Based on 214 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
3150 State St, Caledonia, NY 14423
Phone: (585) 538-2810
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Tex Nolan
First time through Caledonia. Wife said look small pizza place, when in New York, must eat a New York Pizza.
… more
Brandon Marshall
Im in the area for a few weeks and stopped in for a pie. 1 of the best pizzas I’ve had recently. Perfect balance of dough thickness, sauce and toppings. Not too little and not overloaded. I personally dont like a sloppy pie. The crust was crispy crust w a slight chew to it. You can taste the dough is fresh and not sitting around like some, getting that fermented beer taste. Really great. Worker was very friendly and personable. Good service still goes a long way for me. Will definitely be in again while I’m here and in future stops in the area. 5
… more
R. Ashby
We were passing through on a Sunday evening and were pleasantly surprised they still had slices available. This was our first visit to a Pizza Land and enjoyed the slices and the service. Thank you to the young man at the register and to the owner, iykyk.
… more
Briana Sickles
We ordered 2 large chicken finger subs, one had country sweet the other had ranch. We opened the subs and one sub had no sauce and the other had both ranch and country sweet. We called Pizza Land to tell them there was a mistake and would like them remade or have a refund. We then we were questioned about the subs and were told they talked to whoever made the subs and they were done right. Again they were not done right as I was looking right at the subs. We were told if we wanted new subs it would be 30 mins after we already waited that long for our original subs. We asked for a refund since we had plans and couldn’t wait. We were told if we wanted a refund we would have to bring in our original subs and get the refund in person (we paid by card). We proceeded to go to pizza land for our refund and I walk in and they are talking about the situation (not nicely which then made me feel uncomfortable). One worker said the chicken fingers would be done for our new subs in a few minutes and I said I couldn’t wait and would still like a refund. He then said he had dibs on one of our subs. We have always ordered from Pizza Land and have been pleased but lately it has gone down hill from our past orders. We will not be supporting pizza land unfortunately after this experience.
… more
Xavier Bowen
I love this place I have been ordering from here since forever, Me and my family love the food and workers and its local for us. Even if they spell our names wrong sometimes but overall they’re food is great I suggest getting there mild wings which are my favorite thing they have.
… more
Patti T
Food is very tasty. We got a calzone and small veggie pizza. Anything we have gotten here has been fantastic.
… more
Margaret Wolfe
One of the best Pizzas around!! Caledonia not as great as their Leroy location but still amazing!
… more
Matt Wildey
I am not a fan of the sweet red sauce used for pizzas here, but a lot of people love it.
… more
Mandy Sherman
I’m from Gates NY….was close to caledonia and had been craving their pizza. I absolutely love their sauce. Ordered a med…pie cut…with extra sauce and a sauce on the side. Just a little crispy on the bottom. It was so piping hot and ready to eat once it cooled a bit. I drove all the way home and it was still hot. I was so thrilled that someone u give instructions to…actually listened and cared. I called pizza land and said thank u so much. Was the best pizza ever. Thank you pizza land….many more times to come
… more
Derwin Benfer
Heading home to Mount Morris, from Hilton, thought we would get a pizza on the way. Ordered from Pizza Land in Caledonia, order was ready on time, and the pizza was delicious. Love the sweet red sauce! Too bad it is 36 minutes from home.
… more
… View more