Based on 180 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
883 Mt Prospect Ave, Newark, NJ 07104
Phone: (973) 483-5179
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Renee Roman
What a great slice of pizza!! I have not had pizza like this in a very long time. To top it off they also sell scoops of Philadelphia water ice and ice cream. I had a kiddie size scoop of ice cream after my slice and it was the perfect way to end my meal. 100% recommend
… more
KevLar Da Don
The other night I ordered, Pizza Town Pizzeria, for dinner. I ordered their Chicken Alfredo Dinner and my guest ordered their Chicken Cheesesteak. Both orders came piping hot! The Chicken Alfredo was fairly decent in flavor and the portion size was terrific. The sauce is really light and also doesn’t really have that Parmesan-Like taste you’d expect from an Alfredo sauce. The chicken seemed like it was flash fried then chopped. The flavor was there, but it was kinda stiff. Still good though. My guest let me try their Chicken Cheesesteak, and I must say it was really good. It had great flavor and was also very filling. The Chicken Cheesesteak greatly impacts my total score. All in all, would love to try this place again. Just couldn’t highly recommend the Chicken Alfredo, but you can’t fail with their Chicken Cheesesteak.
… more
E.C. Quinones (GRAYWOLF)
One of the most horrible places I have visited to eat literary the pizza was looking back at me. My “Conscience telling me why are you lowering your standards to eat pizza ” the guy never wear gloves, touch his face and made they pie just to deliver it with his finger prints all over the pie. They say never judge a book by the cover Well I said the same about the Toxic Avenger and the movie as Raw just as this place is Added to never go again places ever.
… more
Dora Mino
I used to go here when my husband and I were first together. 4 years ago was the last time due to moving but we tried 2 of our old favorites, tuna melt and Sicilian. I’ve never be so disgusted and disappointed in my life. This place wasn’t just a pizza spot, it was a memory. The tuna was old and disgusting. Lou knows the flavors, don’t get this wrong. He’s just not paying attention to the inventory or stopped caring. The Sicilian is the worst, I almost cried. I was trying to figure out how it went wrong. The toppings of extra cheese and pepperoni were basic but Lou know how to season it, I tried it separately and it was fine. The middle of the Sicilian was beautifully fluffy and a good seasoned dough. The top layer between the toppings and the middle of the slice was fine but when I tried a piece of the bottom of the pie, I found out where it went wrong. They didn’t clean the oven. Imagine a grill or griddle full of old food and you just scrap the pieces off and instead of cleaning it, you keep cooking on it. That pizza tasted like it was cooked on a few months, if not, years of that. I’m very sad to say this is the last time ordering from here. I had to throw everything out. Lou is amazing but the fact that he stopped caring and it reflects on the food guts me. I wish you the very best, please let me know when you change the quality control and sanitary state of the place.
… more
Skye Soto
I live locally n have never really had the food here but I was in a hurry n needed something affordable n on the go. When I tell you this man charged me 3.25each for a plain slice of pizza that tasted worse then a frozen pizza. It took 20 mins to warm. He also stated that he would have to charge me n additional dollar if I was using a card…. so since my order my small I ordered mozz sticks to make my order larger. All together my order was 15 n he still charged me the additional dollar for using my card. 16$ for two small plain slices and 4 mozz sticks!! Food does not match the price. The owner is taking advantage of inflation in a neighborhood that struggles to begin with. Shame on him I will not support this establishment.
… more
John Abeigon
Excellent pizza without the overflow of cheap olive oil in other neighborhood pizzarias. The ingredients are all just right. Dedicated & local run, been serving schools and families for a while. No thrills just 100% take out!
… more
Julia Rivera
First time here ordered mozzarella sticks, NASTY !! Burnt tasted like dirty oil, 2 slices of pizza & cheese steak barely no meat sandwich they charged me $26 NEVER AGAIN!!!
… more
Cynthia Demmer
I grew up around the corner & it was my family’s favorite pizzaria in the late 70’s then I started dating my husband & we started going on own in the 80’s (that alone has been over 40 years) It’s got to be a great place to have survived all these years even thru a pandemic!
… more
Neftali Marrero
After all the bad reviews I decided not to go cause the place is falling apart no maintenance of the oven ….unsanitary conditions…..PLACE NEEDS A COMPLETE OVALHAUL AND NEW MANAGEMENT….
… more
Armando Ruiz
Best plain or pepperoni pizza in all of North jersey, In the Essex County. Crispy, not soggy, cheesy yet not heavy, and something about that crust. Where is fluffy, flaky but it doesn’t cut the roof of your mouth. Such simple ingredients Lou uses yet unique and familiar of good pizza. This is an example of what every pizza joint should taste like.
… more
… View more