Low-key establishment providing pizza, pasta & heaping servings of Italian-American staples. Based on 237 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
574 Newark Pompton Turnpike #5, Pompton Plains, NJ 07444
Phone: (973) 835-3383
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
M
I went to eat here with my gf after playing soccer and training. The lady wit the blonde hair didn’t know the price for hawaian pizza so she asked the guy. Then he does the math and some how it comes out to 22 dollars for 4 slices of pizza, one lemonade and one Diet Coke. The lady’s reaction was like this . I’m not sure how much the lemonade was or the Diet Coke because it’s doesn’t tell you. I don’t know if it’s like local lemonade and that’s why it cost so much but I liked the environment. It was nice and classy and very calm but I still can’t believe I spent 26 dollars for 4 slices and two drinks. On a sign outside it says I can get a 2 whole pie for 20 dollars. but I didn’t know I was better off ordering the pies because I thought the pizza was like 1-2 dollars per slice. I’m pretty bummed out No hard feelings though. Just that the prices need to improve a bit. Because in like NY/NJ a slice of pizza can be as low as 99¢
… more
Brian Lann
This place is awesome! The portion size is great for the price. The pizza is awesome, but go in hungry and try a calzone…I bet you won’t leave hungry! I’m bummed I left full because I wanted to try more items on their menu. The staff are amazing, attentive, and generally great! The family that owns Pizza Man are really great people. Hope to be down in the neighborhood to stop in again.
… more
Lisa Firestone
I have been wanting to return to the restaurant for years now. The service was very good and friendly. The muscles were spot on. The Shrimp Norman was butterflied and very over cook. I was glad there was a lot pasta. I will return and give it another try. Perhaps I’ll try a chicken dish
… more
Carlos Santiago
Small Italian BYOB restaurant nestled in a hidden mall, known mostly to locals. Beware the place is tiny and it is first come first serve for seating, but worth it!! Menu is vast and reasonably priced…highly recommend the Penne Vodka, do yourself the favor and add the grilled shrimp, you won’t be disappointed. Plenty of parking.
… more
Chris G
Wonderful Italian restaurant. The food is always good. The staff is friendly and is a treat to get real Italian food. The portions are generous and the prices are reasonable.
… more
enrique motta
My family and I usually prefer to dine in when we’re in the mood for authentic Italian but we were in a bit of a rush this evening so we opted for takeout. I’ve noticed a lot of other places in the area are lacking when it comes to customer service but never here! We ordered a few apps, 3 entrees, and a pizza for my family of 5 and we still had leftovers. Definitely recommend you check this spot out.
… more
Antigona Mahmudi
Pizza Man is truly an outstanding dining experience. The food is amazing! I don’t normally eat seafood but it’s exceptional here! The mussels are cooked to perfection with everything I asked for to a T. The staff accommodates to my expectations and that is something I can really appreciate in the restaurant industry. I will be back soon, I advise everyone to check it out. It’s worth while.
… more
Cindy Gilson
We ordered over $70 worth of food to bring home for guests. I understand people make mistakes but when you spend 17 dollars on meat ravioli and get home and it’s cheese, I ended up making Mac n cheese . I guess I was just thinking after telling them about it they may of offered to switch it.. that’s my only complaint, all other food was excellent
… more
kathy wilkos
Everything about our dinner was wonderful. All of our meals, appetizers, and desserts were excellant. The portions were more than generous! Our waitress was great!
… more
Dawn D’angelo
We had gone back here after years of being out of the area. The owner and staff went out of their way to give us an experience to remind us of why we love this place!!
… more
… View more