza spot in heart of Fells Point with indoor and dog friendly outdoor seating, and vegan options including vegan cheese pizza and vegan pepperoni . Pizza was good, staff was quirky
… more
Joe Bullen
The pizza here is tasty if you get extra-extra cheese. The staff here can carry a conversation. However, those were the only positive aspects of our visit. The lady at the register charged us for bottled water, even though we wanted tap water, because she “assumed that’s what we wanted.” The staff left the door to outside wide-open to ensure that the dining room remained a chilly 60 degrees on a February evening. So, we froze through most of our meal until the staff shut the door. The bathroom needs a paper towel dispenser, along with a deep cleaning. Additionally, the restroom was out of hand soap. Even when dining-in, the pizza is served in to-go boxes. Lastly, Cardi-B and Black Bear are not exactly the best music to set the vibe for eating pizza IMO.
… more
Raven Ciera
The pizza was absolutely amazing!!! The crust is fresh, the sauce is perfect and the cheese was the best I’ve had on a pizza in years. I also tried to lox sandwich. The bread was phenomenal. They make it fresh in house and you can tell. The strawberry henny crush was great as well. I will def go back soon! So happy I found the place.
… more
Ali Babayev
What a really helpful employee. Mesut, Mesut Mesut, he is just AMAZING. I’m enjoying my nights at Pie in the Sky. The best place to go in Baltimore Downtown. There is no explanation with words, thank you so much guys!! Everybody in my company loved your service and communication. Best Pizzas, Best Wings, highly recommended place!!!
… more
Suzanne McQuaid
I’m being generous with my stars here, because the vegan calzones were that damn good. Unfortunately, the place has no ambience or a good atmosphere, and they serve everything on paper plates, and in plastic cups, which I really hate. I also really wish the bartender had said something to the guy next to me that was having an entire tinder date on video call, because that was just ridiculous. I will definitely be back for more vegan food, but as carry out only.
… more
Samuel Davie
I think my favorite pizza in Baltimore. The ingredients taste so fresh and I love their steak pizza. The sauce is so unique and I love the sesame seed sprinkles. Just a really well balanced and delicious pie with a delicious crust as well. I also take my tour de pizza cutter for a ride as well when ever I get a Pie in The Sky.
… more
Markita Harris
20$ for margarita is ridiculous
… more
Matt Johnstone
We will start with service, I was greeted immediately by the manager. He was polite and attentive. I ordered a pizza to go. When it came out I had to try it and it was amazing. The sauce perfect. Crust was crispy and it was overall a great pie. If you out in Baltimore don’t be intimidated by the bar set up. The pizza is fantastic
… more
Yoku “Royalt-Y88” S-T
Outstanding restaurant. Having a dairy allergy and not being able to eat cheese has been a difficult transition for me and the fact I was able to find a pizza restaurant that does vegan cheese and melts it accordingly has been amazing I am extremely thankful I found this restaurant and will continue to order from here my next will be the calzone Lord knows how long I have had one
… more
… View more