Potbelly is the home of legendary hot, oven-toasted sandwiches. Try our signature: A Wreck®. Plus, fresh-made salads, hearty soups, hand-dipped shakes, and cookies baked fresh daily. With a fun, welcoming atmosphere, Potbelly is the best lunch spot in all the galaxies (sorry aliens, but it’s true). Also offered: pickup, delivery, dine-in, and catering.
Retro-style counter-serve chain known for made-to-order toasted sandwiches, salads & baked goods. Based on 486 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
899 W Main St, Lake Geneva, WI 53147
Phone: (262) 248-4663
Hours
| Thursday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Bonnie Johnson
First week of February is the winter festival, it’s busy. Good service, they were kind despite being swamped. Smart team, and I noticed them helping each other, very cool.
… more
Alexys Hall
Disgusting! I do not make reviews often.. but wow. that was extremely disappointing.. my chicken salad salad was gross to say the least. 3 drinks were out on the fountain, the floor was covered in food and trash behind the counter. the staff was not friendly, especially the guy taking orders.. definitely will not be coming back again.
… more
GroveDog1995
Had a great sandwich today staff is always fantastic and environment is perfect. The only problem I had was parking authority gave me a ticket right when I thought I parked in a free parking space so my sandwich ended up costing over $60 because of lake Geneva parking authority I’d appreciate it if you guys could do something about them they are always watching out for people it’s ridiculous. They need to get their system together no one’s going to stand for a $50 fine just for parking for not even 5 minutes.
… more
T Angela
First sandwich had hair in it. Asked for another one, it also had hair in it after being told they will be more careful.
… more
Traveling O
Great sub. Very clean & efficient. Staff is top notch. You get a smile & a friendly attitude.
… more
Susan Schippel
I had never eaten there before, it was the best. I got “A Wreck” We will return for sure next time we are in Lake Geneva! Nice people, nice atmosphere.
… more
John Meyer
Expensive, not very good and the women behind the counter seemed very displeased to have a customer walk into an empty cafe an hour before they were closing.. Had a mid size sandwich, cup of soup, chips and a drink and it was just short of $19. Ice machine broken and out of pepperoni. VERY DISSATISFIED and will not be back. A bowl of soup(I had the cup) cost over $6 was the size of 3 stacked hockey pucks and a shake costs less! Don’t usually leave reviews and this is the 1st negative review I have ever left. They earned this one for sure! Go somewhere else for $19 as there are many options in town
… more
Patrick Smith
The staff was friendly and helpful. I couldn’t make a decision on which sandwich to get and the young man (blonde/blue eyes) sorry I forgot his name, he suggested a sandwich which was delicious.
… more
Nicholas Pesce
I love a sandwich shop so much for a taking long walks at of amazing workout at lake Geneva.
… more
Barb Steinmetz
Always friendly staff, great food & value. Parking can be a tad crazy but well worth it
… more
… View more