Based on 306 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
37249 NY-23, Grand Gorge, NY 12434
Phone: (607) 588-4070
Website: http://www.pizzaplusgg.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Eric
8/3/23 always stop in when visiting the area and always great food!
… more
Elysium Emporium of Recovery (Lys)
We were camping about 5 miles away. On the last night, it was pouring rain, chilly, and wet. I saw the sign for this place the 1st night. I decided hot pizza and wings would be easy and satisfying. I called when I was 10 minutes away. I ordered a veggie + bacon on half and the other half supreme, additionally a medium cheese pizza, BBQ and mild wings. It took 5 minutes when I got there. The atmosphere was great! Only complaint is there were no paper towels or soap in the ladies room. Also, I couldn’t tell the difference between the two sides of the supreme/veggie. The pizza was hot, fresh, and smelled amazing. I loved their chicken wings. The breading, sauce, and crispness. I would definitely return if I were to come back.
… more
M andD
This review is fair and honestly accurate. I attempted to resolve directly with the establishment, but was unsuccessful. I was told they cannot deliver because they are short staffed, but I was told that last year as well, so apparently, they cannot get their staffing issues resolved either. After my husband picked up my order and delivered it to me, almost an hour round trip in a storm, I received a terrible meal. The only edible portion was the pizza. The garlic knots were swimming in what I believed was oil, but was corrected by the owner that the pool was butter and “it’s the way people like it here”. Didn’t realize there was a market cry for clogged arteries. I found this both unhealthy and inedible. The wings were horrific! A battered blob of nerve and fat coated and disguised as food. They were picked apart to find chicken, and basically 80% was thrown out! Finally, my Cesar salad was a ton of chopped iceberg, romaine and croutons- no dressing! For $9, I could have bought several heads of plain lettuce! I was told “it must have been forgotten.” No apology, no alternate offer. It appeared the owner felt his position was to defend and justify poor food quality and poor service. I politely said I called to give him an opportunity for explanation or correction before posting any negative review. I was told to “do what I had to do”, and this is it! Very, very poor customer service and very, very terrible food. Will never be back!
… more
Samuel Adams
I’ve stopped three times for lunch over the past two months. The pizza slices are absolutely the best. The crust is thin and crispy on the bottom and the edges are fluffy and a pleasure to eat. The cheese slices are probably the best in my opinion, and are full of flavor. The price is great and it can’t be beat. Worth a stop even if it is out of your way.
… more
Fred Mutzek
Wanted a quick bite on our travels so Stopped in here. Our expectations weren’t high, but we were pleasantly surprised. Just got a few slices of Pizza and it was quite good. Plus it did end up being a quick bite as we were in and out in 15 minutes which included eating there and a bathroom break.
… more
Raymond Carson
The pizzas were great! Would definitely come back for their good prices and it works as a good small hangout spot for people that live in the area. The service that my wife & I received was excellent.
… more
Barbara Hartman
Inside was dark and there was a smell that was unsettling. Pi zza looked great, took outside and there was the smell with an off taste.. cheese, oil??? The wings ate babies I have only seen in GA. Again off .. 🙁
… more
Rick Williams
This was my first time there, the large pie with extra cheese and sausage was $25.00 which was more than expected, but I must admit that the pizza was very good, the customer service really sucked, there was no hello or any greeting, there was also no thank you or anything like, have a nice day, just nothing, even though a tip was given, just a not welcoming, cold feeling.
… more
Bernadette Kowatch
Absolutely love the pizza. I am very picky when it comes to Pizza and Pizza Plus has the best pizza I have ever tasted. I love the crispy crust. Most places do the fat crossed and it’s doughy. Pizza Plus we’ll do a bigger thicker crust but I personally love the thin crispy crust. There’s a young man named Aaron making the pizza there and he is absolutely awesome at his job
… more
Matt Faircloth
Overall, OK pizza. Kind staff and they did have gluten free pizza. But the wings were breaded and I couldn’t eat them, and their website didn’t say that the wings were not gluten free.
… more
… View more