Based on 98 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
623 County Rd 539, New Egypt, NJ 08533
Phone: (609) 758-7788
Website: https://www.redstar2pizza.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Renée Bowe
The takeout here is the best in new Egypt. Food arrived hot. Large sandwiches are enough for two meals. Soup is good. Chicken parm and cheese steaks are good. Even the small house salad is good. They didn’t cheap out on ingredients and their food is basic, and good.
… more
Sarah Purcell
Taste wasn’t bad.. but the soup was about 3 full bites then the rest broth and minced veggies. Wasn’t super happy with the sampler platter either..proportions was a rip off with the chicken fingers for (3) chicken fingers (3) poppers (3)wings and (3) mozzarella sticks. Also ordered for delivery..was told 40 minutes…took about 1 and half hours. Which is cool if maybe a phone call was made or the food was hot on arrival.
… more
Kurt G
I have been going here about 4 years when I am in the area. This is hands down the best pizza in New Jersey. Perfect sauce, cheese, no flop, fast, service, and great prices. Very happy. The owners and staff are always really nice. I wish there was one of these in my town down in Atlantic County.
… more
Scott Cornish
Stopped here for the first time tonight after moving to the area from Louisiana last week, ordered the medium calzone with garlic and steak and 6 hot wings for about 20 bucks
… more
Randy Goos
It was nice I have been inside a couple of times but usually get delivery. I eat a lot of stuff there the stuff I like the most is The pizza, Burgers and the Cheesesteaks
… more
Natalie
Delicious! Nice staff too! Their salads are always fresh. Pizza is delicious (and I’m not a huge pizza lover) and wings are awesome! Subs are very good too!
… more
Michael Dalton
Great food great customer service. Only remark. The old way you used to do your garlic knots rocked. Decent amount of oil and lots of fresh garlic. If the change is due to increased prices, hey I get it. If it’s just bc you changed prep methods….may wanna revert to the old way.
… more
Rich Bendock
Normally, I am not in this area was passing by and pulled in to have a slice.. some of the best pizza ever had
… more
cassie
We order from here all the time. The prices are very reasonable, especially when you order pasta because they give you a huge portion along with salad and bread. The penne vodka is amazing as well as their buffalo wings. I like that they give you the sauce on the side. Pizza is also excellent. 5 stars!!!
… more
Big Wilson
The food is pretty good. But they tell you the food will be ready in 30 minutes when they mean a hour. Then you call to check and they say 5 minutes. So you head over and wait. Before you know it you sit in a parking lot for a half hour for no reason. This has happened three times straight. Pretty ridiculous and beyond rude. The couple other places on the same street at least give accurate times.
… more
… View more