Based on 163 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
343 3rd St, Henderson, KY 42420
Phone: (270) 826-2770
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | Closed |
Reviews
Chad Cooper
The pizza that I had from here was excellent, and even better since it’s such a good price for the quality. The breadsticks were also really good. If I lived closer I would order from here more often. Staff was friendly and the pizza didn’t take long to have made. Definitely a recommend!
… more
Sarah O
My family and I absolutely love Pony Express; it’s our favorite pizza restaurant! It’s been open in Henderson for close to 40 years and with good reason. The food is delicious and the buy one get one free deal is unbeatable. To me, their pizza is what pizza should taste like. Love those breadsticks, too! Last time I went, I ordered in person and the pizzas were ready quickly and I got exactly what I ordered for a great price. Definitely check out Pony Express Pizza, they’re the best!
… more
Brandi Skaggs
I love the food, I’ve been trying for the last 2 months to call and order from them but have not been successful. I even went by one day to place an order in person but there was a sign on the door that said “ not taking orders” but I watched a guy walk out with 3 pizza boxes and 2 other boxes. Is this place open anymore? Is there a different number to call?
… more
Nomad Ryder
What pizza place has closing hours of 8pm on a weekend. Let alone when you call at 7pm to place an order they dont answer. You drive by the place and the lights are on and people are inside cleaning and shutting things down. What happened to this place. Used to be the best in town, now its become a joke. Here yet again, tried to call on Friday evening at 530 to order a pizza and the phone rings and rings. Just close the place down if you dont want to work and do your job. Ive ordered pizza from here for almost 30 years. And this is the saddest this company has ever been. Open 4 days a week, and shutdown on the big money days you should be open. Close the doors and do the people that like the pizza a favor, instead of making everyone want something they cant have.
… more
Robin Beck
Had a hard time finding out when they opened. Called numerous times. Also, the pizza was okay. Breadsticks always good.
… more
Ms. Monet
I love the bread sticks and their crust. They put a perfect amount of sauce on the pizza so you can taste the toppings more than the sauce, and I like how they put their toppings under their cheese. It’s seems a little pricey but you’re paying for two pizzas bc it’s always buy one get one. We’ll be back!
… more
Virginia-Jenny Small-Flowers
Great pizza. Just wished they were open longer hours
… more
Katie B
My favorite pizza in town! Never disappointed an can’t beat the buy one get 1 free pizza!! Great prices!
… more
Brandy Newcom
I grew up on pony express loved the pizza. I feel like they changed their pizza ingredients slightly cause it don’t taste nearly as good as it did around the 80s n 90s when food was amazing.. but it was good and ate it. That’s saying a lot cause most things I try to get anymore I take one bite n get so discouraged that I throw it out.
… more
sue gallina
You can’t go in and eat,It’s only pick-up or delivery. You can get two pizzas 1paid for and How One Free.But the Pizzas are Dri.cqnnot not taste any sauce.(Pizza Sauce The People on the Phone and The Delivery Drivers Are Nice Folks.
… more
… View more