Based on 157 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2823 W 26th St, Erie, PA 16506
Phone: (814) 838-3535
Website: http://www.eatpizzapetes.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Denine Andersen
Exceptional customer service and great food! Our office ordered 6 different pizzas, including one for our vegan employee and they even had vegan cheese. We also got several different salads and everything was fresh. Delivery was exactly as promised. Can’t say enough good things about both the food and the staff. Well done!
… more
Rhonda Mills
Wow! What a pleasant surprise. We ordered from Pizza Pete’s and had fantastic food! We ordered the chicken parm sandwich, the bruschetta and an individual med salad (it’s very big). We are from Canada and were just staying in a hotel overnight while passing through and are so happy we ordered from here. Also, our delivery came in a lot faster than expected which was nice because we were really hungry. I highly recommend Pizza Pete’s!
… more
Melodie Vobrak
We ordered extra sauce and double pepperoni. WOW! This was the greatest! Pizza ever! This was the second time ordering from them. And will be the only place that we will ever order from!
… more
Gretchen Shakespeare
Every single time I call for the past 3 years the phone is ALWAYS busy. I don’t know what it is but it never fails. Literally any time of day I call or day of the week it’s constantly busy. The food is good but I just wish I could get through to someone to order.
… more
Tristan Zimms
Pizza is delicious but the staff isn’t often friendly. We used to order regularly until we received an incorrect pizza, was missing a topping and I was charged. It’s the only thing my brother orders, same every time, they say it’s in my order history. When I called to let them know, the staff member berated me saying I never ordered that, she couldn’t explain why I was charged, she refused to look up the history, she refused to rectify the issue in any way. My response? Don’t give your hard earned money to places that don’t want it. Based on several comments, this is a pattern. I hope they can resolve, instead of excuse, and wish them well.
… more
Rhonda Oldham
Ordered delivery and I didn’t have to use Door Dash!! This pizza (a small Supreme) was delivered in less than 45 minutes, hot, and absolutely delicious!!
… more
jeff hassett
The owner reached out to me and was absolutely phenomenal. Have been back multiple times since and every time it’s been amazing..
… more
Kayla weber
Pizza Pete’s is PHENOMINAL pizza. If you haven’t tried the new pickle pizza you’re missing out. The chicken quesadilla pizza on cracker crust is to die for. We like to add black olives and hot sauce! Our boys prefer a half bacon half sausage. It’s one of our go to pizza spots for busy nights! Prices are great for what you get. Haven’t been disappointed yet! Always great deals. Check out their specialty pizza list. Staff are all very polite and cheerful.
… more
Phillip
This is my favorite pizza in Erie. They do a great job. I don’t eat pizza as much anymore but when I do it’s usually Pizza Petes.
… more
Lisa Farbo
I wanted to try their pizza. I walked in and looked at the menu. A medium pizza with 1 topping was listed on menu as $10..99; additional toppings were $1.79. I ordered a medium with 2 toppings assuming the price would be 12.78 plus tax. My bill came to $15.44. I asked the counter people about about it and they actually yelled at me saying “It’s because of inflation.” They were very rude. I pointed to the price on the menu and they said that they were allowed to raise prices because the menu said so When I looked at the menu it said “menu subject to change’ not “prices subject to o change.” Pizza Pete, I will never return! Your pizza is much too mediocre for the price. Your help also needs a customer service class.
… more
… View more