Compact counter serve providing specialty pizzas, pasta, hoagies & gyros in a bare-bones interior. Based on 155 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
5832 Library Rd, Bethel Park, PA 15102
Phone: (412) 833-5200
Website: http://www.pittzarella.com/
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Busy Busy
Absolutely the worst ever. I knew this place had really gone downhill but tonight I received a gyro supreme. It was put in the oven and toasted?? Like a hoagie and it is completely charred and burnt. I can’t even pick it up because the pita is completely burned dried and falling into pieces. There is no sauce on the gyro either and about 3 pieces of burnt up gyro meat. The pierogies ordered are not fried at all. Just in a pool of oil. Completely disgusting and total waste of money. Update: Do Not use DoorDash to order from them. They deliver on their own so DoorDash will not help if there are issues with your order. I’m so sick of places like this ripping people off I’ll be dealing with my credit card company instead.
… more
Lulu Baum
Absolutely Horrible! I used to live in the area and ordered from there all the time & was in the neighborhood so I thought I’d treat my husband. Wow has it gone down hill. Picked up order and it smelled like burnt fryer oil inside the store. Should’ve turned around and left. Gyro salad had no pita & very little meat. Didn’t even eat one bite after I tasted the tzatziki sauce. Husband’s steak salad was awful, too. Very sad because they used to have amazing food.
… more
Joe Campagna
Stopped here to get a hoagie the other day, the owner was working my bread was stale, and he has the nerve to try and tell me he knows better about licensing as a contractor, when he’s totally wrong. Way I see it if he was any good of a contractor he would be busy doing that and not working in a dead pizza shop that probably barely pays the bills. The arrogance of people .
… more
Nicholas Basile
This place was very good and the employees were very friendly! The pizza is a bit on the thicker side (not quite Chicago style though) and is full of flavor. The deals are very good as well. They forgot to add my Italian hoagie to the order but honestly I didn’t realize it until I got home and didn’t feel like calling them about it since we all had plenty of food without it and I didn’t feel like driving back. They probably would’ve had no problem fixing the issue though. The zucchini sticks, boneless wings, and gyros we had were also top notch and tasted very fresh — give this place a try!
… more
Alexis Pachesky
I worked there not long ago and I can tell you choose somewhere else! They shouldn’t even be allowed open they smoke cigs near the food, cook rotten food and serve it to you , not only that but there pizzas suck!
… more
Amy Rees
Tried to use one of their coupons that I received in the mail “Choose Two”. Person on the telephone said they did not offer that coupon. Read the coupon to her on the telephone. Why would I make the coupon up???Horrible customer service. Will never try to order from here again.
… more
Jessica White
Really nice place to get food. I’ve had sever things off the menu. The pizza quality depends on who is preparing it but over all really good. I ordered the crab cake appetizer today and I was so pleased. Definitely a small jewel that won’t let you down.
… more
Keith Fabus
Used to be great. Last 2 times we’ve ordered the website is not updated with the true prices. We keep being told the owner is working on fixing the pricing but that has been for over 2 months. We ordered a large black olive and mushroom, the pizza was labeled a black olive and mushroom. Yet we opened the box and it was pepperoni and mushrooms. They gyro sauce was watered down. We didn’t waste time calling because we had already fought on the phone with them about the pricing difference for 5 minutes at the beginning of this all. If it improves someone let know, or if they atleast update pricing on the website.
… more
maria damico
absolute garbage food!! if i could give negative stars i would!! the ravioli was like dog food and the garlic bread was burned and stale. The pizza was disgusting it had a brown crust under the sauce! I owned a pizza shop and if i served this kind of food, i would be ashamed. When we called the shop to complain, the person answering the phone did not really care and when i asked to speak to the owner i was told he never comes around. Whoever owns this shop of garbage should maybe consider coming around more often to oversee what is being served at your establishment. In conclusion, save your time and money and go to domino’s and then pick up a can of chef boyardee and you will be happier!
… more
Christine Mcwilliams
Not the place i remember from 10 years ago. The hoagies that we ordered tasted a little bland and stale. The veggies on it were not the freshest. The staff that was working there had hair down to their back and did have hair nets. I have long hair myself but i don’t like the thought of hair in my food. Hopefully better luck next time we order.
… more
… View more