Filet mignon & prime rib plus cocktails served in a comfortable, Western-inspired atmosphere. Based on 699 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
710 Milford St, Salida, CO 81201
Phone: (719) 539-3059
Website: http://quincystavern.com/
Hours
| Friday | 4:30–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4:30–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4:30–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
4:30–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 4:30–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4:30–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4:30–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Bruce Almighty
Enjoyed a nice Father’s Day meal!
… more
Lisa Lynn
You know how you feel when going to a restaurant for the first time? This was our first time at Quincy’s and we were pleasantly surprised with our delicious steak dinner, the kind staff, and the prices…even the garnish was delightful! The margaritas were super tasty topped with an umbrella and more garnishes! Great place! We will be back for sure!
… more
JoLene Bernal
The atmosphere was nice, friendly diners and MOST staff. Our waitress was not the friendliest. After boasting of the great food and service, (I usually visit Quincy’s in Florence), my expectations were high. She was not friendly, never once came back after our filet came to ask if we needed anything. She didn’t ask if we wanted our margaritas frozen, rocks, salt or not, did not refill our water once, and did not include the lemon we requested. My mother asked another waitress for more sour cream, our waitress seemed inconvenienced and slid it on our table without saying a word. If I could have tipped the other waitresses for being more helpful, I would have. Our steak was cooked well and to desired temp and tasted delicious, and the salad….AHHMAZING, the potato was a bit hard though.
… more
Peter Juba
Food is good. Steak is the only choice for meat, that’s why we stopped here. My wife’s steak was real good where mine was a little tough with a little gristle running through it. Salad is always good and bread is very good. Baked potatoes only, so they were just fine for the meal.
… more
Susan Matejka
Made reservations for 6 people. Arrived and was seated in a rear booth. Very warm in that booth. It took 15 minutes to see the server. Server brought ice water. We asked for lemon. About 10 minutes later server showed up and took our orders. About 10 minutes later server brought salads. Then About 30 minutes later the dinner showed up. Our prime rib was just luke warm. Had to ask several times for more water. Service was completely slow. Knowing full and well that we were a larger party and expected a mandatory tip of 18%. No, what a shock. It was 25% for terrible service. Of course the server apologized for being so slow, “she was tired and needed to sit down several times to rest.” You can be slow and give bad service when you know you are going to get a 25% tip. Won’t fool me again.
… more
L D
Trash food and they over charge you for your order! Check your bill before you pay! I PAID in Cash and they still charged me a ” non cash payment fee” ! They also advertise 6oz steak for 13.99 and 9oz steak for 16.99 but they charge you 14.45 and 17.45 on your bill. The menu and all the adds on the building all say lower prices but they charge more! The food is disgusting. Overcooked dry unseasoned and inedible. The tables are dirty and the hostess also had snot running out of her nose when she greeted us at the door.
… more
Rebecca Duncan
We did carry out and the place was clean, attentive, courteous and the food was perfect.. really good. I’m not easily impressed but this steakhouse was so goo I will recommend it to everyone I know!!! Thank you
… more
Glenn Boyd
Great food. Service subpar. The table that came in after us, had their drink order taken, received their drinks, had their order taken, and received their salad before we were greeted by our server. It seemed the person who greeted and seated us (Cindy?) did not like the fact we were from out of town. This is a question she asks everyone as they come in due to the unique nature of their one item menu. Cindy seated us and told us the other server would serve us. Cindy slammed the other server with out of town guests and took all the locals. Our sever was sweet and tried hard but was just slammed and could not keep up.
… more
Tanya Maxwell
Food was good when we all finally received it (some were finished before one even got theirs the first time.). Waitress was new and training so we tried to be patient. Our waitress was actually very friendly and was trying her best. The main problem was another waitress, Cindy, who wanted to butt in where she had no business. She was extremely rude and even told us not to come back. She also told us that if we were going to have 10 people, we should have made a reservation. We had 7 adults, a 5 year old, 3 year old. 1 year old and infant.We were seated quickly, so I’m confused why she thought we needed a reservation. . If she thinks that number of people is too much for her, maybe she needs another profession. Again, she was not even our waitress, so she needed to just keep her mouth shut. I’m not going to hold this unprofessional employee against this business, but I do think the owner should know about her behavior. We have been patronizing Quincy’s for many years in Buena Vista, Leadville, and Salida, and have never had such an unpleasant experience.
… more
N. Gaymon
We loved this place. The prime rib was incredible, could’ve cut it with your finger. Loved the idea of a simple menu. Mike, our server, was wonderful. Price was right. Definitely worth it! Loved the historical aspect to the place.
… more
… View more