Based on 627 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
18 Public Sq, Shelbyville, IN 46176
Phone: (317) 825-5220
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ashley
DELICIOUS!!! we stopped here on our way to Edinburgh and had some of the best food. Don’t skip the Tater Kegs or fried pickles- so good. Bacon Jam burger and buffalo chicken grilled cheese were mouth watering. We will definitely make our way back here!
… more
Edie Crone
Wow! We stopped after picking up a purchase in green castle. The food was such a high quality. We had bacon jam pizza, wings and loaded tots. And blue moon draft. Yum yum and more yum. Hope to be back.
… more
Mark Stargel
Went to try the tenderloin, and it was good. I would get it again, but there are better ones out there for sure. It was fairly thick and well breaded. I think it was slightly overcooked as it was very juicy, and the outside was darker than it should have been. I subbed up for $2 more to get the onion rings, which were very good.
… more
Donna Snelling
I’ve never had a pulled pork sandwich served to me ice cold. Had it been even a little warm, it would have been great. Onion rings were super greasy. And there was a mysterious ring in my cup. Thankfully, I had an excellent server (Casey).
… more
Justin Cotten
The hamburger was cooked to perfection and the onion rings were amazing!! the nachos and pork were good, and had plenty of toppings no problem. My only complaint was that they gave me a sour beer mug that smelled so bad.. but overall a great place to eat, good family atmosphere ,and good adult entertainment.
… more
Justine Ramirez
I recently suggested to my family that we dine at Pudders, a decision that has turned out to be my worst recommendation ever. Our experience was marred by atrocious service, with a wait time exceeding 50 minutes for our food. The quality of the food was equally disappointing, beginning with the beverages. My family and I ordered Pepsi, Dr. Pepper, and Sprite, but all the drinks seemed deficient in syrup, tasting off. I even exchanged mine for another soda, only to find it tasted nearly identical.
… more
Katie Schacher
When we first got there it took a good 2 minutes to even be acknowledged even though staff was walking around. A simple “we will be there in a minute” goes a long way. Our waitress was amazing. The food was really good in some aspects but really mediocre in others. Buns on the burgers were hard. Too many chips and not enough toppings. High prices.
… more
Sue Winslow
Independence Day! Wasn’t sure they would be open, thankfully they were. Weren’t extremely busy since it was getting close to time for fireworks for a few places. One waitress on duty but she did great. She kept up with the customers and kept the tables cleaned off. I’ve never had a meal that wasn’t good. I had a grilled tenderloin sandwich and these are always good. They are not paper thin so u can actually taste the meat. Any food we have had here at different times has always been tasty. Stop in and give them a try. You won’t be sorry.
… more
Cheri Miller
We got to the restaurant about 45 minutes before closing time and even though it was late, our food was excellent and the waitress provided great service without making us feel rushed. It has been great every time we’ve been there. Highly recommend.
… more
Elizabeth
Pudders used to be our favorite place in town. We went all the time and loved it. However, we got food poisoning from there four times in a row, and last time we went, my husband saw one of the cooks go into the bathroom wearing his apron!! Absolutely disgusting. Their standards seem to have gone down dramatically since this never happened under the previous owners. We are never ever going back.
… more
… View more