Based on 55 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
124 Main St, Port Jefferson, NY 11777
Phone: (631) 509-5805
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–1:30 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–1:30 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Danielle Rooney
I grew up on LI, went to Our Last of Wisdom (Catholic School just up the street), and went down port every couple of weeks.
… more
Geoffrey Staysniak
We arrived to the ferry with just a small window of time and empty stomachs. I was thinking of just getting a few of the ready-made slices, but then my partner asked about getting a fresh pie and how long that would take. We got an estimate of 15 minutes, but as soon as he read our hesitant looks, he vowed, “10 minutes.” We agreed, and within 10 minutes we had a fresh pepperoni pie, plus two impulse-buy Jamaican beef patties that were fresh out of the oven, and it all hit the spot when we enjoyed it on the ferry not long afterward.
… more
Brian
I recently had the displeasure of visiting this pizza place that left me deeply disappointed and questioning the sanity behind their exorbitant prices. While I am usually open-minded when it comes to trying new eateries, this particular establishment failed to deliver on all fronts.
… more
Darth Vader
This place is used to charging the bar patrons obscene prices at night when they’re too drunk to question anything. I’m not a drunk patron, I’m a local, so I was extremely put off by the $7 charge for a “specialty slice” that had been sitting around all day (if not several days). Tasteless, cheap, stale crust, & visibly old, dry chicken pieces. Prices aren’t posted, I think the guy just pulled a price out of his rear end (Colosseo, a superior establishment, is less than $5 for the same slice…and it’s delicious, too). Then the guy who randomly charged me the $7 cash added insult to injury by handing me the old, reheated slice on a just a paper plate to go. No bag or box? Never again. I miss Vincenzo’s. Better off driving to Miller Place for his REAL Italian food.
… more
Hormuz N.
If you’re looking for a cheap quick slice, go here. Nothing fancy. Had a regular cheese slice and pepperoni slice. Serviceable pizza
… more
MARTINO MASIELLO
Had to be the worse gyro I’ve ever eaten. It was like a gyro taco, the meat was hard and unfresh, the onions were soggy and old and the tzatziki was like paste, the fries were under cooked too… avoid this place at all costs…
… more
Rebecca Kassay
Their garlic knot crust pie is amaaaazing.
… more
AJ DESIGN
Great location, always open late, but i think its a bit over priced.. hopefully i was just over charged.. no bad vibes here.. 15 $ for 2 special slices and 1 drink seemed a little steep.. had no change for tip jar.. lol.
… more
Petko Kamburov
Pizza was okay. No price list. Was charged $8 for 2 slices and seemed too much. Overheard the lady after me was charged “tres dolares” ($3) where i paid $4. Dirty and old interior.
… more
Hayden Camarda
1 hour delivery. Driver got lost. Extremely overpriced, did not give total over the phone. No yogurt sauce with Gyro. Food needs to be better for the price, and especially because there is a pizza place on every block. Next time, we’ll be ordering from Joey Z’s directly across the street.
… more
… View more