Prime Catch Menu – New York, NY

Type : Steak house

Location : New York, NY

Based on 265 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery

Prime Catch 10036

Address:
140 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036

Phone: (646) 649-2288

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 11 AM–11 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–11 PM
Thursday 11 AM–11 PM
Friday 11 AM–12 AM
Saturday 11 AM–12 AM
Sunday 11 AM–11 PM
Monday 11 AM–11 PM

Menu

APPETIZERS
FRIED CALAMARI $18.00
BAKED SHRIMP
BAKED WITH BREADCRUMBS IN GARLIC BUTTER SAUCE
$20.00
PRIME CATCH MUSSELS
WHITE WINE OR MARINARA
$16.00
BAKED CLAMS
BAKED WITH BREADCRUMBS IN GARLIC BUTTER SAUCE
$16.00
PRIME CATCH CLAMS
WHITE WINE OR MARINARA
$16.00
SHRIMP & LOBSTER AVOCADO
SIDE OF PONZU SAUCE
$22.00
BURRATA
ARUGULA, ROASTED PEPPERS, CHERRY TOMATOES PROSUIUTTO & BALSAMIC
$18.00
AMERICAN CAPRESE
SMOKED SALMON, FRESH MOZZARELLA, TOMATO & CAPERS
$19.00
CHICKEN WINGS
6 WINGS, CURRY BBQ OR BUFFALO
$14.00
MEATBALLS
WITH TOMATO SAUCE & RICOTTA CHEESE
$16.00
EGGPLANT ROLLATINI
EGGPLANT STUFFED W RICOTTA CHEESE TOMATO SAUCE & MELTED MOZZARELLA
$14.00
ZUCCHINI STICKS
WITH TOMATO SAUCE
$12.00
MOZZARELLA STICKS
WITH TOMATO SAUCE
$12.00
VEGETABLE SPRING ROLLS
WITH SWEET CHILLI SAUCE
$14.00
RAW BAR
EAST COAST OYSTERS
W HORSERADISH, VINAIGRETTE & COCKTAIL SAUCE PP
$3.75
SHRIMP COCKTAIL
W COCKTAIL SAUCE
$20.00
TUNA TAR TARE
(AVOCADO, SESAME OIL, PONZU)
$20.00
SEAFOOD TOWER
MIXTURE OF CHILLED SEAFOOD PP
$33.00
SOUPS & SALADS
PRIME CATCH SALAD
SPRING MIX W CUCUMBER, ONIONS, TOMATOES, TOPPED W FETA CHEESE
$16.00
CAESAR SALAD $14.00
WEDGE SALAD
ICEBERG, TOMATOES, CHOPPED THICK CUT BACON W CRUMBLED BLEU CHEESE DRESSING
$15.00
TRI COLORE SALAD
ARUGULA, ENDIVE, RADDICHIO & PARMIGIANA CHEESE
$15.00
CHARCUTERIE BOARD
MIXTURE OF MEATS AND CHEESES
$24.00
FRENCH ONION SOUP $12.00
LOBSTER BISQUE SOUP
W OYSTER CRACKERS
$15.00
MAINS
SALMON LIVORNESE
(TOMATO, OLIVES, CAPERS)
$38.00
GRILLED SALMON
W BROCCOLI
$38.00
MILANESE
PANKO BREADED, FRESH MOZZARELLA, ARUGULA, TOMATOES & ONIONS W BALSAMIC VINEGAR
$36.00
PARMIGIANA
PANKO BREADED TOPPED W TOMATO SAUCE, & MELTED MOZZARELLA SERVED W PASTA
$34.00
ROASTED CHICKEN
W POTATO & BROCCOLI
$36.00
HANDHEALDS
PRIME CATCH BURGER
LETTUCE, TOMATO, ONION & PICKLES AMERICAN OR PROVOLONE CHEESE WITH FRIES
$19.00
FRENCH ONION STEAK SANDWICH
SWIZZ CHEESE, CARAMELIZED ONIONS, FRENCH ONION DIP WITH FRIES
$20.00
GRILLED CHICKEN BACON RANCH SANDWICH
AMERICAN CHEESE, THICK BACON, LETTUCE, TOMATO & RANCH WITH FRIES
$17.00
COD FISH SANDWICH
BATTERED COD, LETTUCE, TOMATO, WITH HOMEMADE TARTAR SAUCE WITH FRIES
$20.00
HAND CUT STEAKS
PAT LA FRIEDA
U.S.D.A PRIME DAY AGED STEAKS ALSO AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST
FILET MIGNON
8 OZ
$48.00
BONELESS NY STRIP
12 OZ
$44.00
BONELESS RIBEYE
14 OZ
$48.00
LAMB CHOPS
W SPINACH
$48.00
SIDES
MASHED POTATOES $12.00
FRENCH FRIES $12.00
BAKED POTATO $8.00
BROCCOLI $12.00
CREAMLESS CREAMED SPINACH $12.00
ASPARAGUS $12.00
LONG HOT PEPPERS $12.00
SAUTÉED ONIONS $12.00
SAUTÉED MUSHROOMS $12.00
ONION RINGS $12.00
MAC & CHEESE $12.00
THICK CUT BACON
PP
$5.50

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reservations: opentable.com

Reviews

Tha Profechanel
On a side street in the heart of Times Square holds a small gem of a restaurant with delicious food and great service. The vibe is elevated bar & grill meets Italian classics. The food is cooked well, seasoned and nice portions. The Chicken Parm is really good and the pasta is a wonderful complement not just a filler but really stands out on its own. The lamb chops are some of the best I have ever eaten at this price point. It is affordable but yet done perfectly, has just the right seasonings and the grilled flavor takes it to the next level. Wonderful portion and spinach was delicious. The Mac & Cheese was creamy and luscious and made a wonderful mate to the lamb chops. I also had a strawberry margarita and it was lovely but I consumed it before taking a picture but it is worth the money.

… more

Sylvia Perez
So where do I start….after Broadway show, literally walked for an hour to have a fancy dinner since we were without the kids…Prime Catch was the end result and it did not disappoint. The food was exquisite the service was great..the owner was the sweetest man ever. Gave us complimentary desert and was consistently making sure all the guests were pleased and content. Ambiance was very romantic, dimmed lighting, very intimate. Rest room couldnt be cleaner. Rating was an A! Took us a while to find an A in the Times Square area. Def will visit again.

… more

Sarah
This restaurant is definitely a must go! The steak is delicious and cooked to perfection. Other family members got chicken and pasta, which was delicious. Make sure to save room for your dessert since you will want to try several. Customer service was top notch and everyone worked together to make the experience perfect.

… more

vlada d
Amazing dinner spot. Lots of great options to choose from. We had the lobster and steak which was great. Everything was good from the appetizers to the desserts and the drinks. Highly recommend. Service and ambiance was phenomenal.

… more

Alexander L
Great spot! The service was top-notch. Our server was very attentive and kept the drinks flowing. The entrées were excellent. The lamb chops needed some season but was cooked perfectly. I’ll definitely recommend this spot…Philly

… more

Doris Ishikawa
Had bday dinner there which nice service and atmosphere but the food was not good as what I expected. I ordered lamb chops that’s medium rare but sounds overcooked. I mean if your looking for the nice atmosphere of dinner that’s the place that’s the one of my recommendation

… more

Joe Wicks
Welcoming restaurant and excellent, attentive service. I enjoyed Chicken Parmesan; my wife loved the ribeye. Crème brûlée and chocolate soufflé were delicious.

… more

LATOYA SPENCER
One of the BEST non planned dinners I have had. Walked in without a reservation. Everyone was very nice and courteous. The food and drinks were DELICIOUS!! Steak cooked to perfection. I will definitely revisit this restaurant.

… more

ray mack
Fantastic happy hour near Times Square! $1.50 oysters all day at the bar.

… more

Michael Rybicki
Food was great. The head waiter was unimpressive but maybe that was the point.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions