Based on 130 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
572 Evans City Rd, Butler, PA 16001
Phone: (724) 482-6330
Website: http://pizzapiebutler.com/
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Daniel Schumaker
We ordered an XL Mushroom Pizza and were blown away by it! Great crust and sauce, but the star is the cheese! Amazing!
… more
John S
I called to place what would have been about a $300 order. Apparently they were having phone issues. The woman kept talking and was very rude saying she couldn’t hear anything, yet she was repeating what I was saying?… Some other person got on the phone and was also very rude. Ordered elsewhere!
… more
John Lefebvre
I goto the 68 location alot. Never a problem. Excellent food and cool staff. I have to laugh at some of the reviews complaining about the building or restaurant. Newsflash!!!! It’s a take out or delivery shop that pride themselves in awesome food. It’s not a bar and grill millenials.
… more
Kim Shuler
I called on Monday and ordered pizza to be delivered the next day at 11:15 for our lunch at BIHS. When it didn’t show up after waiting about 10 minutes, I called. I was told “it’s sitting here. It will be there in 10 minutes.” That’s great! We will enjoy eating our lunch in the few minutes we have left. The pizza was very good, but I won’t order from there again.
… more
David Myers
I’ve ordered from here several times and never been disappointed. It costs alittle more than other pizza places but worth it.
… more
Sandy Glover
Thought I’d pass along my experience with Pizza Pie today – 10-17-21. Having recently moved into the Meridian area I figured I’d try them out and searched the web for “Pizza Pie on Evans City Road” in order to peruse their menu. When I located it (oh by the way I’ve since found three) the price seemed a tad high but thought I’d give it a go anyway. It should be noted that the page I’d retrieved noted the correct phone number and address. When I picked up my order I was given a price significantly higher than the one that was advertised, which I, of course, questioned. Unfortunately at that point I was accosted for using the wrong website . . . who new. It was infuriating to be verbally insulted and rudely treated for what was obviously unbeknown to me. Not so much as a dollar was offered as a recompense as a result of their misnomer. Ironically I was told by the cashier that three other customers that day mentioned the exact same scenario and a fellow in line behind me made a very similar comment. Sadly, they’ve lost my business.
… more
Reagan Pieri
The establishment doesn’t look very impressive and needs some major overhauling but I’m not here to eat the building. The pizza is very good, from the dough to the sauce. We have never been disappointed.
… more
Mike Goetz
Hands-down best pizza in Butler. Very consistent quality, always on time, great pricing, and the BEST TASTE!!! I would have to say I am probably the number one pizza fan and would eat for dinner seven nights a week if my wife would let me and this place is the best. I moved out here from Pittsburgh so I was pretty spoiled down there but as a miracle I found Pizza Pie route 68. They don’t even deliver to us so we have to drive to pick it up and it’s still our go to spot every week and I strongly recommend you do the same.
… more
Nathan Werner
I love this place as a local pizzeria. The owner Is frequently in there sweating it out at the ovens and takes a lot of pride in his work. My favourite go to is the meatball casserole. It comes with garlic twists made fresh and a salad with amazing ingredients. The reason I am writing this is my salad tomatoes were mind blowing. I’m pretty sure they were homegrown by the look and taste. You know when you know you are eating something that was homegrown.
… more
Meg Harancher
Get takeout for lunch during the week sometimes – great pizza, amazing hoagies ( I get the Italian typically), fresh ingredient salads (the steak is real!), and their homemade Italian dressing is so good. Love to support local businesses that provide consistent & good quality food.
… more
… View more