Prodigy Burger Bar – 96th Street Menu – Indianapolis, IN

Type : Restaurant

Location : Indianapolis, IN

Based on 41 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Prodigy Burger Bar - 96th Street 46240

Address:
3905 E 96th St Suite c, Indianapolis, IN 46240

Phone: (317) 343-2974

Website: https://www.prodigyburgerbar.com/

Hours

Sunday 11 AM–9 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
 11 AM–9 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–9 PM
Thursday 11 AM–9 PM
Friday 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday 11 AM–10 PM

Menu

Prodigy Burger & Bar – Before Burgers
DYNAMITE SHRIMP
Beer-battered, deep-fried shrimp, coated in our delicious dynamite sauce served overa bed of Asian slaw		 $13.95
IN-A-PICKLE
Crispy, beer-battered pickle spears with ranch		 $8.95
PRODIGY NACHOS
House-fried tortilla chips topped with ground chorizo, queso blanco, salsa, pickled jalapeños, sour cream and guacamole		 $13.45
WHITE CHEDDAR CHEESE CURDS
Battered crispy white cheddar cheese curds with a side of ranch		 $8.45
BYO DIP TRIO
House-fried tortilla chips served with your choice of 3 of the following		 $12.95
SOFT PRETZEL
Three salted pretzels, served with your choice of house-made queso or honey mustard dipping sauce		 $8.95
BEER BATTERED ONION RINGS
Beer battered onion rings finished with Prodigy Dust and served with our signature sauce		 $8.45
Prodigy Burger & Bar – Greens & Wraps
CAESAR
Chopped romaine and iceberg lettuce tossed in Caesar dressing topped with croutons and parmesan cheese add Chicken add Shrimp add Salmon		 $8.45
SALAD BUFFALO CHICKEN
Crispy fried buffalo tenders, served on a bed of romaine lettuce with tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles and your dressing selection		 $14.45
SEASONAL SALAD
Arcadian blend, apples, cranberries, candied pecans and goat cheese served with apple vinaigrette		 $9.95
SALMON SALAD
Grilled salmon on a bed of Arcadian blend, topped with peaches, oranges, freshly shredded beets and goat cheese served with sesame ginger dressing Substitute chicken breast		 $14.95
TY COBB
Romaine, topped with grilled chicken, crumbled bacon, hard-boiled egg, shredded cheddar, tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles, cucumbers, red onions and your choice of dressing		 $14.95
WRAP BUFFALO CHICKEN
Crispy fried buffalo chicken tenders served on a sun-dried tomato wrap with tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles, and your dressing selection		 $14.45
WRAP CAESAR
Chopped romaine and iceberg lettuce tossed in Caesar dressing topped with croutons and parmesan cheese sun-dried tomato wrap add Chicken add Salmon add Shrimp		 $8.45
WRAP SEASONAL
Arcadian blend, apples, cranberries, candied pecans and goat cheese served with apple vinaigrette		 $9.95
WRAP TY COBB
Romaine lettuce mix with grilled chicken, crumbled bacon, hardboiled egg, shredded cheddar, tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles, cucumber, and red onion in a sun-dried tomato wrap with your choice of dressing		 $14.95
SALMON WRAP
Grilled salmon on a bed of Arcadian blend, topped with peaches, oranges, freshly shredded beets and goat cheese served with sesame ginger dressing Substitute chicken breast		 $14.95
Prodigy Burger & Bar – Not Burgers
HOOSIER DADDY
An Indiana favorite. Hand-breaded, deep-fried pork tenderloin topped with dill pickle chips on a house bun		 $14.45
BLT WITH A TWIST
A heap of bacon, lettuce and tomato, topped with garlic aioli between two slices of Texas toast		 $12.95
BUFFALO CHICKEN SANDWICH
Hand-breaded, deep-fried chicken breast, drenched in buffalo sauce, with ranch and bleu cheese mousse on a signature bun		 $14.45
ADULT GRILL CHEESE
Two slices of Texas toast toasted to perfection with parmesan cheese, goat cheese, spicy marinara and fried provolone		 $13.95
ITALIAN BEEF
Shredded Italian beef dipped in au jus and topped with giardiniera		 $14.95
JERK CHICKEN SANDWICH
A jerk-seasoned grilled chicken breast with pineapple salsa on a signature bun		 $14.45
CHICKEN TENDERS BASKET
Beer-battered chicken tenders, served with fries and a dipping sauce of your choice		 $14.45
TERIYAKI SALMON
Grilled, teriyaki-glazed salmon, over a bed of Asian slaw, alongside fresh, steamed broccoli		 $15.45
SPINACH MAC & CHEESE
Our signature mac and cheese, blended with house-made spinach dip and sautéed mushrooms, topped with crumbled goat cheese and grated parmesan, served with a slice of Texas toast		 $13.95
BUFFALO MAC & CHEESE
Our signature mac and cheese, mixed with buffalo chicken dip, topped with bleu cheese crumbles and two hand-dipped buffalo chicken tenders served with a slice of Texas toast		 $14.95
CHILI MAC
Our signature mac and cheese with Prodigy chili, pickled jalapeños, minced onion, a sour cream drizzle and a shredded cheese topping, served with a slice of Texas toast		 $14.95
WINDY CITY
Nathan’s Famous all beef hot dog, topped with tomato, relish, a pickle spear, chopped onions, mustard and celery salt on a poppy seed bun		 $9.95
SOUTHERN INDIANA
Prodigy chili, queso blanco, minced onions and shredded cheddar over a Nathan’s Famous all beef hot dog on a poppy seed bun		 $9.95
Fish & Chips (3)
Hand-dipped beer-battered atlantic cod served with our signature fries and fresh coleslaw.		 $16.95
Prodigy Burger & Bar – Smash Burgers
CLASSIC
American cheese and Prodigy sauce on a signature bun		 $12.95
BACON & BLEU
Bacon, seasoned fries, bleu cheese mousse and buffalo sauce		 $13.95
MUSHROOM & SWISS
Swiss cheese and sautéed mushrooms, on our signature house bun, topped with truffle mayo		 $13.95
PRODIGY MELT
Two smash patties, American cheese, caramelized onions and Prodigy sauce, between two slices of Texas toast		 $13.95
MAC & CHEESE BURGER
American cheese, bacon and garlic aioli, topped with signature mac and cheese		 $14.45
* JAMAICAN BLACK BEAN BURGER
Jerk-seasoned black bean burger, pineapple salsa, pepperjack cheese, all on a signature bun		 $12.95
JUICY LUCY
A double smash burger with provolone cheese between the patties, American cheese, bacon and Prodigy sauce served on a signature bun		 $16.95
CHICAGO BURGER
A single smash patty served with Italian beef, provolone cheese, giardiniera, tomato aioli and a side of au jus		 $12.95
PEANUT BUTTER CHEDDAR BURGER
Two smash burgers with cheddar, pickled jalapeños and peanut butter on a signature bun		 $13.95
MEXICAN BURGER
Chorizo, green chile salsa, guacamole and pickled jalapeños on top of two smash burgers with pepperjack served on a signature bun		 $14.95
Prodigy Burger & Bar – Signature Burgers
BACON & CHEDDAR
Thick-cut bacon, cheddar cheese, Prodigy sauce, on a sesame bun		 $17.95
FRIED EGG & BACON
Our award-winning burger: fried egg, thick-cut bacon, tater tots and queso		 $17.95
NO NAME BURGER
Bacon, goat cheese, pickled red onion, balsamic glaze and truffle mayo on a sesame bun Try it with Chicken!		 $17.95
STEAK BURGER
A-1 steak sauce, sautéed mushrooms and onions, served with provolone cheese and a creamy horseradish		 $17.95
KIMCHEESEBURGER
Sautéed peppers and onions, kimchi, Korean BBQ sauce and American cheese served on a sesame bun		 $17.95
GUT BUSTER
Chili, queso, minced onion, pickled jalapenos, and sour cream served on top of a grilled cheese on Texas toast.`		 $17.95
SIGNATURE SLIDERS
Sampler-sized sliders featuring the No Name, Steak Burger and Bacon and Cheddar		 $15.95
Prodigy Burger & Bar – Create Your Own Masterpiece
* BUILD YOUR OWN $0.00
Prodigy Burger & Bar – Featured Options
BLACK & BLUE SALAD
Sliced sirloin steak, arcadian mix, cherry tomatoes, bleu cheese crumbles, pickled red onions and giardiniera served with blueberry balsamic dressing		 $16.45
MEDITERRANEAN SALAD
Chopped romaine, cucumber, grape tomatoes, pickled red onion, fried chickpeas and goat cheese served with lemon tahini dressing		 $11.95
THE PHILLY CHEESESTEAK
Sliced sirloin sautéed with peppers, onions and mushrooms, topped with provolone cheese, all on a hoagie		 $14.45
STEAK SANDWICH
Sliced sirloin, pickled red onions and creamy horseradish served on Texas toast		 $14.95
STEAK & FRIES
A 6oz sirloin seasoned and grilled to perfection, served with an order of Prodigy dusted fries		 $14.95
GRILLED CHICKEN & CHORIZO PASTA
Grilled chicken, chorizo, sautéed peppers and onions, with cavatappi pasta, green chili queso, served with Texas toast and garnished with pickled jalapeños		 $14.95
Feature $14.95
Prodigy Burger & Bar – Next To Burgers
Fries $3.00
Truffle Fries
Cooked in oil.		 $4.00
Sweet Potato $4.00
Tater Tots
Fried grated potatoes.		 $4.00
Onion Rings
Fried battered onion.		 $4.00
Cup Of Chili
Stew made with chili peppers or powder.		 $3.00
Cole Slaw $3.00
Broccoli $4.00
Fruit $4.00
Side Mac & Cheese $4.00
Side House Salad
Basic vegetable salad.		 $4.00
Side Caesar Salad
Green salad with caesar dressing and cheese.		 $4.00
Loaded Tater Tots $5.50
Loaded Fries $4.50
Loaded Sweet Fries $5.50
Asian Slaw $3.00
Prodigy Burger & Bar – Kids
Kid Grilled Cheese
American cheese sandwiched between two slices of Texas Toast		 $5.00
Kids Smash
A thinly smashed patty topped with American cheese and a side		 $5.00
Kids Cheese Curd
Our crispy cheese curds served with french fries and ranch dipping sauce		 $5.00
Kids Mac & Cheese $5.00
Kids Chicken Tenders
Our crispy tenders served with your choice of dipping sauce		 $5.00
Prodigy Burger & Bar – After Burgers
* ICE CREAM – SCOOP $2.25
PEANUT BUTTER CAKE $5.95
CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE MILK CAKE $5.95
Prodigy Burger & Bar – Buffets
Adult Buffet $16.95
Kids Buffet $8.95
Baby Buffet $0.00
Prodigy Burger & Bar – * Soft Drinks & Non-Alcohol Drinks
Coke $3.00
Diet Coke $3.00
Coke Zero $3.00
Sprite $3.00
Lemonade $3.00
Fanta Orange $3.00
Mr Pibb – Dr Pepper $3.00
Mellow Yellow $3.00
Ginger Ale $3.00
Rootbeer $3.00
Milk $3.00
Red Bull $4.50
Sugar Free Red Bull $4.50
Orange Juice $3.00
Sweet Tea $3.00
Ice Tea $3.00
Decaf Coffee $3.00
COFFEE $3.00
Prodigy Burger & Bar – * Milkshakes
* REGULAR MILKSHAKES $5.95
* KIDS MILKSHAKE $3.95

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

H. Yee
Sunday mid afternoon visit. Think they eere short staffed but our server tended to us the best he could. Very friendly . Mushroom burger on pretzel bun delicious almost a butter burger. Seasoned fries cooled perfectly and tadty crunchy. Strawberry shake had real strawberries blended in it. Others had loaded tater tots a bit decadent yummy, huge pork tenderloin sandwich, macaroni and cheese burger. All good!!!! Would return again, they have several large screen tv’s and a kids hame area.

… more

Ayperos
The staff is great here during the day, she’s happy to recommend plates to try and she always offers a drink to go which is really above and beyond. The smash burger with peanut butter and picked jalapenos is unexpected but incredibly good. I super enjoy that this restaurant has a diverse menu that you can’t just get anywhere else. Love stopping in at lunch for a bite to eat

… more

Jason Wuerfel
Friendly service, affordable prices, tasty food. Easy to get in and out, some free video games to keep the kids busy, Touch Tunes to play some of our favorite songs. I get the chorizo nachos almost every time. Yum!

… more

Mary D’Souza
Watched the game Saturday night with my sister and family. Amazing service and great atmosphere. Our server Maggie was the best! Dylan created an amazing cocktail I recommend the Strawberry Field of Fire. The “No Name” Burger was delicious! Management and staff were helpful and accommodating! I highly recommend!

… more

William Colwell
Ordered their tenderloin sandwich. Was thin, overcooked & crisp.

… more

Kevin Templin
I ordered the philly burger and the strawberry milkshake for take out. I had to order over the phone since this location hasn’t been added to the website yet to order online. Unfortunately you can’t order alcoholic milkshakes for take out, so will have to try that in person sometime.

… more

Michelle Karl
Went out to Prodigy yesterday with two friends. I got the no name signature burger with truffle fries, one of them ordered the Hoosier Daddy (fried pork tenderloin) and loaded fries and the other got a pineapple salsa burger (don’t remember the name) with a cup of fruit. We all got draft beers, and I loved the Rudy Red one (it is under Prodigy signature).

… more

Richard T
We stopped by after leaving Woodland. I’m not sure what to think about this place. Place was empty but nobody was in a hurry to help us. That immediately made me want to leave but my family was down for something new. Carey got our order for 2 beers, coke and cheese curds. We opted not to eat after looking at the menu. The manager was just kind of wandering around, never asked or even walked by the table. New place should have everyone greeting you with a smile, sharing great things about the place. We didn’t have a reason to stay or come back. Good luck!

… more

Sheryl
Meh, service was fine, but it wasn’t busy! , atmosphere sterile and unappealing, food average. Burger was avg and tenderloin was a thin, fried piece of somewhat flavorless pork. Smash burger also applied

… more

Lori Compton
The server was nice. The burger was very expensive for a steak n shake version. The fries were coated with an odd flavor. The onion rings were good.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch