Pizza Barn Menu – Newcastle, WY

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Newcastle, WY

Based on 238 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout

Pizza Barn 82701

Address:
66 Old US Hwy 85, Newcastle, WY 82701

Phone: (307) 746-2874

Website: http://www.pizzabarn.net/

Social Profile:

Hours

Thursday 4–9 PM
Friday 4–9 PM
Saturday 4–9 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday 4–9 PM
Tuesday 4–9 PM
Wednesday 4–9 PM

Menu

Start It Off Right Appetizers
Pickle Fries
Dill Pickles Corn Breaded just right and Deep Fried		 $5.75
Cream Cheese Peppers
Jalapeno peppers stuffed with Cream Cheese Breaded and Deep Fried		 $5.75
Mozzarella Sticks
What’s Better than Fried and Breaded Cheese		 $5.75
Onion Rings
Rings way Cheaper than a Diamond		 $5.75
Popcorn Chicken
Small “Bite Sized” Chicken Pieces Breaded and Deep Fried		 $6.95
Garlic Cheese Bread Sticks
Our Homemade Pizza Dough covered with Garlic and Cheese with Marinara on the side		 $8.00
Breaded Mushrooms
Small “Bite Sized” Whole Mushrooms Breaded and Deep Fried		 $5.75
Hot Or BBQ Wings
There Ain’t no Thing like our Chicken Wings – Make Yours Hot or Make Yours Sweet & Saucey		 $7.00
Sampler Platter
Can’t decide then this is for you (Choose from Pickle Fries, Peppers, Mozzarella Sticks, Onion Rings or Breaded Mushrooms)		 $7.95
On The Side
Baked Potato $2.00
Loaded Baked Potato
Load your Spud with Cheese & Bacon		 $2.50
Loaded Mashed Potatoes
Load your Smashed Taters with Cheese & Bacon		 $2.50
Loaded Fries
Americas Favorite way to have Potatoes, But Even Better with Cheese & Bacon		 $2.95
Fantail Shrimp (3ct)
Hand Breaded Fantail Shrimp		 $4.95
Salad Bar As A Meal
No Lie, Best Salad Bar Around, Plus it includes our Homemade Soups		 $6.95
Add Salad Bar To Any Meal
One Trip to the Best Salad Bar Around		 $2.95
French Fries
Regular, Ranch, Sweet Potato, Curly, Waffle, Buffalo Chips or n Tater Tots		 $2.00
Cup Of Soup
Fresh, Hot & Homemade just like Momma Makes		 $2.00
Side Of Gravy
Country White Gravy or Good of Brown Gravy		 $1.00
Side Of Ranch
Creamy Homemade Ranch		 $0.50
Side Of Jalapenos $1.00
Side Of Pickles
Dill Pickle Chips		 $0.50
Quench Your Thirst
16oz Fountain Pop $2.20
64oz Pitchers Of Pop $5.95
16oz Iced Tea $2.20
8oz Coffee Or Hot Tea $1.50
8oz Hot Chocolate $2.00
8oz Milk Or Juice $2.00
8oz Kids Fountain Pop $1.10
Areas Best Prime Rib
8oz Prime
Not Nearly Enough		 $17.95
12oz Prime
Just Enough		 $22.95
16oz Prime
Left overs go good with eggs in the morning		 $28.95
Spice It Your Way
Seasoning By Request
Lemon Pepper, Joe’s, Cajun, Greek, Seasoning Salt, Blackened, Garlic, & Herb, Poultry
From Land to Sea
8oz Ribeye
Known as the “Beauty Staek”, choice, Aged and Cut to Order		 $16.95
12oz Ribeye
Known as the “Beauty Staek”, choice, Aged and Cut to Order		 $21.95
8oz Sirloin
Delicious Choice Cut of steak that is Tender, Pretty Lean and Bursting with Flavor		 $14.95
Homemade Chicken Fried Steak
Homemade Breading, covered Tenderized Sirloin, Southern Fried to Perfection		 $13.95
8oz Chicken Breast
Un-breaded, Juicy 8oz Butterfly Breast with Choice of Seasoning		 $10.95
8oz Breaded Cod
Battered Deep Fried Golden Brown Cod Fillet		 $13.95
Fantail Shrimp
5 Mouth Watering Hand Breaded Fantail Shrimp		 $13.95
Shrimp Scampi
Saute Shrimp with Garlic, Butter, Freshly Cut Lemon & Lemon Pepper		 $14.95
8oz Salmon Steak
Steamed Wrapped with Butter, Freshly Cut lemons and Lemon Pepper		 $12.95
A Moo Moo Here Cluck Cluck There an Oink Everywhere
Chicken Strips
Breaded, All White Meat Chicken		 $9.95
Hamburger
6oz Patti – Boring		 $6.95
Cheeseburger
6oz Patti wit American Cheese – Still Boring		 $7.95
Bacon Cheeseburger
6oz Patti – Getting Better		 $8.95
Poppy’s Mate (The Ultimate Olive Burger)
Now We’re Taken!!		 $10.95
Black & Blue Burger
A little Spice Covered with Melted Blue Cheese Crumble		 $10.95
Cowboy Burger
Cowboy Up on our 6oz Beef Patty with Ranch,BBQ Sauce, Bacon, Cheese & Onion Rings		 $12.95
Gravy Over All – Hot Hamburger
6oz All Beef Patti on Top of Real Mash Potatoes and Texas Toast Smothered in Good of Brown Gravy		 $9.95
Cowgirl Chicken Sandwich
Chicken Breast topped with Ranch, Bacon, Guacamole, Lettuce & Tomato		 $12.95
Oh My Turkey
Eat Clean, Stay Fit & Eat a Burger To Stay Sane		 $9.95
King BLT
Bacon, Bacon & More Bacon with Lettuce and Tomato		 $9.95
MaMa Mia Burger
It used to be On Top of Spaghetti all Covered with Cheese but we had an idea to flatten our Homemade Meatballs and make a Burger to Please, Covered with Marinara and Cheese if you Please		 $11.95
Straight Out Of Philly
Make it a Combo with Italian Sausage – $2. Shaved Prime Rib Marinated in Our Special Recipe with the Same Dipping Sauce on the Side		 $14.95
Kick’n Burger
Get your taste Buds Kick on a 6oz Patti with Jalapeño Bacon, Jalapeño Chips, Jalapeño Ranch & Jalapeños. Topped with Gouda Cheese & A Side of Guacamole		 $12.95
A Combination Of Magic and Pasta
Homemade Lasagna
The “Italian” Taco – Two layers of Meat, Cheese, Cottage Cheese, our Homemade Marinara in between Lasagna Noodles		 $10.95
Spaghetti
Homemade Marinara over Spaghetti Noodles		 $9.95
Cheese Tortellini
Homemade Marinara over Cheese Tortellini		 $10.95
Cheese Ravioli
Homemade Marinara Cheese Raviolis		 $10.95
Alfredo
Homemade Alfredo Sauce with Parmesan Cheese, Heavy Cream and Garlic. Served with Fettuccine Noodles		 $10.95
Chicken Alfredo
Homemade Alfredo Sauce with Parmesan Cheese, Heavy Cream and Garlic. Served over Fettuccine Noodles & Chicken		 $11.95
Shrimp Alfredo
Homemade Alfredo Sauce with Parmesan Cheese, Heavy Cream and Garlic. Served over Fettuccine Noodles & Shrimp		 $12.95
Cajun Chicken Alfredo
Homemade Cajun Alfredo Sauce with Cajun Seasoning, Parmesan Cheese, Heavy Cream and Garlic. Served over Fettuccine Noodles & Chicken		 $12.95
Cajun Shrimp Alfredo
Homemade Cajun Alfredo Sauce with Cajun Seasoning, Parmesan Cheese, Heavy Cream and Garlic. Served over Fettuccine Noodles & Shrimp		 $13.95
Kid’s Round Up
6″ Single Topping Pizza
Available Toppings: Canadian Bacon, Ground Beef, Sausage, Pepperoni, Onions, Bell Peppers, Mushrooms, Black Olives, Pineapple, Bacon, Jalapenos, banana Peppers & Chicken		 $4.95
Spaghetti
Homemade Marinara over spaghetti Noodles with One Garlic Cheese Bread Stick		 $4.95
Chicken Alfredo
Homemade Alfredo Sauce with Parmesan Cheese, Heavy Cream and Garlic served over Fettuccine Noodles & Chicken		 $6.95
Shrimp Alfredo
Homemade Alfredo Sauce with Parmesan Cheese, Heavy Cream and Garlic served over Fettuccine Noodles & Shrimp		 $7.95
Chicken Nuggets
5 Hand Breaded Chicken Nuggets		 $4.95
Mini Burger
Little Burgers for Little Hands. Two 2oz burgers on a toasty Hawaiian Bun		 $6.95
Corn Dog
Corn Breaded all Beef Hot Dog		 $4.95
New York Style Pizza
Joe’s Supreme
Canadian Bacon, Pepperoni, Beef, Sausage, Bell Peppers, Black Olives, Mushrooms & Onions		 $13.00
Meat Eaters
Pepperoni, Beef, Sausage & Canadian Bacon		 $11.00
Grand Slam Pepperoni
Double the Pepperoni and Extra Cheese		 $11.00
Vegetarian Delight
Onions, Black Olives, Bell Peppers & Mushrooms		 $11.00
Bacon Cheeseburger
Lots of Hamburger, Real Bacon Crumbles, Choice of Pickles		 $11.00
Hawaiian
Canadian Bacon, Pineapple Tidbits & Extra Cheese		 $11.00
Bacon Chicken Ranch
Take off the Sauce & Add Ranch, Chicken & Bacon		 $11.00
Ranch
Take off the Sauce, Add ranch with Extra Cheese		 $10.00
The Barn Mac
Thousand Island, Beef, Onions & Pickles		 $12.00
Cowboy
Ranch, BBQ, Beef, Cheese & Onion Rings		 $13.00
Giant 20 Big Wheel Pizza
Plain Cheese Pizza $22.00
Create Your Own
Cheese-Only
Additional Toppings Each		 $8.00
Load It Up
Canadian Bacon
Ground Beef
Sausage
Pepperoni
Onions
Bell Peppers
Mushrooms
Black Olives
Pineapple
Bacon
Jalapenos
Banana Peppers
Chicken
Calzones
Combo
Cottage Cheese, Cheese Blend, Marinara, Canadian, Bacon, Pepperoni, Beef, Sausage, Bell Peppers, Black Olives, Mushrooms & Onions		 $13.95
Meat
Cottage Cheese, Cheese Blend, Pepperoni, Sausage, Ground Beef & Canadian Bacon		 $12.95
Veggie
Cottage Cheese, Cheese Blend, Onions, Green Peppers, Olives & Mushrooms		 $11.95

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Colin Rankin
We drove through on our way to Devil’s Tower to camp and had a great experience. The hostess turns on the arcade for our kids, and the food was great. The salad bar was perfect and I regret not ordering off the rib bar! Great spot.

… more

Meghan Oesterle
Stopped here on a work trip and it was a lone option for vegan option. Their spaghetti was fantastic! Their sauce tasted homemade and was delicious. Would not recommend the salad bar.

… more

rabi gurung
Not a bad place to dine if you are in Newcastle, Wyoming. Wide variety. I ordered meat eater pizza and it was real good and the serving was generous. Service was prompt and server was very nice. Got my pizza in 10 minutes.

… more

Jennifer Cherney
Great food. Calzone was great. The chicken bacon ranch chowder had a little too much pepper for my liking but it was very

… more

Travis Ukkonen
Great place to have family get-togethers and enjoy some great food too!

… more

Chris Bechtel
10 times better than the captain table in Custer here they let you eat anything on the menu, better service too.. good place even has pizza guy spinning crust in the air.. good floor show.

… more

Kyle Borger
I had a 10″ pizza. It was really good, but a little much for one person. Lots of people here and it seems to be a local hangout which improves the atmosphere.

… more

Amos Self
Great food! Our family loved the wagon wheel sized cowboy pizza! Neat atmosphere and the staff were very friendly. Gotta go again!

… more

jennifer dawson
Don’t let the outside fool you! This place has wonderful food and service! We had a great experience and will dine here again. I only wish they made their own ice cream.

… more

Sam Heckman
I love this place great food. Service is a bit slow but I’ve only went in there when they have been busy. Try the calzones, they are huge and very good

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch