No-frills local chain known for pizza by the slice, plus extra-large pies & specialty toppings. Based on 951 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
960 Main St, Stevens Point, WI 54481
Phone: (715) 341-9980
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–3 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–3 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ichimichael
Decent pizza by the slice. Central location downtown which is nice for walking but ? for parking. Otherwise it’s a consistent place for a pizza. 15.50 for three slices and three sodas.
… more
M J
Called for a curb side pickup as their website says they do that, the man on the phone sounded annoyed I asked, I have a 1 year old and it’s easier not taking him in and out to pick up food. Was never given a total for how much my pizza cost. It was ready on time, food was hot, I personally didn’t care for the pizza, the sausage was spicy to me, I had to pick it off.
… more
Dan Tauferner
Iconic. Good, fast pizza . Lots of variety by the slice . Fan favorite for my family.
… more
The Keith-Donovan Experience
Out of all of the college town pizzerias, I will definitely put this place on my top list of pizza joints. A lively crowd comes in late after two from the club. However if you don’t mind the fun and excitement of seeing that, this is the place for you.
… more
RJ Normand
Amazing Pizza! Huge portion for a great price. Fast, friendly service.
… more
DEBRA YANDA
Just ordered 5-10-23 by phone for a pi k up. We had 4 off menu items with only extra cheese extra roni on a pizza as a fifth. The items ordered was read back to me when I placed the order. My son asked about fries specifically , was told ” oh yea there in there…” when he picked up the order. He was given no receipt. He knows he was charged for the item plus he gave the broken arm girl a tip besides ! When called about the screw up same girl that took the order answered the call . She said it was never on the bill and whomever in charge said it was there mistake but since we were not charged it was just an” our bad, sorry” situation. He offered to make us fries if we wanted to run back to get them. We specifically ordered for pick up because the food and service is usually good and we needed to get something in our travels to get other things in our day tended to. We ordered her because it was. On our way to another nearby stop we had. We live more than 6-7 miles away and it just is not worth the aggrevation to run twice to get french fries. The fact that the main access road was blocked by construction was just another insult, besides all the other road work obstacl that had to be driven through. We are just very disappointed and saddened by the service today and the staff disregard to just do the jobs adequately. We will go to a competitor when we get the desire for pizza next time.
… more
Alexandria Johnson (Ali from Iola)
I love Politos. It was there for me in Oshkosh as I made way drunkenly through college, and it’s here for me when I need a delicious bite that my whole family can enjoy. Also, the garlic knots are the best!!!! And can I have the recipe for garlic butter sauce???
… more
Scott Breckenridge
Best pizza I’ve had in a very long time. Slices are huge. Ordered the XL and that filled me and my two 17yr olds right up. Best price I’ve seen on a pizza this size too. The Resturant itself is very clean, fun atmosphere. They also sell pizza by the slice. Staff was very friendly and that is hard to find anymore. Polito’s management Thank You for a great restaurant with the best staff around. Next time I’m in Stevens Point, I’ll be back.
… more
Carl O’Neil
We have had many a pizza from here. We usually get the large cheese to go, take it home and add topping and cook it for another 10 minutes. I have never really liked the crust, seemed too soft and I suspected they came pre-made. The last time I visited my wife and I got a couple slices, dine in. I watched them throw the dough, not pre-made! The crust on the pizza was excellent, nice crunch on the outside but a good tooth on the inside. Crunchy and chewy like a good New York style crust should be. I though they must have changed the recipe or something and asked about it. They were baffled at first but then one guy said, ” our slice oven is broken so we heated it up in the pizza oven which is much hotter.” Duh! The crust has been fine these last three years, it just has not been cooked hot or long enough. When you order a slice ask them to heat it up in the pizza oven, waaayyy better. I’m mostly a purist when it comes to pizza but they are known for all kinds of toppings on their pizzas so if that’s your thing you should be happy. Tried the macaroni and cheese pizza, it was okay, the cheese was very mild, maybe use a couple stronger cheeses? The staff are always nice. Place is a little grungy but not dirty, if you know what I mean.
… more
Evan Pfeffer
Good pizza for a low price, plenty of options. Staff are friendly and generally nice people.
… more
… View more