Based on 628 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
8177 Bell Oaks Dr, Newburgh, IN 47630
Phone: (812) 490-0655
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–12 AM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Rachel McLinko
Everything here at Prime Time was outstanding from the food, to the friendliness of the staff and the ability to be able to dine outside with your dogs. They started a dog menu and our pups happened to be the first “customers” to place their orders. They each had a prime rib lunch and devoured it so fast that I couldn’t capture a picture of their plates. We certainly were impressed and we will be bringing our cavaliers back with us!
… more
Jennilyn Brown
Prime Time was pretty good but pricey. I wanted to try the prime rib but it was too early to order it. I settled for the Prime Rib Sandwich and some French Onion Soup. I was given a free small bowl of homemade chips. They were ok. Too burnt for my taste buds. The soup was good. Lots of onions but very little broth. The sandwich was good. It came with onion straws on top with a side of horseradish and au jus. The atmosphere was nice. Lots of different beers on tap, as well as wine. I’ll be back to try their prime rib.
… more
Dustin Walters
My wife and I had an excellent first time experience at Prime Time Pub and Grill in Newburgh IN on January 11, 2023. The service was exemplary, the food was delectable, and the price was more than fair. I am pleased to give this restaurant 5/5 stars!
… more
Julia Chaney
This place was amazing. We went at a slow time so service was quick. The food was excellent. The burger was just right and the fries were seasoned very nicely. The Chicken sandwich was juicy with fresh vegetables. Drinks came out fast and were well made. Definitely coming back again. I loved our waitress she was personable and nice!
… more
S Young
Service was good. Food was pretty good. Good menu selection. Dry rub bone in wings had too much dry rub on them… Buffalo wings were good. Everything was reasonably priced except the steaks. Expect a sticker shock on the prime rib. I really wanted the prime rib, and despite the fact that I can afford it, I am not paying that much. Wow. I expect prime rib to be expensive, but when your salmon and shrimp dinners are half the price of the prime rib, you are charging waaayyy too much for it.
… more
Austin Rogers
Really great place! They have live bands at times and the band was phenomenal. Everyone was really friendly. Food was delicious. I had the pretzels and cheese and fried mozzarella for appetizers and they were delicious. My wife got the prime rib and I got a double cheeseburger with bacon. We were both extremely satisfied! We definitely will be returning often.
… more
june villines
Our 1st time w/4 of us.
… more
None Required
Ordered takeout for my team. Everything was good with the exception of the fried pickle spears. They were more like fried pickle fries based on the size. Not sure if it was just my order up that’s how they normally come but it was pretty insulting for in order fried pickles in my opinion. I pretty much only tasted batter. The rest of the food was really good including my burger and what everyone else ordered. The bartender was kind and even gave me additional ranch upon request. They were filming some sort of segment for the news while I was in there but the atmosphere seemed pretty lively and there was a decent-sized crowd in there for a Sunday. Would recommend checking them out!
… more
Michelle Robinson
Went for the first time last week. Had a free appetizer, got the Pretzal sticks which were very good. Our friends got the loaded tots which were good as well. Everybody liked their food, grilled chicken sandwich, sirloin, salmon, Mac & cheese burger. I liked that they bring out a bowl of homemade chips for the table. That was a nice surprise.
… more
Don Annis
Our dining experiences have always been enjoyable here. Service staff are professional, attentive and friendly. Food is consistently very good. They offer military/vet discounts with the proper ID. The restaurant is conveniently located adjacent to the Newburgh Movie Theater for a tasty meal before or after watching that blockbuster movie. Parking and seating can be challenging during peak times, so plan ahead. This visit i enjoyed the Sunday brunch biscuits and gravey with a side of bacon. Yum! We really like this olace and so will you.
… more
… View more