Basic regional chain with an extensive menu of specialty pizzas, subs, wings & calzones. Based on 228 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1203 N Croton Ave, New Castle, PA 16101
Phone: (724) 652-7355
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–7 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Shane Eaton
I used to live across the street from here about 9 years ago and I frequently came here. I admit the food is fantastic. The service wasn’t so great though. Our bathroom was being renovated at one point so sometimes I would come to use the restroom and sometimes when I did I would also order some food. One of the employees said I couldn’t use the restroom anymore and was very rude about it. So I just quit giving them my business. I don’t live around here anymore but I’d love to find a place that made a vegetable pizza like this place does.
… more
Eisie Buddaie
Another great pizza joes. Friendly employees. Closes early
… more
Aunt Nessie
Always clean with friendly prompt employees. Service is quick whether ordering delivery through door dash or calling for pick up. Always have had a good experience. Food was always perfect as it should be. Couldn’t ask for a better experience.
… more
Leanna Addair
Ordering is always so easy and the employees are always nice and helpful. They have good food and different food to choose from then other pizza places!
… more
denny c
A variety of delicious pizza by the slice and an affordable lunch special.
… more
John Wesner
Make sure you get the Veggie Pizza. The best.
… more
Anne Jones
I’ve ordered wings from Croton Ave Pizza Joe’s that were really good but tonight I ordered a dozen Hot Garlic 30 minutes before they closed and they didn’t have any garlic and they were not hot. No flavor at all. I would like to tell you NOT to order when kids are working and it’s almost closing time! VERY DISAPPOINTED!!
… more
Stephanie Cunningham
I am not one for leaving comments or reviews, but i decided to make an exception this instance. I was very impressed during my last visit at the Croton Ave location. Speaking as someone who had many years in management in the food service industry, I always am impressed whenever I see a well run restaurant and see guests leaving happy and satisfied. This evening it took the franchise owner rolling up his sleeves and getting behind the line making food to make this happen. It’s very rare when you see a franchise owner in the back of the restaurant, let alone working during a busy shift. That kind of passion for the business and caring of the staff shows. Even the gentleman grabbing my order was enthusiastic to talk to me about the owner and got my food promptly. I will gladly continue coming to this location if this is the level of service that we all receive. Thank you.
… more
Jenny Sines
Delicious pizza try the veggie square pizza for sure!
… more
Jeffery Antoniotti Jr
Pizza Joe’s is my favorite pizza. However I live in Ohio and this was the first time I had this places pizza. A coworker and I stopped in on lunch. The pizza tasted great, but gave both of us diarrhea. Not sure why.
… more
… View more