Rustic restaurant offering typical Italian entrees & sandwiches, plus pizza whole & by the slice. Based on 841 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
90 Catskill Cmns, Catskill, NY 12414
Phone: (518) 943-4446
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kara C
Whenever I’m in the area of Catskill we always pay a visit for a quick slice. Pizza is ok, but definitely not what you’d find in NYC. Visiting Garfield on top of the beverage machine is always a must do to start our trip. He even has a new little friend next to him.
… more
Ralph Germain
I can’t speak on service or atmosphere bc I ordered delivery with my fellow coworkers. On that note. They warned me… They ONLY ever order chicken wings from this establishment bc the wings are always good. I foolishly ordered a Ceasar salad…it was literally the worst Ceasar salad I’ve ever eaten. Romaine soggy, croutons subpar and whatever you thought was Ceasars dressing is DEFINITELY not Ceasars dressing.based off this botched salad, I won’t order from you ever again..although my coworkers were happy with your wings, I STILL won’t order from you ever again. Whoever made this salad needs to be retrained. A foodie should never fall any food the worst they’ve ever had. DO BETTER, ur always packed when I drive by, so your food quality should reflect that.
… more
Andy Heffner
Nothing special. Slow service, high prices. Had a chicken parm sub. Had to wait for them to pluck the chicken. Good cafeteria quality sub, not great, on a small roll. I want to leave an Italian place with a box, definitely not still hungry. The margins on chicken, sauce, bread and cheese are huge. Especially for $19 for a sub and Pepsi with tip.
… more
Maria Robles
The Margherita pizza was amazing!!! The smell make your mouth melt. Super fresh and very kind team. We visited the area for our anniversary and that place was one of our favorite restaurants.
… more
Timothy Phillips
Food is ok at the best! Take out is a hassle (front counter people are a mess) food was cold!
… more
K D
Got take out. Calzone just thrown in a bag on a paper plate. Grease all over the bag which got on my fabric car seat. Dough wasn’t cooked enough, ricotta cheese was clumped in only one part of the Calzone and I got no side of sauce. Totally disappointed and disgusted.
… more
Katie Unger
As a former delivery driver here, I can easily say it was my favorite restaurant to work at. Anyone who works or has worked in food service knows the toll it can take. But Pomodoros was an amazing place to work. I was in college part time and was able to make a killing working part time here. The family that owns the restaurant are amazing, friendly, and always takes care of their employees and customers. Customer service is great, restaurant is always clean and the servers (shout out to you all) are all amazing and bust there butts for their customers as well as a huge shout out to the people that work behind the counter, Most of them being young, they work so hard and deserve praise for dealing with some disgruntled customers sometimes.
… more
Colin Bosler
When we visit the Catskill area, we always eat at Pomodoro’s! This trip we ate there twice! It takes some time to receive your order but that’s because everything is made fresh and the quality is amazing! The stars of the show are the meatballs. You HAVE to add them to your meal.
… more
Corinne Valentino
Ordered Chicken Marsala for my husband and I for takeout. The sauce was very thick almost like too much corn starch, there was no marsala flavor, and the dish overall had a terrible sour flavor. We will not be ordering from them again.
… more
Mathew Hall
Great good, very pleasant service, so I’ll be going back.
… more
… View more