Based on 201 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
5000 Winters Chapel Rd Suite 4, Atlanta, GA 30360
Phone: (470) 514-5389
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
David Graham
It just didn’t work out for me. I ordered a Margherita pizza. It came out soaking wet from the tomatoes bleeding out. This watered down all the flavors and made small puddles all over the pie.
… more
chris henshaw
I have to say, that in my 25 years in Atlanta, this is the most authentic north NJ / NY city pizza I’ve found… Slices are thin, flop just the right amount when picked up. Oily but not too oily, good chew to the crust. All the stuff I’ve been missing in a NJ slice!!! I’ve had their plain, white, pepperoni, and Sicilian (so close to my childhood ones that it threw me right back to being a kid) slices, as well as a slice topped in an excellent pink vodka sauce. Garlic knots were awesome and fresh (also reheated well the next day). Service has been fast every time and the owner is super friendly. And yes, I give the atmosphere a 5 star rating as it is almost identical to any of the hundreds of NY/NJ pizza by the slice places where I grew up. It’s a to go only joint with 3 bar stools and a single picnic table outside if you really want to eat there.
… more
Jodi Jennings
This pizza is great BUT please do not order via menufy. Something about it always makes the order take exceptionally long and it goes through Uber eats without the delivery time guarantee.
… more
Gary Whitlock
This is our favorite pizza in Atlanta. The owner of the shop, Wilton, is passionate about the product he’s making. You can taste the love and care he puts into every part of the process. We time our trips to Atlanta so we arrive as the pies are coming out for the slice counter (around 11:15). We buy a slice, hangout for a little while and spend some time getting to know Wilton. What a guy, and what a wonderful little pizza place.
… more
eabsurfs808
I eat here about once a month and the pizzas are always good!
… more
Greg Royster
Wonderful NY style pizza. The thin crust focuses on the toppings. Their lunch slices are big. Indoor seating is limited to a window bar. But there are picnic tables just outside.
… more
Keli F
We found their pizza mushy and wet and the
… more
Karen W
I have been searching for a “true authentic pizza place” for quit some time.. Read the reviews, will try it….. Baby! This place is it. I am from NY so I know NY pizza.. I took a bite before I left the shop….OMG, delicious, reminded me of being in NY. Yes I definitely will return. Will try other food on menu also. I bought a cannoli, it was ok, I thought they were freshly made… but still ok.
… more
Sylvia Newsome
So happy I found this place, exactly what I was looking for. Highly recommend the pepperoni roll, big enough to have leftovers or share! The garlic rolls 10/10, mouth waters just thinking about them. Customer service is outstanding. Will be eating here often!!
… more
Luis Santos
Never have I ever had pizza like this. The service was good and the food was like non other. I am baffled that food can taste as such.
… more
… View more