Large, New York-style pies, pasta dishes & sub sandwiches round out the menu at this casual locale. Based on 261 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
833 Hill Rd N, Pickerington, OH 43147
Phone: (614) 862-4743
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Dominic Edwards
Our favorite pizza in the Columbus area. I gave it a few tries before reviewing to be sure they’re consistent, and they are consistently great. Not “Columbus style” pizza with the garbage cracker crust and square cut. It’s authentic NY style pizza. Only downside is I live slightly too far for delivery and they’re not on the delivery apps (to my knowledge). But the pizza is too good to knock the rating for a short drive. Great pizza!
… more
John and Lara Y
Impressed! Tastes and looks like the famous Bleecker St Pizza in NYC. Great cheese and crust, sauce is good but don’t expect sweet like Romeos/Papa Johns etc. Kind service. Took us a while to try this place because they don’t seem to advertise to the degree other local pizza shops do, but word of mouth brought us here. Will be back!
… more
Andrea Rudin
Do not sleep on this place! My family and I visited on a weeknight, and the place was completely empty. Considering how good the pizza is, we were shocked. Although, I imagine the vast majority of their business is pickup orders. The cheese and crust were absolutely perfect, and I believe they could hold their heads high anywhere in New York. The only drawback in my mind is that the didn’t have a waitstaff (considering how large and open a space it is!). You have to do all your ordering at the counter, and you get paper plates, plastic cups, and no ice. That all could be a lot better, but it’s still amazing pizza.
… more
Juanita Powell
This place was recommended by a friend however I found it to be disappointing. I was born and raised in New York and I know authentic New York style when I taste it and this isn’t it. Pizza was ok, bread knots were bland. The best tasting thing was the onion rings. Place looked very dirty and dusty when I went in to order and looked like they were moving and not open for business. Staff were cordial but you can tell over worked and not as responsive as they should be. Sadly I don’t recommend this place and I will not be returning.
… more
Jim Lim
I reviewed 3 thin crust pizzas: Here (New York Pizzeria), Romeos, and Mod pizza. I had high expectations because it was “New York” style but was sadly disappointed! You can hardly taste the sauce and the bread was kind of hard, thick, and slightly burnt. The main flavoring were the mushrooms and less on the cheese. I would not order from here again. Romeos and Mod pizza were much better in terms of taste and flavor.
… more
Dave Crocker
Wow!!! Finally found some awesome pizza in Columbus area. These pies were even better than their other location in Reynoldsburg. It’s not cheap, but the quality is worth it. Dough, sauce, cheese & the toppings are top notch and marry together perfectly. If you like NY style, this is basically a Brooklyn hand tossed I would call it and our family loves it, reminds us of our favorite pies South of Boston.
… more
Letha Oliphant
I Dont post reviews often but this was a MUST REVIEW! I’m from Chicago, lived in NY for 5 years, not impressed with most eateries in Ohio and I am particular ( not picky) about my food. In Ohio for the arrival of my grand daughter and got a recommendation from the hospital. The BEST RECOMMENDATION EVER!! Had a taste for pizza and remember this recommendation. The location did not deliver to Canal Winchester but made an exception 5 stars for that alone!! The PIZZA!!!! WAS BAKED TO PERFECTION! THE SAUSAGE AND PEPPERONI WAS WELL FAVORED!! THE CHESSE WAS DELICIOUS! THE CRUST PERFECT! My daughter who is “picky” was in heaven! She has lived in Ohio for 10 years and said this was the best pizza she has ever had!THANKS PIZZERIA NY FOR COMING THROUGH AND REPRESENTING NY. I told my daughter the lasagna has got to be the BOMB! Can’t wait to try it!
… more
Cindy Lichtenauer
Love the thin crust and the triangle cut! It’s great for take out but the inside is a lite lacking, there is dine in, but just not very inviting. So it’s a definite stop but for take out…in my opinion. They even offered to go next door to add in a drink option for us that they didnt carry, so service was great!
… more
shaunoliver1
We always get carryout and we are please nearly every pizza. Because it’s New York style pizza, it’s best served with only 1-2 toppings before it becomes soggy bottom pizza so choose your topping carefully.
… more
Nicci Faw
You get the feeling that no one really eats inside this place so that was my bad. The pizza was ok. The crust was thin but that’s where the New York similarities end. The sauce was basic. The bottom of the crust was not NY back to hunting for NY pizza in Ohio. The guys inside are nice though. I just felt overall the experience was lackluster.
… more
… View more