Pies, calzones & basic Italian pasta dishes served in a simple counter-serve eatery. Based on 303 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2799 NY-112, Medford, NY 11763
Phone: (631) 758-1589
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Hannah Pollard
Very delicious Alfredo and great portion for the price! Also, the tiramisu looks delicious and great portion for the price as well! They have great weekly deals.
… more
David Perkins
On 5/30/23 I took my contractor to Pizza Corner in the morning around 11 AM. to purchase food for him. He asked the staff if the pizza with a meat was fresh, we were told it was recently cooked. We also purchased another pizza. Upon arriving home we discovered the pizza with the meat was not fresh and probably put in the freezer the night before. The other pizza was excellent. I returned and told the young man at the counter the other gentleman was not truthful about the 2nd pizza. The younger gentleman replied I did not tell you that, but he over heard the conversation and rang me up. Been in the community over 30 year. You can’t run a business well and not be honest. Unhappy customer here
… more
Debora Landolfi
Their grandma pizza is delicious order it with extra sauce and you won’t be disappointed. The sauce is so sweet you can’t stop at just two slices. Ordered their Sicilian once not my fav but I def do order their grandma pizza once a month.
… more
John Tropiano Jr.
When people say “hole in the wall” this is kinda the best case. There plenty of seating space and they work quick(not too fast) but they do a great job of getting you your food.
… more
Jennifer Figueroa
I bought a plain slice for $3.50. it was missing dough. I could see through the bottom. It slumped over the second I picked it up from the soft crust. I had it replaced, no questions. He could see the slop.
… more
Selina Tropiano
Pizza Corner claims to have the best pizza in town. It’s a claim that a lot of pizza restaurants make, but they may actually be telling the truth. With a well-seasoned crust, balanced sauce and perfectly melted cheese that delivers a pull straight out of a commercial – they have one of the most perfect slices on the Island. Upon first bite there’s even a fragrance that enhances the taste of oregano as you chew.
… more
MICHAEL CASCIO
Delish pizza BUT this place is starting to annoy me. New ownership might be why!! I ask for a slice warm and she put it in for 2min as I went to sit at the furthest table away. She (or someone) put it on red tray and put it on a table further away from me (to my back so I couldn’t see) without saying anything… I get up to go for my slice and see a roni slice at table and just ignore it and I got to front and she points at the slice. I did started to ask “why would?”…(you put it there if I’m over there) but that was it. PLUS the tray was dirty (as you can see by the white piece of whatever it is by soda)…… ALSO the past few weeks the blonde girl that normally is here with the raccoon eyes always grabs my money out of my hand like she mad at the world!! I’ll take my $$ somewhere else (which is probably what they want anyway)
… more
F M
We really love this pizza shop. The food is delicious and one of a few pizza shops that our WHOLE family can get what they want and be satisfied and happy with, no matter what is ordered. We used them to cater a party a few years back and everyone really loved the food and kept asking who was catering. Sometimes the wait is a bit longer than the time given to pick up an order but in all honesty, for our family, it’s worth the wait and I don’t mind as long as the food is as amazing as it always is. The staff are all so kind and helpful in our experience and always going above and beyond. Personally, I think medfords pizza corner is awesome and hope it stays that way!
… more
Travis Heller
Can’t beat Sicilian Sunday. Get it almost every Sunday. The pizza is hot out miss with how much cheese they put on it but other than that it’s delicious.
… more
Darryl Manning
On October 7, 2020 I have been a loyal customer and received burnt pizza pie. Called the Pizza corner & would not give me another pie for my inconvenience & tasting burnt, very hard, burnt crust.I will not go back for burnt food & not be a satisfied customer just asking for another pizza pie. I would hope for the price of a pie I could enjoy to its last bite…. BUT I GUESS PIZZA CORNER DOESNT APPRECIATE MY BUSINESS OR THEIR QUALITY OF PIE
… more
… View more