Low-key stop offering classic pies, breadsticks, wings, salads & Italian subs in unfussy digs. Based on 223 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery ✔️ No dine-in
Address:
75 Wells Plaza, Wells, ME 04090
Phone: (207) 536-5844
Website: http://pizzamarkettoyou.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
4–8 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 4–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Cathleen Espinosa
THE WORST CUSTOMER SERVICE I’VE EVER EXPERIENCED!!!! If you want to be disrespected and treated like you’re less than….by all means, get your pizza here!!! My fiance and I both are disabled with PTSD and physical issues. We can’t get out a lot, so we’ve ordered quite a bit over the winter. We have spent HUNDREDS of dollars at this restaurant in the past month alone (photos to prove it). We ordered our usual 2 20″ pizzas….we had cash. They always complain when we pay with big bills, so we made sure to have smaller ones. We were short on cash this time and only had $2 extra for a tip. The driver literally walked himself back up on to our porch and informed us that the restaurant will no longer deliver to us because they haven’t received enough of a tip. Are you serious?! We are taking our excellent business elsewhere where our hard earned money is appreciated. The pizza isn’t THAT good, dude! Great business ethic…good luck to you and your business!
… more
Kenneth Muir
I recommend that you do not order from here. We placed an order for one pizza online and arrived 15 minutes later to pick it up and were told it would take another 30 minutes!!! The person taking the orders was not accommodating either. This was our first and last time.
… more
John dough
My wife and I stopped in after seacoast pizza was closed, ordered a large pepperoni and mozzarella sticks.. the pizza was aweful, greasy, and had a sweetness level that was unacceptable. The mozzarella sticks were just a sad display of dry cheese and bad batter.. I have had better out of my microwave and I didn’t have to spend $35.. just aweful
… more
Brian Gold
The mozzarella sticks were soggy and tasted like they had been left over from the day before. The pizza was as INEDIBLE. I opened the box to see it was burnt on top and took a bite. The crust tasted like cardboard and the sauce was the spiciest over-peppered sauce I’ve ever had in my life. Sauce should never taste like my mouth is being attacked by ants. I truly have never been more disappointed with food in my life.
… more
Marissa G
We ordered delivery online through here to our hotel when we were on vacation. There was a little miscommunication on delivery address (I blame us since we were from out of state) but they gladly remade our pizza and we offered to just come pick it up. It was almost closing, but the staff was awesome when we came in to pick it up. This was in 2020, and we still talk about the size of the pizza we ordered and how good it was! It is on our list for when we come back!
… more
syn edgē
Been meaning to try this place during past visits, finally got around to it this time. Ordered on-line and picked up the order so I check the interior. Kind of nice and roomy with a large sitting area. The buffalo wings were above average, but the pizza was really good. A hawaiian with BBQ chicken. Never had one before, looking forward to trying more of the menu.
… more
William Kell
We were visiting Wells for the kids April school break and called in for take out. Friendly, prompt service and the pizza was very good. The 20” pie was plenty for our family of 4 (2 adults and 2 younger children, 4&6). A good New York style pizza with a tasty sauce and a good crust.
… more
Devin Brown
Pizza was good. However. Service. Very poor!
… more
Brittany Durand
Our first time we came here and have to say it was the best pizza we have had. We came up from Mass for a day trip and this definitely didn’t disappoint. We got the cheesy garlic bread sticks, an order of chicken wings, a half and half large pizza (half Mediterranean and half chicken veggie ranch) and a small cheese. Only cost us a little less than $60 and the portions were huge.
… more
Randy Peterson
Unreliable. Seldom open to advertised hours. Past 4 times we tried to order we have gotten excuses. Or just randomly closed. No food. No boxes. Always an excuse that equals no pizza. Even calling ahead the results were no pizza. This is not how to run a business or treat your customers. Never again will I as much as try to get food from here. I will not recomend this place. Very unreliable.
… more
… View more