Compact strip-mall option for pizza, subs & more, with delivery to a limited area. Based on 156 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.5 stars. Price $
Address:
7117 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068
Phone: (614) 604-9536
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Perry Perry
We ordered this due to trying them at the Tomato Festival pizza challenge…
… more
Mike Sullivan
At first I was nervous to order from these guys due to other negative reviews, but I am seriously happy I decided to give them a try. They taste absolutely delicious and I will 100% be ordering from them again. It tasted good, was a super good price, and they even have mozzarella sticks, so thats an automatic + from me. Seriously, if you enjoy pizza you will absolutely like this place.
… more
Cacheymama
Everything we’ve ordered has been delicious! Gyros and stuffed grape leaves were amazing, shrimp is the best I’ve had. I love how the breading is just a little bit tangy, maybe lemon? My son loves the pizza and he’s very picky! They were out of rice last time so we got fries instead and they were just OK. The only reason I didn’t rate a 5 was because both times we’ve ordered, they forgot an item, but they immediately apologized and gave me a refund. Hoping that it’s because it’s a newly opened store, that they are still just working out the kinks. But I definitely recommend!
… more
Scott
Grandmas pizza used to be so good and one of my favorite pizzas. Over the last 4 or 5 years, this place has gone downhill fast. I’m not sure why this happens but sometimes I get great pizza just like I remember from years ago. Other times, the pizza is downright disgusting and inedible. Today, the pizza was a soggy, disgusting mess, the bacon was barely cooked, the crust was so thin I could see the cheese through it and the sauce was absent unless the greasy mess was the sauce. Mind you, I ordered the pizza well done. Puke, I threw it in the trash. The sub was ok but still not like it usually is. The bread was off not sure what was wrong, just off. Please, fix these inconsistent problems or I won’t order pizza here ever again.
… more
Nicole Hatcher
Had Grandma’s pizza in the past, at work functions but never purchased on my own time till recently. And well now me and my family can’t get enough! Sometimes we order twice on the weekends. Customer service is always great! Pizza is always ready, or coming straight out the oven when I arrive for pickup. Ordering online(Slice) is easy.
… more
Stephanie Brinkman
We just moved to the area and we’re excited to have a piece of home nearby as we are from IL. I was severely disappointed. The Chicago style pizza says nothing online about it being pepperoni and it came with pepperoni. No big deal, we can call and have it fixed, right? WRONG. We weren’t even angry at first because mistakes happen, but then when we called, the gentleman on the phone was incredibly rude. He told us we should have known because it stated online that it’s pepperoni. After reading reviews, this seems to be a common issue. I suggest fixing the website or maybe, just making it a cheese pizza by default. We will not be returning.
… more
Patrick
Placed order online, wait time 15-30 minutes. Arrived in 25 minutes and was told 10 more minutes and ended up waiting another 30. On the way back, realized the chicago style we ordered had pepperoni on it when we ordered just cheese. The dough wasn’t thick at all and didn’t hold at all. Try to pull a slice and everything comes off. Pizza is also very greasy. Not worth the time or money.
… more
Rodney Wollam
This is unquestionably the worst pizza I’ve ever had. And the tuna sub was even worse than that … it caused the hairs on the back of my neck to raise and not in a good way. The chicken philly I got with them? I wasn’t even going to go there. It went straight into the bin.
… more
cassaundra porter
The customer service is as awesome as their pizza. The pizza is a thin crust and it’s covered in pepperonis and I’ve had their sausages as well and then I’ve had the works and they all are really good and filling.
… more
Tamara Hill
Great pizza. Family owned. For those who don’t eat pork… Their sausage, ham, bacon, and pepperoni is not pork. It is either beef or turkey. And it tastes amazingly awesome. Their grilled chicken salad is wonderful too. You can taste the love in their food. Good portions also. And the price is right. My new fav!!!
… more
… View more