Based on 128 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price
Address:
4585 Austin Blvd, Island Park, NY 11558
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Rayna Portnoy
Nice large personal pizzas the type can customize. 3 choices of dough, 3 choices of sauce, pick your cheese ( including a vegan lactose free cheese) . Then pick your toppings at .99 each or $2.99 each premium toppings. Even though the premium toppings are good I think it’s too expensive for a sprinkle of topping for a personal pie. It really adds up fast. We ordered 3 pies with 4 toppings each and 3 waters and it was $47! It is definitely yummy but kind of expensive for pizza.
… more
Vita
Friendly service. Went on labor day and they were still open. The pizza was great, but I knocked a star off for their chicken noodle soup. The soup was lukewarm and didn’t have much flavoring to it.
… more
Tstarr Crafts
Great diy pizza place . Recommend the buffalo chicken pizza and the sangria!
… more
Erin Kalenka
I used to come here all the time and loved it, all though it was a but pricey. The last time I went, they gave us barely any toppings and our 2 pizzas were not cooking all the way through. We emailed the owner and sent a picture of our receipt and of our raw pizza. All he wanted to do was give us $10 towards our next purchase. We asked for a full refund and he stopped responding. I think that Is very wrong considering his food was unsafe to eat and not up to safety standards. I will definitely be taking this further because this is no way to own a business and it is definitely wrong to serve uncooked food and not give a full refund. I will never eat here ever again and i recommend to everyone to never go here.
… more
Myron Allis
This place has amazing options and food. We always get a Gluten Free pizza and the fact that they have a separate oven for cooking them is amazing. They keep everything separate to reduce cross contamination and are some of the friendliest staff. Highly recommend it. As far as portion size, my four year old eats an entire pizza himself.
… more
nina kavesteen
Went there recently to try the food under the new management. It was great. I found out they also have a space upstairs for small parties. I booked for my daughter’s first birthday. All the kids had a great time they all love the food Pizza Pasta and meatballs. Love the place and the service was amazing.
… more
Jeffrey Katz
It is an interesting setup they have here – the concept is great! Design your own pizza, with their big selection of toppings, and their choice of dough. Their “firecracker” dough adds a little spice if you are into spicy. The toppings are all fresh and tasty and added at your whim or you can order a pie with toppings they’ve chosen – either way you seem to get a good, tasty pie to satisfy your craving for pizza.
… more
Ashley Leo
The place used to be great. However, customer service got worse as soon as they turned it into just another restaurant. I can’t blame the waiter, there was only one working at the time, but we waited a while for our pizzas. When we got them they were partially burned, and my vodka sauce pizza didn’t look or taste like one. I’m disappointed.
… more
Joseph Naham
I like this place for a number of reasons. top of the list is the pesto sauce I make my borata cheese and pesto pizza with. I appreciate the layout, I wish the line moved faster, but it moves pretty reasonably for the most part. Great beer on tap selection. I’m going to try their milk shake soon.
… more
Jason Lazarus
Came here for a birthday party – it was really great inside for the event. The staff was super nice and helpful to all of us. Really attentive to all the kids and parents. I took away one star because the upstairs does NOT have a gate across it blocking little kids from falling down a huge flight of stairs. This was brought to management prior to the party, yet they did nothing. Therefore the people who attended the party had to stand guard to stop toddlers from falling and getting hurt. Not a great way to spend your party. The owners should seriously get a locking gate for the top of the steps. This is a lawsuit waiting to happen.
… more
… View more