Storefront pizzeria & sub shop by train depot with a small side room serving classic Italian meals. Based on 424 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
125 Morris St, Morristown, NJ 07960
Phone: (973) 538-6000
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
J
Great pizza. Reminds me of what I grew up with in Newark. Grandma pizza with sausage, black olives and extra basil, gnocchi with chicken. GNOCCHI!! So good I think no one should try it because this place will become way to popular.
… more
Emily DiMambro
I came here to get food while at the brewery next door – so convenient! Highly recommend if you’re in the area. The pizza was ready in only 20 minutes, at exactly the time predicted. The Sicilian pizza was so good! Crust was crispy and light, but nice and thick, with delicious sauce. I will definitely come here again!
… more
Alan Pfersch (Al)
Wow. The thin crust pizza is really thin and the Sicillian was really thick. Both excellent. Lots of sausage on my slice and a big slice at that. I’ll be back.
… more
Candyce Ryder
Visiting family& after a bad experience at The Godfather pizzeria, we walked across the street(where we should have went from the start)& our order was promptly taken. Customer service was absolutely phenomenal! Order came out quick& everything was fresh! As we were leaving the cashier ran over to give us honey mustard and napkins(we didn’t ask for them). 10 thumbs up
… more
Ritz The Reviewer
First time trying the food here on a pickup order. The food was ready in a timely 20 minutes. I ordered a large grandma’s pie and a calzone. The pie was not what I expected as traditionally the dough is thick. Pomodoro makes a very thin crust pie. I liked both the flavor of the sauce and the mozzarella cheese was fresh. I was a little disappointed by the crust. It was burnt and not edible. Also, the pie was small. Because the crust is so thin (more like bar pizza) it can’t be shared by a family. For the calzone, it was a good size and tasted good! They allow you to choose whatever toppings you want to stuff inside – I went with pepperoni, peppers, onions and cheese! Since the flavors were overall good, I would order again but I would try a different pie.
… more
Laura Truitt
Half margherita pizza no basil half margherita with basil and mushrooms. So good! The kids loved the half with no basil and mushrooms and my husband and I loved the other half! And the chicken scampi with penne was sooo delicious and fresh! Very light and refreshing lemony dish (not too lemony but it was perfectly cooked). I’ll definitely order that again. I’m wondering if I could order the chicken scampi over spinach?!
… more
Des KF
I found this spot to get lunch and called ahead my orders. I called in for myself the pasta Primavera with no dairy. I called about an hour ahead and told the nice man what time I would be there. When I arrived I parked in the lot in the back. I walked in assuming everything would be ready. The nice man greeted me by name and the 2 other meals were done but not mine. I waited about 10 minutes and asked when it would be done. He said they made a mistake and put cream in the Primavera so they had to redo it. I was running late for ny client at this point and the man apologized and told me to grab a drink on the house and I did. The 3 meals I ordered came to about $62, a little pricey but hey. When my food was finally done after about 15 minutes I jetted out. When I ate my food I will say the Primavera was very good. It was flavored well and there was plenty. I was ready to give 3 stars for the long wait and me getting to my client late but everything else pushed it to 4 for sure.
… more
Margaret DeFazio
Hands down, the best meatballs around. This is from a meatball connoisseur. At the Taste of Morristown, we did a taste test and compared them to all of the other restaurants. A few were pretty good but theirs was the clear winer. They also make great soups. Each one is made to order.
… more
S Faulkner
Nice folks, good food. We randomly found them while driving by on the highway. Would come here every week if I was local. May plan to stop next time on the way by.
… more
James Mitchell
If you’re looking for good pizza in the area, this is a solid choice. I wasn’t wowed. BUT the pizza was very tasty, and I don’t have anything bad to say about it. The only reason why I’m giving it a 3 is bc of the appetizers. I have a feeling they are frozen from a bag. I’m coming back when I’m in the area again.
… more
… View more