Locally owned and operated. Pizza, Pizza Twins, Chicken Wings, Athens Gyros, Hot Subs, Fish Dinners, Pit Stix, Appetizers, Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream Pints, and more. Fresh, Fast, & Hot Delivery. Made from Scratch Pizza since 1969.
Providing pizza delivery, food delivery, catering services, and takeout for over 50 years.
Pizza and Food Delivery in Sun Prairie and Marshall. Take and Bake pizzas available.
Veteran regional chain offering pizza (including bake-at-home pies), plus wings & sandwiches. Based on 195 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
330 W Main St, Sun Prairie, WI 53590
Phone: (608) 825-2818
Website:
Hours
| Thursday |
11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday |
11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday |
11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday |
Closed |
| Tuesday |
11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday |
11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Alex
This place fell off for a while. But the last few pizzas I got reminded me of pizza pit of old. The new owner is doing pretty good. Prices are higher than they used to be but the ingredients seem to be similar or the same to what always made this the best pizza chain in SP in my opinion.
… more
Coleman Dole
Staff were very friendly and helpful. The pizza was VERY good. Our 6yo claimed it was the “best pizza ever” and would have ate half the pizza if we let her.
… more
Ch Ad
It’s been YEARS since I’ve visited a Pizza Pit (Literally years, the portage location which hasn’t been there for a long time now) and going to this location has triggered some great memories. Don’t listen to the Karen’s who don’t know what good pizza is lead you astray. This place ROCKS and the new Owner Sarah is an all star. Keep up the great work.
… more
Linda Serafini
I can understand why Pizza Pit’s ratings are relatively low as it changed hands a number of times through Covid, and the buyers really ruined it. However, the new owner has brought everything back to its former glory. Back to the original crust, original sauce, and I believe she’s bringing the original gyros back. I’ve never in my life thought I would take Pizza Pit out of my phone but it was it so bad I finally gave up. But when I heard new owners were in, and they brought back the original recipes and original ingredients, I had to try again. Super glad I did. They’re back to 5 stars!
… more
Allexus Unger
When the pizza is fresh…. Man it’s good. Too tier pizza in my opinion. Love that they have cans of soda too
… more
Cindy Ostrom
Nothing, but excellent service & the pizza & garlic cheese bread was so delicious @ Pizza Pit, Sun Prairie location. Sarah Winter keep up the great work!
… more
Calvin Sorchy
Pizza is amazing now that its back to the old ways/recipes. The new owner is doin it right again. And they got daily $2 slices….say no more!!!
… more
Samantha Fiscus
Pizza pit is my favorite pizza place in Sun Prairie. I really like the convenience of the $2 slices for lunch. That’s a great deal.
… more
Jean Alt
We had them provide pizzas for the concession stand at an archery tournament last weekend. They were quick in bringing the pizzas, when we needed more. Also the quality of the pizzas has improved a lot. They were really good. They are under new management and I would get their pizzas again.
… more
Evan Dittmann
The new owner, Sarah, has really turned this place around. The pizza and delivery have certainly improved since she took over.
… more
… View more
