Based on 245 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
2 W Main St, Windsor, PA 17366
Phone: (717) 246-8100
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sheri Wolf
We love their pizza! The best around and that’s coming from a family who lived near Philadelphia and the Jersey shore most of their lives. They’re food is amazing. We order takeout but there is seating for eating in. Portions are good per price. Love the antipasto salad. For gluten-dairy-free option, ask for no cheese or on the side if sharing. Although I shouldn’t, I do indulge on their amazing pizza. It’s one of the few places I can and not suffer from my food intolerances which tells me they use quality ingredients. I recommend this place for sure.
… more
Tony C
The best pizza in the area. Typically, the dough / crush diminishes the quality of the pizza and the effect of toppings. However, their dough anchors the whole experience. Really well done. I was surprised to find such a gem in rural Pennsylvania. Great place.
… more
todd sindlinger
Pizza was not cooked and doughy. Continue to order from them as we want to support out local shops but have had many disappointing experiences. About a year ago I made an arrangement for a large pizza order like 15 pizzas when tried to contact them on the day of my event no one would answer the phone ended up last minute having to order food from a different establishment. Never heard from staff or Ryan about what happened. In a positive note the staff was friendly and open to conversation about concerns. Very disappointing. My advice find another local shop to support.
… more
Ryan Wissler
My crew was working in the area decide to order subs after reading all the great reviews. DONT BE FOOLED! A 45min delivery wait turned in 2hrs only for them to drop off soggy subs made not to order and at best mediocre quality would not recommend.
… more
Brian Fox
I went for a Ham, Pineapple, and Sriracha pie today, and it was AMAZING. It was made with love and great sauce, dough, and ingredients—one of the great pizza shops in the area for sure. Ryan and the team just do a great job.
… more
Michael Mazzucco
Consistently great food, delicious pizza and wings, and the first and only time I’ve had a problem (unable to fulfill a portion of my order) Ryan called me directly and made it right and then some. That’s something as valuable as the food being tasty.
… more
M R
By far the greatest pizza I’ve had in a long time. They are Windsor’s Hidden Gem. You should definitely come in and check it out. They even have awesome lunch specials. And did I forget to mention the lettuce placement on there subs? It is truly amazing and beautiful.
… more
Eric
Great place for pizza, albeit a bit expensive. Arguably, they do make up for it in quality. I would go elsewhere for feeding a larger group of people (like if it requires more than one pizza). Also, fries are small serving so keep that in mind if you have a few people that want fries.
… more
Rusty Wilson
Had two slices of cheese pizza and Italian submarine sandwich. Both were terrific pizza was just what I was looking for thin and tasty. Sub was just as good. Had takeout so I was unable to check the inside out. Thanks Primo pizza for a great lunch.
… more
Samantha Wierman
Tonight we ordered the pizza of the week (brisket Mac and cheese) and it was everything I hoped it would be. These guys always do such a great job!
… more
… View more