Based on 15 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1227 N Main St, Princeton, IL 61356
Phone: (815) 879-7671
Hours
| Sunday | 4–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
| Thursday | 4–10 PM |
| Friday | 4–11 PM |
| Saturday | 4–11 PM |
Reviews
midwest mogger
Excellent food , pizza was awesome. Staff was friendly and fast . Definitely recommend
… more
Janelle
Ordered pizza….amazing as always to say the least. Anyway, delivery boy, delivered to Tiskilwa tonight about 5:15pm. My dumb ciusin hands him a $26 tio (story for another day). Now this delivery boy is young…. Teenager…. Comes back a couple minutes later beating on the window, wide eyed…. “Do you guys realize you have me a $26 tip??” Instantly I was so impressed by his honesty. You don’t see that much in young kids nowadays. Kudos to his mom, dad, whoever raised this young man…. And kudos to pizza cellar for not only have great pizza, but great staff. I never do reviews, but this young man could not go without recognition. You’re a good person kid!! Keep it up.
… more
Don DeWaele
The pizza was ok, after it cooled and the cheese congealed it stayed on and the pizza was actually better, otherwise the toppings just came off the pizza. The bigger disappointment was the server. She was about as snotty as can be. We had 16 people in our group, she said we can spit up between tables and booths and said she couldn’t put tables together for us. That was fine since the kids wanted a booth anyway. Then she came to get our order, we hadn’t fully decided and while deciding she got upset tore up the order paper and said to call her back when we decided. Once we did order a large cheese & mushroom and a large cheese & sausage. When it came it was a large sausage and large pepperoni. When I told the server it was wrong she argued and said that’s what I ordered. The other members in our group said they heard mushroom so she said she could have some mushrooms added to the top. When she brought the order slip/receipt that said MUSHROOM her attitude seemed a bit more apologetic and didn’t end up changing for the pepperoni with mushrooms thrown on top, but in my opinion, that was too little too late
… more
Venture Lover
Solid customer for 35+ years, and still the BEST pizza I’ve EVER had!! Always consist=Excellent
… more
cohen vetter
they close their kitchen 30+ minutes from when they actually close. this time it was 1.5 hours from closing according to google
… more
Dawn Marciniak
Always yummy, and feels like family when your there .
… more
Greg Grieff
Pizza was excellent! Service was great!
… more
Kyle Owens
I have. Been at the pizza cellar alot thay have good food the help is good an clean
… more
Dennis Chirchirillo
Great pizza and service
… more
Nancy Bornsheuer
Pizza cooked old school way
… more
… View more